Conjugal rights for prisoners can wait, make jails corrective institutions

High court orders granting of right to procreation and conjugal rights to prisoners

GN Bureau | January 7, 2015



Indian prisons are no longer the hellholes of the world and neither comfortable places. The jails are mostly crowded and brutality is almost a daily affair. Under these circumstances, another high court judgement to allow sex for the married couple and conjugal rights for the deserving prisoners is baffling.

The Punjab and Haryana high court this week allowed sex in prison, with certain riders. The court said the couple should be legally married and conjugal union would be allowed only for procreation.

Last January, the Maharashtra high court had asked the Maharashtra state government as to why can't the prisoners have sex in jails.

The Punjab and Haryana high court, in an order made public on Tuesday, backed the right of jail inmates to have conjugal visits. It said even artificial insemination for progeny was a fundamental right.

The verdict was delivered by justice Surya Kant. The orders were passed on a petition filed by Jasvir Singh and Sonia. They are lodged in Patiala jail and legally married. The couple had  sought court directions to the prison authorities to make 'the necessary arrangements' for their conjugal union

The judge held that right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of Indian Constitution included the right of convicts and jail inmates to have conjugal visits or artificial insemination as an alternative.

As a result of this judgement, the prisons department will have to create the 'environment' for the conjugal and family visits in jail. It will also have to categorise the inmates entitled to such visits.

However, with overcrowded prisons and vastly stretched jail authorities, the feasibility of such arrangements looks improbable.

Capital’s Tihar Jail is notoriously crowded with nearly 10000 prisoners at any given day.  The jail also has various posts lying vacant.

The jail staff and the police have their hands full in monitoring the prisoners and escorting them to courts.

In fact, overcrowding is a massive problem in the jails of Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh. Last year, the supreme court had ordered freedom for under-trials who had served half the term of their maximum punishment period possible in their cases.

Prisons reform is one area that both the government and rights organizations have tried to bring in few changes. What is needed is proper manual to bring behavioral changes in the prisoners so that when they come back to society, they do not pick up crime again.  The jails should become corrective institutions and not breeding grounds for hardened criminals, who remain a menace to the society. 

Hence, it will be a long time before conjugal rights are granted inside the jail.

Comments

 

Other News

Business houses donated Rs 956.77 crore to political parties in 4 years

Business houses loosened their purse strings while making donations to political parties, showed an analysis carried out by Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR).   Various sectors of business houses, between FY 2012-13 and 2015-16, donated a total of Rs 956.77 crore, cons

PPP model in metro rail may not be a good idea

The PPP model has been made mandatory in metro rail projects, but it has not been successful in at least three cities – Delhi, Mumbai and Hyderabad.  The cabinet chaired by prime minister Narendra Modi approved a new Metro Rail Policy that m

India must have a cyber security framework: Deloitte

In absence of proper regulatory and supervisory capabilities, some regulators in Asia-Pacific region believe the next financial crisis might be triggered by a cyber attack, said a new report on cyber security. According to Deloitte`s ‘cyber regulation in Asia Pacific’ report, cyber at

Industrial performance has weakened: RBI panel

There is a need for speedier clearance of projects by states, RBI’s monetary policy committee said and added that there is an urgent need to reinvigorate private investment, remove infrastructure bottlenecks and provide a major thrust to the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana for housing needs of all.

“Parents need to be taught that each child is special”

It has been a year since you took charge of the new ministry. What is your biggest worry as in charge of education in India? My first priority – and that reflects my worry as well – is to improve the quality of government schools. It’s a tough job. Unfortunately,

Should National List of Essential Medicines be expanded?

Should National List of Essential Medicines be expanded?



Video

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter