Why Chaturvedi’s removal as AIIMS CVO defies logic

Contrary to Harsh Vardhan’s claim, he was eligible, and his appointment was perfectly legal

pankaj

Pankaj Kumar | August 23, 2014




Contrary to health minister Harsh Vardhan’s claim, whistle-blower officer Sanjiv Chaturvedi’s appointment as chief vigilance officer of the All-India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) was not illegal and the central vigilance commission (CVC) had legitimized it too.

Also read: Why Sanjiv Chaturvedi was shown the door

The Indian forest service (IFS) officer of Haryana cadre, known for his anti-corruption moves, had apparently earned the ire of political masters in the state, when the centre intervened and made him the CVO at the prestigious institute in the capital two years ago. He, however, has been removed the post earlier, once again apparently because he had ruffled feathers of those close to new political masters. Harsh Vardhan told reporters on August 21, “Chaturvedi was not eligible for the post he was holding. We were told that without the approval of the CVC, nobody can be assigned the post of CVO anywhere.”

However, facts are contrary to the health minister’s claims.

1. It has been alleged that Chaturvedi, a deputy secretary, cannot hold the post which is meant for a joint secretary level officer. However, para 2.3 of the CVC manual clearly mentions that a deputy secretary rank officer can very well become the CVO in ministries or departments.

2. CVC did indeed raise an objection to Chaturvedi’s appointment as the AIIMS CVO in 2012 itself, but the health ministry had then given a strong reply, pointing out that there was nothing irregular in the decision. The ministry had argued that the appointment was done as per section 6(2)(c) of the AIIMS Rules of 1958. Moreover, AIIMS, as an education and research organization, is not included in the list of commercial organisations – only for which a prior approval of CVC is mandatory for the appointment of a CVO as per the CVC manual.

3. Governance Now has a copy of the file notings by health secretary Luv Verma (dated May 23) and then health secretary PK Pradhan (way back in 2012) that the decision was taken by the AIIMS general body, institute body (IB), and the standing finance committee (SFC), that this issue was already settled, and the then health minister (Ghulam Nabi Azad) had twice expressed his approval. These statements communicated to CVC as well.

4. CVC then did not raise any objection again. In its correspondence, it repeatedly addressed Chaturvedi as CVO. In one instance, CVC in fact told AIIMS on October 4, 2012 that though Chaturvedi was part of the procurement/tender works in the institute, he should be relieved of that duty because he was CVO and this might lead to a conflict of interest.

5. Indeed, CVC had never objected to the appointment of CVO though the deputy director of administration used to hold this post before Chaturvedi, leading to a conflict of interest as all the tender/procurement were approved by deputy director (administration).

6. Also, the vigilance panel also accepted all reports Chaturvedi sent to it as CVO, and did not object even when he reported the alleged irregularities committed by two former deputy directors (administration) of AIIMS, Shailesh Yadav and Vineet Chaudhary

Comments

 

Other News

Stories you must read over the weekend

Joseph A Cannataci is the UN’s first and current special rapporteur for the right to privacy appointed by the Human Rights Council (HRC) in July 2015. His appointment came with growing global concerns about threats to privacy in the digital age where governments and big corporations collect mass da

When Jaitley sparred with Chidambaram

This is what Arun Jaitley had to say:   We want to take action which may either want to have an assault on what is the shadow economy or the parallel economy itself. Let us take this example of what everybody has commented on Section 132. Section 132, in simple,

One country, one tax from July 1

 After an intense seven-hour-long debate in the Lok Sabha, the cabinet gave a nod to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Bill. A green signal has also been given to the four crucial supplementary bills; Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Bill, Integrated GST (IGST) Bill, Compensation GST (compensation

Indian team’s internet access to villages gets global recognition

 A successful effort to take high speed internet to over six lakh Indian villages by an IIT Bombay team failed to get support from the government. But, the same indigenous television white space technology developed by the team has now won Mozilla Corporation’s ‘equal rating innovation cha

DJB unveils Yamuna river project

Delhi Jal Board, in collaboration with University of Virginia on Thursday unveiled the Yamuna River Project with a symposium cum exhibition as a part of the overall effort to map out an expansive, multidisciplinary prescription to clean Yamuna. The discussion opened on the lines of eradicati

UJALA scheme: Over 22 crore LED bulbs distributed

  Over 22 crore LED bulbs have been distributed by Energy Efficiency Services Limited (EESL) under UJALA scheme, union minister Piyush Goyal informed the Lok Sabha.   The minister said that the National LED programme, called Unnat Jyoti by Affordable LEDs for

Video

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter