Why Sarkar isn’t a national icon

Despite delivering good governance, Manik Sarkar is not even a bleep on the radar of the national consciousness

Vivek Kumar | August 9, 2013

To understand the establishment and evolution of a charismatic personality in India, we have to approach the issue from religious, historical and contemporary politics perspectives.

Going by the paradigm of religion, charisma can be located within the religion of the majority and within the larger geographical area which is Aryavarta, or north India. This is because of the majority religion’s staunch assertion that civilisation was born here; hence, individuals fulfilling both conditions (belonging to the majority religion and from the region where it is most dominant) automatically gain charisma. The phenomenon of eulogising people is seen to emerge here.

Thus, if the said personality is located in polity and governance and fulfills the two criteria, then it is very easy to gain charisma. Examples are Jawaharlal Nehru, often termed a visionary, Indira Gandhi, for whom the slogan “India is Indira, Indira is India” was coined, and Atal Bihari Vajpayee, anointed Yug Purush by the right. (Note: There have been, undoubtedly, instances of personality cults of leaders in the southern states. But they have remained restricted to their respective states and have failed to be a national icon.)

To understand the issue of charisma of leaders from a historical perspective, we have to look back at our colonial history. The British developed an administration that was bureaucratic, systematic and militaristic, with a proper structure and hierarchy. However, the political leadership never had any institutional development and location.

Coming to contemporary politics, it is obvious that the polity has become broader than before. However, with the rise of coalition politics, ideology has been a casualty. With ideological stands modified or entirely dispensed with to suit allies, there is very little scope for leaders with ideologies to shine in the national spectrum. Marxists had to leave staunch Left stands at home while in coalition with the Congress, the JD(U) toned down secular rhetoric to stay in the NDA, as did the BJD in Odisha. In such cases, people following party agenda are sidelined to keep fragile alliances going. So individual leaders toe a common line, failing which they are not brought to national attention by their own parties.

Also, the emergence of a pan-India charismatic personality has been systematically stifled by the leadership in Delhi.

Thus, despite doing good work in Tripura, Manik Sarkar finds no place in the political centrestage as he is neither from north India nor from a polity which is essentially BJP or Congress. He hails from the Northeast, which is far removed from the imagination of the so-called ‘mainland’ India.

Failing to meet these important conditions, rising in consciousness and consideration of the people outside Tripura is difficult for Sarkar.

Another important factor behind Sarkar not becoming a national icon is the lack of coverage in the media. While the mainstream media is interested in the market, Left Front politics has historically been media-shy. Sarkar and his politics does not have any market orientation, therefore the media does not give him preference, like it gives to other regional leaders who are pro-market.

For example, Narendra Modi, who provides largesse to corporate houses with interests in media but is unable to give land for a central university in Gujarat, becomes a huge media success.

In the larger context, success of neo-liberalism and its propaganda globally has decreased the appeal of socialist or Marxist ideologies, which does not go very well with forces of liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation that look at development only in a certain form. Hence, if the governance and development model is not tailored in that model, it fails to hold interest.
(As told to Shivangi Narayan)

Kumar is associate professor at the Centre for Study of Social Systems, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi



Other News

A blueprint of India’s economic future: From a former RBI governor

From Dependence to Self-Reliance: Mapping India’s Rise as a Global Superpower By Bimal Jalan Rupa Publications, 184 pages, Rs 695 Bimal Jalan, a former governor of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), has been one of our finest commentators on econom

Carbon neutrality: distant dream or a possible future?

While many countries have been chasing to reach the carbon neutral status, only a few seem to be living up to their pledges as of now. The famous ’Paris Agreement’ of 2015 was glorified and celebrated that finally 196 countries have united with an intent to mitigate and reduce the greenhouse ga

Agnipath: benefits and challenges on the path ahead

The government this week announced the Tour of Duty or `Agnipath` scheme for the recruitment of soldiers in the armed forces. Under this scheme new soldiers will be recruited only for four years. This radical and far-reaching scheme has attracted mixed reactions from various quarters. While some officials

Connecting credit card with UPI: What it means for you

UPI has become an integral part of our daily lives now. We use it to buy groceries, we use it to send money to friends and family, we use it to purchase tickets, book shows, pay the cab driver, and a whole host of other things due to the ease and availability of such a platform at our fingertips. The best

Gandhi’s letters to his youngest son also hold his aspirations for nation

Scorching Love: Letters from Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi to his son, Devadas By Gopalkrishna Gandhi and Tridip Suhrud Oxford University Press, 528 page, Rs 1495 Gandhi’s era happened to be an era when letter-writing was a primary mode of communica

‘In Mumbai, society, police forces triumphed over Covid-19’

Crediting the citizens of Mumbai for coming forward to help the police in combating the crisis situation due to Covid-19, Mumbai police commissioner Sanjay Pandey has said that Mumbai Police lost quite a few policemen during the pandemic but cumulative efforts, with citizens working hand in hand with the p

Visionary Talk: Sanjay Pandey, Mumbai Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Current Issue


Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter