Aadhaar a national danger?

Former Defence Officer says the data base has become an exploitation tool in the hands of corrupt

geetanjali

Geetanjali Minhas | January 15, 2013



In India, when the National Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) Bill, 2010, was presented to parliamentary standing committee on finance chaired by Yashwant Sinha it was called ill conceived, directionless and threat to national security.

Colonel Thomas, a former defense services officer and missile scientist was speaking at a seminar, “UID/Aadhaar: Medicine worst than disease”, organised by Money Life Foundation in Mumbai.

Thomas said that private foreign companies with links to intelligence agencies will have access to data. Explaining this he said that the contract for UID has been given to Satyam Mahindra and Morpho L1 ID Solutions, a company created after merger of two US companies- Visage and Identics.

Visage had contract for driving licences in Georgia, US. Due to defaults, the contract was terminated. Later when CIA and FBI took over and merged the companies into L1 Identity Solutions, it received many US government contracts. Later they merged it with a French company called Safran and while they still have operations in US, L1 Identity solutions is now called Morpho Trust.

Both Satyam Mahindra and Morpho Trust, the erstwhile L1 Identity Solutions, are subsidiaries of Safran, a company working on intelligence and biometrics in France. This company is now providing all biometric technology equipment to India. Against procurement norms, it has two subsidiaries competing for same product and secondly all data base of the country will be available to these foreign companies with links to intelligence agencies abroad. They are also providing same services to Nadra, a Pakistani National Identity Database.

Further pointing to perils of linking UID database to banks, he said the moment you link UIDAI database into your bank account you are introducing into transaction a third party (whom you cannot identify), i.e. the person who controls your database.

“If your account is hacked who do you complain to as the bank will not take responsibility. Unfortunately the draconian draft bill does not mention who will take up responsibility. In fact if the UID has not been used for three years the draft bill declares the person nonexistent,” he pointed.

Calling it a national danger, the former head of Missile Manufacturing Facilities at Defence Research Organization said, “Biometrics is fallible. Finger prints at best is corroborative evidence in court of law. There is a lobby at work that sells equipments and technology. All that has failed.”

“As database increases, the error rates increase exponentially. In fact UIDAI’s own biometrics standard committee has admitted that the error rates could be 15 percent. You can calculate this with 15 percent of India’s population. The control passed away from you to a system which is impersonal,” he said.

While demonstrating how finger prints can be faked, Jude D Souza, an expert on design and development of microprocessor based embedded electronic systems, explained how the machines are incapable of detecting the fundamental foundation of biometrics i.e. live detection. He showed how a Fevicol mould can be used for authentication.

“Finger prints can differ or vary due to ageing, cuts and bruises, skin ailments, environmental limitations, dry skin, water logged hands, device variations,” D Souza said.

Sucheta Dalal of Money life Foundation informed that across the country UID is being challenged in different courts. While Colonel Thomas has filed a case in Bangalore, a judge has filed a case in Delhi High Court. Another case filed against it in the Bombay High Court is to come up for hearing soon.

Comments

 

Other News

Ram Nath Kovind to be India’s next president

 India’s 14th president is going to be former Bihar governor Ram Nath Kovind, a dalit. He triumphed over former Lok Sabha speaker Meira Kumar in the vote count that took place on Thursday.   Kovind succeeds Pranab Mukherjee, who demits office on July 25. He becomes the

At JNU, all that is beautiful and “solid has melted into the air”…

Dear “Professor” Vice Chancellor,    When the clamour is made all around us, and rightly so, about the condition of growing degeneration of quality education in the higher institutions of learning in our country, you have justly – for which you must be

Making words count

In 2016, 38 bills were enacted in parliament. During that year, on average, the time spent on legislative debate (without interruptions) was 23 percent in the Lok Sabha and 16 percent in the Rajya Sabha (calculated from the PRS Legislative Research data).  Time is, however, just one measure

Business goes north

Tyre manufacturer MRF (originally Madras Rubber Factory), which enjoys instant brand recall thanks to the presence of its logo on cricket superstar Virat Kohli’s bat, figures among the most prominent industries in Tamil Nadu. But the state does not figure in its future plans. Like another TN industry

Do you think the Central Water Commission needs to take on the responsibility of irrigation governance?

Do you think the Central Water Commission needs to take on the responsibility of irrigation governance?

Debating the idea of privacy

Is right to privacy a fundamental right? The Supreme Court on Wednesday heard arguments on the contentious issue linked to the Aadhaar debate. Here`s how the issue has been addressed by different countries, with the first reference dating to 1890.   The Supreme Court on Tuesday s





Video

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter