Union Law Ministry says it keeps no such record though it is in public domain
Danish Raza | February 5, 2010
The central government does not maintain any record of cases where judges and chief justices were superseded in their elevation to the supreme court or as chief justices of high courts.
This has been revealed by the Ministry of Law and Justice in response to an RTI application filed by Delhi resident Subhash Candra Agrawal.
In his RTI application to the President’s secretariat filed in December 2009, Agrawal had sought these details and other information like the name of judges whose files were at least once returned by the president for being elevated to the apex court.
The President secretariat transferred his application to the Ministry of Law and Justice which, in its reply, dated February 2, 2010, said that “no such list maintained by the department and therefore, no information can be furnished.”
Agrawal is surprised by the reply. “A lot of such cases are reported by the media. This is something that the media and members of the bar council must be having. But interestingly, our Union government does not find necessary to preserve this data”, said he.
“In November 2009, Jurist Fali S Nariman delivered a speech at the National Law Universit, Delhi. He mentioned the case of Justice AK Patnaik who was superseded three times before being finally elevated to apex court but only after retirement of a particular collegium-member”, he added.
Agrawal has filed first appeal with the President’s Secetariat.
As India gears up to celebrate its 71st Republic Day on January 26, it will host Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro as the chief guest of the event that marks the day when the country formally adopted the Constitution as the guiding document. This will be Bolsonaro’s maiden visit, which he would like
With the outbreak of Coronavirus reported from China, India has started taking precautionary measures, and begun screening passengers of selected flights. “As of 21st January, a total of 43 flights and 9156 passengers have been screened for novel Coronavirus illness. Till now, no case
Every middle-class Indian dreams of a home coupled withlanded property to live off the rent. However, large initial investment, particularly inmetros, and low yields ensure that real estate is out of the reach of the common man. A return of 7-8 percent from commercial properties is considered highly commen
The Maharashtra State Election Commission has urged the residents to take advantage of the ongoing Electors Verification Programme (EVP) and register their names along with those of the members of their families in the electoral rolls. The drive, which started on November 11, 2019, will continue till Febru
The budget season is here, and the annual document has gone to print, beginning the lock-in period till its presentation in parliament on February 1. The Halwa ceremony, marking the commencement of the budget printing process, was held in North Block Monday morning in the presence of finance
Investment banker, venture capitalist and stock-market expert Vallabh Bhansali is the co-founder and chairman of Enam Group, a pioneering equity research company in the country. He is a promoter of spiritual and cultural traditions and also an expert on development economics, behavioural science and co