Recalling a time when BJP opposed GST

GST will roll out from July 1

GN Bureau | June 29, 2017


#tax laws   #RBI   #Goods and Services Tax   #GST   #BJP   #Arun Jaitley  


The Bharatiya Janata Party is today going to town over the Goods and Services Tax (GST). But, there was a time in the recent past when the party opposed it tooth and nail, with the Gujarat government, then led by Narendra Modi, describing it as “retrograde in nature and completely against the tenets of fiscal federalism”.
 
From putting up an exceedingly strong resistance to the GST to now championing its benefits, it has been a complete U-turn for the BJP.
We recall what the BJP had said.
 
On February 20, 2011, Yashwant Sinha, a senior BJP leader and chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance, bluntly said:  "They are doing a wrong thing."
 
Sinha said several states, including those ruled by the BJP, were opposed to introduction of the GST because of their own interests and not due to any partisan issue, reported Hindustan Times.
 
"It is not Gujarat, it is Madhya Pradesh, which has been strongly opposing GST from day one,” added Sinha.
 
On October 23, 2013, the Narendra Modi-led Gujarat government opposed the UPA government's attempt to pass the 115th Constitution Amendment Bill, 2011 to enact GST regime.
 
Gujarat minister Saurabh Patel, who attended the the national empowered committee meeting, said, "If the union government through an ordinance enacts the GST regime, Gujarat will have to bear Rs 14,000 crore loss per annum due to the destination based taxation principle."
 
Patel said that Gujarat is facing a severe problem of realization of revenue due to economic slowdown. "Yet the Centre has not yet released the pending compensation of Rs 4,500 crore. This issue should be resolved instead of moving towards the constitution amendment. As suggested by the standing committee, broad consensus has not been arrived at on key issues concerning the implementation of GST," The Times of India quoted him as saying.
 
Not just that. On August 4, 2010, the Gujarat government made a detailed written submissions before Empowered Committee opposing GST, the Congress said
 
It said:  “The proposed constitutional amendment has come at a time when consensus is lacking even within the Empowered Committee on many features of GST….. This amendment fundamentally alters powers of the States to levy and collect indirect taxes.
 
“The power to determine rate of taxes is a basic function of legislative body like Parliament or, as the case may be, State Legislature. Article 265 very clearly states that no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. Thus, provisions of proposed Article 279A runs counter to the existing provisions of Constitution. I find it difficult to agree to wide ranging powers given to GST council. These powers shall remain within legislative and administrative purview of State and cannot be ceded to the council as it will take away entire financial autonomy of the State.”
 
Again on February 11, 2011, the Gujarat government stated: “The new constitutional amendment draft proposed by the GoI is retrograde in nature and completely against the tenets of fiscal federalism…… Therefore, Gujarat does not support the proposed constitutional amendment in its present form.”
Prime minister Narendra Modi admitted in parliament on August 9, 2016 that he did have doubts about the GST, reported NDTV.
 
Modi said that that his experience as a chief minister who had doubts about the GST, made it easier for him to address those issues as prime minister.
In a discussion in the Lok Sabha, Congress leader Mallikarjun Kharge said, "Those who are passing the GST now, why were they opposing it when they were in the opposition?
 
"I had many doubts. I had discussed it with Pranab Mukherjee many times," PM Modi said in his speech, referring to the President who was then finance minister in the UPA government.
 
The Narendra Modi government has now managed to resolve some of the sticking points.
 
Finance minister Arun Jaitley, at an event organized by ABP on June 27, said: “The country will benefit from the new indirect tax regime.”
 
Crude oil, natural gas, aviation fuel, diesel and petrol have been excluded and Jaitley said that while negotiating with the states on GST there were some “tough” issues like petroleum and potable alcohol on which states were unwilling to leave their taxation powers.
 
“If we insisted on that, then the deal would have been broken. The Constitution amendment provides that petroleum products can be taxed under GST as and when GST Council decides. And once GST is implemented, in 1-2 years once again the Council will get opportunity to revisit it,” Jaitley was quoted as saying.
 

Comments

 

Other News

How to leverage AI to solve urgent global issues

The world seems to be hurling towards World War III in all the possible scenarios: hot war, cold war, and proxy war. The battleground seems to have expanded beyond physical to digital or virtual/mixed reality with technology like drones. Moreover, the line between civilian and military targets seems to hav

Budget: Progress towards SDGs and areas for improvement

The Union Budget 2025-26 outlines India`s vision for economic and social growth while also reflecting the country`s commitment to sustainable development. As India moves closer to the 2030 deadline for the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), this budget presents a balanced approach

Repo rate cut by 25 basis points to 6.25%

The Reserve Bank of India has, for the first time in five years, reduced the policy repo rate under the liquidity adjustment facility (LAF) by 25 basis points to 6.25% with immediate effect. Consequently, the standing deposit facility (SDF) rate will stand adjusted to 6.00% and the marginal

Amitav Ghosh’s new work: Connections between the word and the world

Wild Fictions: Essays By Amitav Ghosh HarperCollins, 496 pages, Rs 799.00 Amitav Ghosh, one of a handful of Ind

How markets can help (and also hinder) fight against pollution

In the annals of environmental policy, few ideas have been as transformative as the Emissions Trading System (ETS). Born from the minds of economists in the late 1960s, this market-based approach to pollution control has evolved from a theoretical concept to a global tool in the fight against climate chang

Will Bihar complement the resolution of Viksit Bharat 2047?

As India completes its diamond jubilee as a republic, I am reminded of a statement by Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, delivered during an address to the Bihar Chamber of Commerce in Patna on March 28, 2006. He said, “I have visited Bihar numerous times, and it has always been a source of happiness for me to

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now



Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter