Pulok Chatterjee sat on Bhagvad Gita issue for six whole weeks
Wonder what Obama or the King of Saudi Arabia would do in a visit if an Indian court had cooked the goose for banning their holy book
View Image Gallery
Author Profile
Bansal is CEO of India Strategy Group, Hammurabi & Solomon Consulting, an HBS alum, and a student of Indian governance
My story doesn’t start with the pandemonium in parliament over the Bhagwad Gita, but seven weeks before that.
In the third week of October, I received a call from my friend in Russia Bhakti Vigyana Goswami. Goswami who heads Iskcon in Russia is known to me since my days in India TV, when Moscow civic authorities razed his Krishna temple to the ground citing some strange arguments. To its credit, my then organisation played the footage of that video to chilling effect and it was hard to remain unmoved after watching it. SMSes poured in in the thousands. Hema Malini lent her voice in support. And our ratings went up.
Also read these related stories:
Govt wakes up, takes Gita issue with Russian authorities
Embassy seeks federal officials' favourable and positive intervention: Ambassador
Russia expresses sadness over Bhagwad Gita controversy
Taking holy scripture to court "inadmissible"
PIL seeks Centre's intervention in case against Gita in Russia
But those weren’t the days of the social media and the issue got buried after a few days though not before prime minister Manmohan Singh on a visit to Russia at that time reportedly made a mention of this to Vladimir Putin.
Truth being stranger than fiction, I found myself listening in horror to Goswami’s narrative after so much water had flown in the Yamuna and the Moskva. That this time not just a Krishna Temple, but the source of his entire philosophy, the Bhagwad Gita, is facing a ban in a kangaroo court. Since there was no television channel to back us, nor even video footage which channels demand before affording a minute’s coverage, we decided to do what my law firm and advocacy firms know best. We followed the rule book and invoked prime minister Manmohan Singh.
To ensure this didn’t get lost in a mountain of paper, we made a petition to the PM’s highly-regarded principal secretary Pulok Chatterji and had it signed by Gopal Krishna Goswami, a top functionary of Iskcon. The letter, which is attached (see below), explained the issue in brief and also provided detailed annexes of the injustice being done to the sacred text. To make things even simpler for Chatterji, who we realised was really busy, an expansive translation of the court proceedings (attached) was provided too. The entire docket running into a few dozen pages was delivered at PMO ,as also to the principal secretary’s email ID. With a touch of paranoia, the docket was also hand delivered at Chatterji’s home address, including by a comical error to the residence occupied by TKA Nair, the previous incumbent now advisor to PM.
A similar protocol was endeavoured for four key people on cc., ie, UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi, commerce and industry minister Anand Sharma, external affairs minister SM Krishna, and national security advisor Shiv Shankar Menon. It was hoped that diligent follow-up will ensure that at least one of these people will understand that doing business with Russia will be difficult once India’s social media stream discovers how a state prosecutor is leading the charge against the Bhagvad Gita.
But until a newswire got hold of the story while accompanying the PM on his trip to Russia, not one of these notables batted an eyelid. The only one who claimed he’ll do something was Ajai Malhotra, India’s envoy to Moscow. One of his boys, with one eye on the prime minister’s trip to Russia, summoned Goswami and mentioned that they have advice from 10 Janpath (not PMO, by the way) to do something.``But don’t do anything while we mull over what to do!’’ the interlocutor told Goswami.
So, we waited and waited in hope, while Anand Sharma made yet another pilgrimage to Moscow in November and the top brass in the prime minister’s establishment got busy chasing sexier stuff like warships and fighter aircraft.
I realise Sharma’s predicament or Pulok’s or even Dr Singh’s. I realise a book isn’t worth the weight of deals and contracts. But isn’t it Krishna who told us to look beyond material things?…Here’s what he meant.
I wonder what Obama or the King of Saudi Arabia would do in a visit if an Indian court, by no means an agent of the state like its Russian counterparts are, had cooked the goose for banning their holy book. Do you?


