Judicial appointments bill passed by RS too: what it means

The bill proposes to replace the collegium system of selection of judges to the supreme court and the high court by a six-member body

deevakar

Deevakar Anand | August 14, 2014



In what is seen as a big victory for the Narendra Modi government, the Rajya Sabha on Thursday (August 14) passed the national judicial appointments commission bill, 2014. The bill, along with a constitutional amendment bill, was passed in Lok Sabha on Wednesday. 

The bill proposes to replace the collegium system of selection of judges to the supreme court and the high courts by a six-member body consisting of the chief Justice of India, two senior-most judges of the SC, union law minister, and two other eminent persons picked by a panel comprising the prime minister, leader of the opposition and the chief Justice of India himself.

Like in the lower house, the judicial appointments commission bill was passed by voice vote in Rajya Sabha. The Lok Sabha had passed the constitution (121st amendment) bill, 2014 through a vote – 367 in favor and none against it.

The collegium system of selection of judges has recently come under scanner in the light of corruption charges against SC and HC judges. The recent case of former solicitor general Gopal Subramanium's elevation as a SC judge as proposed by the collegium was rejected by the government leading to an ugly face off.

The new system of selection of judges in the higher judiciary would entail greater transparency and accountability. The critics, however, say it would lead to more political intervention in the process and undermine the independence of judiciary.

What is the new system, the proposed national judicial appointments commission?
The bill proposes to replace the collegium system of selection of judges to the supreme court and the high court by a six-member body consisting of the chief justice of India, two senior-most judges of the SC, union law minister, and two other eminent persons picked by a panel comprising the prime minister, leader of the opposition and the chief Justice of India himself.

Five of the six members of the panel must agree on a name for final appointment.

What is the collegium system of selection of judges?
Post 1993, the selection of judges to the high court and the supreme court are done through the collegium system. Under the collegium system, the SC judges are selected by a panel comprising the chief justice of India and four senior judges of the same court. In case of the high court judges’ appointments are made after a collegium of the particular HC proposes the name which then is cleared by a three member SC collegium headed by CJI. One of the other two judges in the panel must have been associated with that particular HC in the past.
On October 6, 1993, the Collegium system was brought through a nine-judge bench decision of the SC to give primacy to CJI in such appointments.

How the judges were selected prior to 1993

The appointments were made by the law ministry in consultation with the judiciary.

Arguments in favor of the proposed judicial appointments commission
The collegium system of selection of judges has recently come under scanner in the light of corruption charges against SC and HC judges. The recent case of former solicitor general Gopal Subramanium's elevation as a SC judge as proposed by the collegium was rejected by the government leading to a face off.
The government and those in support of the new arrangement argue that the collegium had become too opaque. The new system will bring more transparency and accountability in appointments.

Argument against it
CJI RM Lodha has defended the collegium system. On Monday, during a hearing on a writ petition questioning the reported elevation of Karnataka HC judge K.L. Manjunath as chief justice of the Punjab and Haryana HC, he remarked that there were vicious efforts to tarnish judiciary’s image through the questioning of the collegium.
Others against the new appointment commission view it as a compromise on judiciary’s independence. They believe it would lead to political interferences in the process and that would be motivated.

Comments

 

Other News

Reform first, privatise later: Bibek Debroy to railways

Before privatisation and corporatisation, the Indian Railways need to undertake major reforms including commercial accounting, decentralisation and human resource among others, said Bibek Debroy, economist and member, NITI Aayog at Railways Reforms and Governance Conclave organised by Governance Now on Fri

NTPC plans for 32 GW installed capacity via renewable sources

NTPC Ltd has raised Rs 2,000 crore through green masala bonds in overseas market under its $4 billion medium term note programme, union minister Piyush Goyal informed the Lok Sabha. The proceeds of these bonds will be used for financing renewable energy projects in accordance with applicable

Big test for Palanisami

It’s been over a month since the power centre in Tamil Nadu shifted from Poes Garden to Greenways Road in Chennai. The thirteenth chief minister of the state, Edappadi K Palanisami, is taking baby steps to bring about a change in the state which has been battling political uncertainty for the past fe

A trowelful of empowerment

When her husband died last year, 60-year-old Chakkamma was not sure whether she would be able to have some money of her own: she has a son who looks after her, but she wanted to maintain a degree of independence. Opportunity came knocking when the Tamil Nadu government, as part of its Pudhu Vaazhvu (or new

Should Shiv Sena MP Ravindra Gaikwad be arrested for assaulting an Air India employee?

Should Shiv Sena MP Ravindra Gaikwad be arrested for assaulting an Air India employee?

Railways suffered over Rs 33,000 crore loss on passenger service: CAG

  The Railways was unable to meet its operational cost of passenger and other coaching services. During 2014-15, there was a loss of Rs 33,821.70 crore on passenger and other coaching services. The freight services earned a profit of Rs 38,312.59 crore which indicated that 88.28 percent

Video

जानिए क्यों ये किसान अर्धनग्न अवस्था में बैठे हैं जंतर मंतर पर

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter