Budget should focus on direct tax reforms to provide much needed relief to the common person, says Pahle India Foundation
GN Bureau | January 31, 2017
Pahle India Foundation (PIF) has suggested that finance minister Arun Jaitley should take cognizance of some of the possible negative effects of demonetization and take steps to minimize its negative impacts and enhance the adoption of digital currency and transactions in his budget speech.
PIF had organized a seminar and the recommendations were presented to Jaitley.
Direct Tax Reforms: In this context, Jaitley should focus on direct tax reforms to provide much needed relief to the common person. These reforms could include;
Arun Jaitley should act on his promise of bringing down the corporate tax rate to 25% from the current 33.5%. The effective corporate income tax incidence is no more than 23%. Thus, if he removes all the exemptions, he will not really suffer a revenue loss. The 2% two cut in the corporate income tax rate coming along with a sharp reduction if not elimination of exemptions, will surely be more than made up by an expanded tax net. It will improve compliance, reduce litigation and harassment by marauding tax inspectors. This step has also been suggested in the draft Direct Tax Code and should therefore be implemented in this budget.
Personal Income Tax Reduction: Unfortunately, we still suffer from widespread poverty in our country (12.3% of our population lives on $ 1.00 per day!). Given the poverty and average annual nominal per capita income in 2016 being only Rs 93,230, it would be quite inequitable to raise the level of income that is exempted from personal income tax from the present level of Rs2.5 lakh. However, there is scope for rationalizing the personal income tax structure. The highest rate of personal income tax at 33% rate (30% plus cesses) presently becomes applicable at an annual income of Rs 10 lakh. Imposing this high rate at this income level encourages non-compliance as it is seen as far too high by middle class professionals and small traders and entrepreneurs.
This is perhaps also reflected in the rather bizarre fact that as few as 24 lakh people in India declare their annual income as above Rs. 10 lakh is ample evidence of the consequent widespread tax avoidance. My suggestion would be to apply this highest rate of 30% at an income level of Rs 24 lakh per annum. This would both expand the tax net and provide a much needed rise in disposal incomes of the middle class. This will boost consumption boost, which is currently much needed in the post demonetization period.
Indirect Tax Rationalization: Another tax measure that the finance minister should take is to roll back some of the excise duty increases on petroleum products (petrol plus diesel) that were announced over the last two years. Excise duties were hiked eight times during 2014-16 to absorb some of the gains from the steep fall in global oil prices as government revenues. With global oil prices having firmed up over the last six months, it is time to reverse some of these excise duty hikes. This will provide a timely relief to the common man and also bring down costs in the economy. Both measures will stimulate economic activity.
With the likely introduction of the GST in July 2017, the forthcoming budget would be the logical place to start bringing indirect tax rates on goods and services in line with the rates proposed under the GST. This should see a rather sharp reduction in central excise duties on goods and a modest increase in tax on services.
Boosting Slackening Investment: Private investment activity, which started to plummet during the last two years of the UPA government, needs to be revived urgently and significantly. The following steps will help in this regard:
Hiking Public Capital Expenditure: Finance minister will do well to announce an increase of at least 25% in public capital expenditure in 2017-18 over the revised budget estimates for 2016-17. This will give a clear signal to all concerned that the Modi government is serious about expanding productive capacities in the economy and generate additional employment.
Fiscal Versus Revenue Deficit: Fiscal hawks should be aware that their stance could well have serious national security implications at the present conjuncture. The Finance Minister has to take the necessary though difficult call between placating and pampering international credit rating agencies, with somewhat dubious credentials, against a rising storm of youth agitation fed by continued frustration of their exploding aspirations. The Finance Minister must surely recognize that in the absence of a strong economic recovery by March 2018, BJP’s political fortunes in 2019 general elections could take a severe knock. Please Mr. Jaitley, do not succumb to threats either from fiscal hawks or rating agencies as these are paper tigers while the rising tide of youth anger is certainly not.
Instead the Finance Minister may focus his attention on eliminating revenue deficit as quickly as possible. Rising revenue deficit clearly implies living beyond one’s means. The share of revenue expenditure in total government expenditure has been rising inexorably from about 60% during the 70s to an unsustainable 85% in 2015. The noxious impact of FRBM implementation has been a continuing reduction in capital expenditure to meet FRBM targets. This must be reversed. Surely borrowing done to raise productivity and expand production capacities is fully justified.
Time Bound Affordable Housing Program: The Government should hugely ramp up its capital allocation for affordable and workers’ housing and establish a special task force to monitor the project’s execution in a tight deadline of 18 months. Land already in Government possession should be handed over to these projects for facilitating their execution. The government should consider providing affordable housing infrastructure status.
Special Infrastructure Fund: The budget should also announce the setting up of a ‘Special Fund’ to assist in the re-starting of stalled infrastructure projects. However, this should not imply bailing out those corporations who took unnecessary risks and failed in project implementation. Finally, the proposed National Infrastructure Investment Fund (NIIF), that has been long in the making, could also be directed to help in re-starting stalled projects.
Does AAP continue to suffer from political immaturity?
There`s a popular folktale shaped by the tongues of the bards and storytellers of Rajasthan about the folly of Rajputs. A Rajput crossing a dense, dark jungle falls into a dry, abandoned well. He is trapped for hours till a passing youth throws him a rope and pulls him up. Nea
The Canadian PM has received an official reception by the prime minister of India Narendra Modi on Friday at the Rashtrapati Bhavan. The two are expected to talk some serious business at the bilateral meeting, and are expected to focus on trade, defence, civil nuclear cooperation, space, tackling climate c
Have you used Rotomac pen? The brand is owned by a Kanpur-based Kothari family, which owns Rotomac Global, now under CBI and ED scanner for round-tripping. Rotomac Global is run by Vikram Kothari, who is also the managing director with the firm. A key allegation against Kothari is that he o
India is faring worse and worse on Transparency International’s ‘Corruption Perception Index’: the latest for 2017 shows India ranking a poor 81 (placed between Ghana and Morocco) and the same 40 points out of 100 as the previous year. In 2015 and 2014, the number stood at 38 and
During his reply on the Motion of Thanks to the Address of the President of India, in the Lok Sabha on February 7, prime minister Narendra Modi compared his government`s efforts to curb corruption and flush out black money to Swachh Bharat Abhiyan – the nationwide mission launched to clean up cities,