-AndrewYule.jpg)


Wonder if Mr chatterjee would have got the guts to do so shud it have concerned the Holy Quran OR the Bible. All this for the pseudo secularist of this country AND their srevants like Mr Chatterjee. Anyways Pulok Chatterjee has been brought in the PMO to keep a watch on Manmohan Singh for his 'MADAM' whose lap dog he is - one amongst many..... .
India is NOT a Hindu state.
Nor Hinduism is the 'state religion' of India.
Go to Nepal (Hindu nation).
Or take your caste share of land FC(5-15%), BC(50%), SC/ST/MC(35-45%) from India as per "Communal Award" and build your own nation.
90% of corrupt money is with the Forward caste leeches.
Tell them to take their 'merit' and their caste share of land FC(5-15%), BC(50%), SC/ST/MC(35-45%) from India as per "Communal Award" and build their own 'corruption free' nation.
(2011)
Black Money in Swiss banks = $1.4 trillion (FC)
Goa mining scam = $700 million (FC)
Noida Corporation farm land scandal = $40 million (SC)
Bellary mines scandal = $3.2 billion (FC)
BL Kashyap EPFO Scam = $118 million (FC)
Hasan Ali Khan = $8 billion (MC)
ISRO-Devas = $300 million (FC)
Cash-for-votes = $715,000 (FC)
(2010)
2G spectrum scam/Radia Tapes = $6.9 billion (BC)
Adarsh Housing Society (FC)
Commonwealth Games = $15.5 billion (FC)
LIC Housing Loan scam = $200 million (FC)
Belekeri port = $12 billion (FC)
Lavasa = $80 million (FC)
Uttar Pradesh Food Grain = $44 billion (BC)
APIIIC = $2 billion (FC)
IPL Cricket = $8 billion (FC)
(2009)
Madhu Koda = $800 million (SC)
UIDAI = $1 billion (FC)
Vasundhara Raje land scam = $4.4 billion (FC)
(2008)
Satyam = $1 billion (FC)
(2006)
Scorpene Deal = $10 million (FC)
(2005)
Oil-for-food programme (Natwar Singh) = $10 billion (FC)
(2004)
Gegong Apang PDS = $200 million (ST)
(2003)
Taj corridor = $44 million (SC)
(2002)
Kargil Coffin (MC)
(2001)
Ketan Parekh = $200 million (FC)
Barak Missile = $200 million (FC)
Calcutta Stock Exchange = $2 million (FC)
(1997)
Cobbler scam = $214 million (FC)
Sukh Ram = $5 million (FC)
SNC Lavalin = $10 million (FC)
Advani Hawala = $18 million (FC)
(1996)
Bihar fodder = $211 million (BC)
C R Bhansali = $200 million (FC)
(1995)
Telgi scam = $4.46 billion (MC)
(1992)
Harshad Mehta = $800 million (FC)
(1989)
Bofors = $400 million (FC)
(1971)
Nagarwala = $1 million (FC)
Haridas Mundhra = $10 million (FC)
Mr. Rohit Bansal / copy Editor: Please correct the line "...when Moscow civic authorities raised his Krishna temple ..." as "... when Moscow civic authorities RAZED his Krishna temple ..."
From: @equateall
Done. Thanks for pointing out.
MM Singh is a Globalist,member,Club Of Rome.The Globalists, simply are against the majority Community of any nation.This is DELIBERATE.
Pulak Bhai has not been brought there to serve as professional but as honest order-doer for the big bosses. Who does not know in the administration that what is the background of these coveated job holders? Where are the professionals? The story of Gita is not new.Now the challange is how to make people realise the need for identity of the nation? While now in Germany on Study.research mission I really feel India was better known when it was not independant. It seems lot has been lost and for that civil services are more to be blamed. It is here Pulak Bhai type people must do some search as to whom will they serve all the time and at what cost to the nation? Let us use right to information to find out why this letter was unattended for such a long time on his table?
Post new comment