Chidambaram says didn’t get letter, Vinod Rai says didn’t send any

“Surprised” at former FM’s statement on letter on audit of PPP projects, ex-CAG tells Governance Now

shreerupa

Shreerupa Mitra-Jha | September 17, 2014


Former comptroller and auditor general (CAG) of India Vinod Rai
Former comptroller and auditor general (CAG) of India Vinod Rai

Former comptroller and auditor general (CAG) of India Vinod Rai has denied writing any letter to former finance minister P Chidambaram on audit of public-private partnership (PPP) projects coming under the CAG’s purview.

In a statement issued on Tuesday (September 16), Chidambaram said, "I have read some interviews given by Vinod Rai where he has remarked that letters written by him to Dr Manmohan Singh, Shri Pranab Mukherjee and me on the subject of audit of PPP projects did not receive any response…. (But) I do not recall any letter addressed to me by the CAG on the subject. I have since confirmed that no letter was addressed to me.”

But Rai today told Governance Now: “I don’t think I have said anywhere that I have written to Mr Chidambaram. I was surprised when I saw the statement [of Chidambaram] today. In September 2009, we made a presentation to Mr Pranab Mukherjee (then finance minister) on the fact that our Audit Act is of 1971. There was no such thing as PPP or the 73rd or 74th amendment.”

He said the panchayati raj institutions  “came much later”, while the special societies for NRHM were “non-existent”. “So he [Pranab Mukherjee] immediately said we should write to him and suggest the amends that we need to make. In November 2009, I wrote to him [Mukherjee] on the amendments [for the Audit Act]. In fact, we did not suggest amends but a repealing of the [Audit] Act. They got back to us suggesting that [the repealing] would be a long-drawn process [and asked us] to suggest some amends.

“In 2010, we suggested that, too. So it [the issue of PPP audit] is part of that. I don’t recall personally writing to Mr Chidambaram. He [Chidambaram] says he has verified, and I was looking for what statement of mine Mr Chidambaram has referred to. Yes, I have written to Mr Mukherjee originally for the repealing, and then amendments. If a reminder has gone to him [Chidambaram], then I do not know.”

Rai’s book Not Just An Accountant, which reveals purported scams and financial transgressions during his innings as the 11th CAG from 2008 till his retirement in May 2013, has ruffled many a feather in the Congress. The book will be launched today.

The exclusive interview with Rai will appear in the October 1-15 issue of Governance Now.

Comments

 

Other News

"We will be involving community volunteers to effectively police the park"

The work on Sunder Nursery, a lush green refuge from urban chaos in central Delhi, started in 2007, when the Aga Khan Trust for Culture (AKTC) undertook a conservation and renewal proje

Namami Gange: Of promises and achievements

Twenty-six-year-old Surender is a ferryman in Varanasi. Surender and his family own three boats and their livelihood is dependent on taking tourists on a joyride on the Ganga. Recalling the time when he used to ride a boat with his grandfather, Surender says, “At that time Ganga water was so

Trouble on the metro line

The storm is yet to die out over the Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited`s (MMRC) taking over 30 hectares of the famed Aarey colony, a green belt of mumbai, when another application has come in from MMRC demanding another 12,000 sq metres of land. The colony in Goregaon, inaugurated in 195

"Govt must allow open spaces which can serve as lungs for the city"

For years we had a tradition in Mumbai, particularly for all the trunk roads, to be avenues (boulevards). Though we continue to have trees in some parts of Mumbai, the fact is that we appear to have given up on this. Having trees and plants on streets and roads not only provides shade but also absorbs poll

Dry ATMs: Rahul takes a dig at govt

As media reports spoke of ATMs across the country going dry, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi took a dig at the government even as the finance ministry reviewed the situation and blamed it on “unusual demand for cash”. “Desh ke ATM sab phir se khali, Benkon ki haalat kya kar da

A hundred years ago: Lessons in civility

Gandhi was, as usual, busy on several fronts in April 1918. The previous year had witnessed his frst major satyagraha after returning to India, in Champaran. The previous month had witnessed his frst major political campaign in the chosen hometown of Ahmedabad, intervening in the mill-workers strike. B

Current Issue

Current Issue

Video

CM Nitish’s convoy attacked in Buxar

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter