Degrees and democracy rarely cross path

Questioning Smriti Irani’s qualifications for being an HRD minister is why we need to understand democracy all over again.

shivangi-narayan

Shivangi Narayan | May 28, 2014



Not even getting into the debate of “was Indira Gandhi qualified enough to be the Prime Minister of India” or “what qualifications does Sonia Gandhi have to be whatever”, the whole debate regarding Smriti Irani, current union HRD minister, and her qualifications for being an HRD minister should be viewed in the light of who is fit to administrate and not who is most educated.

India has been conceived on the principles of representative democracy, one where people elect their representative to make decisions on their behalf in the government.

These representatives need to be “qualified” enough to bring the issues of the people in the government. Nowhere does this entail the necessity of a PhD degree.

The beauty of a democracy is that it allows theoretically anyone to be a ruler. There are certain gatekeeping criteria of course, but they are purely logistical. Such as being able to be sober enough to sit through the proceedings of a parliament and be able to ask questions. This is because a democracy, which is “for the people and of the people” does not and cannot exclude those who did have the good fortune to afford an education.

An HRD minister’s job is a tough one, considering the current state of education in India. The universities are in a mess, the curriculum more so. There is no research and teachers and students do not have a common agenda saved to make the students ‘job ready’. Education spending is in shambles and organisations in need for certifying colleges for courses are busy filling their coffers. No Indian university is present in the top 100 and research, well, what is research? Incidentally, this is the mess that our previous HRD minister Kapil Sibal left us with. Sibal was a graduate from St Stephen’s College, University of Delhi (LLB and MA in history) and later completed an LLM from Harvard Law School.

No doubt the country needs an able person to deal with this mess right now but to judge the ability on the basis of her degrees, considering the status of the education system, is not just ironical but hypocritical. These are the same crop of people who have seen the Steve Jobs Harvard commencement address 1000 times and lauded his lack of formal education. Many of them in fact attribute his success to lack of high profile degrees. Bill Gates is another one who gets the same reverence from our countrymen and women.

Lets all hail the lords of double standards. For the uninitiated to the workings of Indian government, ministers are generally flanked by experts, consultants and group of people who help them in governance activities. Just as Omar Abdullah tweeted today, coal ministers do not have to be miners and civil aviation ones do not have to be pilots. PhD also need not be the qualifying criteria for an HRD minister.

Some websites have reported discrepancies in Irani’s educational qualifications in her affidavits from 2004 and 2014. Now that might be an issue worth considering. What her qualifications are, is sadly not.

 

Comments

 

Other News

Manufacturing will remain dark horse for economy: Niti Aayog expert

Manufacturing will remain the dark horse for the Indian economy, especially as labour-intensive industries shift from China, writes Sukhgeet Kaur, director, project appraisal and management division, Niti Aayog in an official

The un-importance of being Pravin Togadia

Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) working president Pravin Togadia is in the news after a long time. This week, Togadia went `missing` for an entire day as the Gujarat and Rajasthan police were on the lookout for him, arrest warrant in hand. Togadia was later brought to a hospital in an unconscious state. At a p

Confused signals

Of late, there have been some anxious moments for broadcasters and no one knows where it’s been coming from, and why it’s happening. For starters, the ministry of information and broadcasting is the licensor for TV channels, in two categories: (i) news and current affairs (&lsquo

Should there be a “rational, orderly and transparent system” to allocate cases to different benches of the Supreme Court?

Should there be a “rational, orderly and transparent system” to allocate cases to different benches of the Supreme Court?

Here`s why providing milk through PDS is unrealistic

Milk is one liquid that usually moves upwards, at least in economic terms. The poor can’t afford this important source of nutrition. But imagine children getting milk in schools as part of mid-day meals, and the poor getting some from public distribution system (PDS) shops. That is precisely what the

Here’s why TRAI slashed international termination charges

The telecom regulator`s decision to cut international termination charges (ITC) to 30 paise from 53 paise will hit the incumbent operators (Airtel, Idea and Vodafone) the most. At present, the annual revenue of the industry from ITC is approximately Rs 4,500 crore. It may also, as incumbents say, impact go

Current Issue

Current Issue

Video

CM Nitish’s convoy attacked in Buxar

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter