IIT Delhi report is not comprehensive enough and they have not taken samples properly, says green tribunal
GN Bureau | May 18, 2015
The government sought stay on order banning plying of over 10-year-old diesel vehicles in Delhi—NCR by quoting a study by IIT Delhi, and both were hauled up by the National Green Tribunal (NGT). It directed that they come back with a thorough explanation from IIT Delhi on why they think the ban will not be effective. The NGT stayed the ban till May 25.
The tribunal was angry during a hearing on Monday as it felt that the scientists from IIT and the ministry of road transport had not prepared a well reasoned report on how much air pollution do more than ten year old diesel vehicles contribute.
The green tribunal wanted the ministry to submit its views on capping total number of vehicles, scrapping of old vehicles, car pooling and incentives to those who want to dispose of their old vehicles.
The ministry was against the ban as it claimed that more than ten year old diesel vehicles contribute to less than 1% of PM 2.5 (fine, respirable pollution particles) emissions in the city. Their argument is based on a study by Dinesh Mohan and other IIT scientists. The ministry had argued that only 7% of the vehicles in the capital are more than 10 years old.
“What is the basis of this report? IIT has no business to comment on this. This report is not comprehensive enough. They have not taken samples from any place. IIT could have done a better job. You have placed 100 pages without conducting any study. Merely because you are IIT you can’t be always right,” the bench said.
The NGT bench said they expected much better from IIT Delhi in terms of both research and analysis of the problem. For example, the study said PM 2.5 levels in RK Puram were on Sundays or holidays despite traffic being very low. The NGT bench asked what is IIT Delhi's explanation on this? "Why are the levels high? Are they because of trucks and commercial vehicles plying at night?" one of them asked.
The NGT bench also said that the IIT study only refers to private vehicles but what about contribution from diesel commercial and heavy vehicles?
“Don’t try to tell us our order is wrong. The whole IIT report is tilted towards proving that the ban order is bad. There has to be proper reasoning to what you are saying,” the bench added.
The bench also referred to a Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) study which found that old vehicles are responsible for 60% of air pollution from vehicles despite being very small in number. "Merely because you are IIT doesn't mean you can do this? There has to be proper reasoning to what you are saying."
The ministry is willing to ban more than 15 year old diesel vehicles, which has been ordered by the supreme court earlier.
Abright yellow van with figures of children playing with a whirligig, a Newton’s cradle, a magnetic compass rolls into the Government Higher Primary School in Kittaganahalli, on the outskirts of Bengaluru. Students in the playground leave what they are doing and mill about it in excitement. For they
Not many children dream of starting an idyllic school of their own when they grow up. But Ramji Raghavan, founder of the Agastya International Foundation – which fosters the creative learning of science in stude
While the entire nation is agog with political grapevine, political parties are weighing on all options to lure voters by touching upon issues that impact their lives. Several parties, including the BJP and the Congress have released their manifestos while many are about to join the bandwagon. The
Urmila Matondkar joined the Congress party and within just two months into politics, the actor is already surrounded by controversies – from being accused of making anti-Hindu comments to inappropriate poll campaigning. Fielded against BJP’s Gopal Shetty in the Mumbai North constituency, Ma
Dressed in white shirt and pants, three time Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP) corporator Manoj Kotak is now contesting from Mumbai north-east constituency. Kotak, representing BJP in the BMC, is ready to rally around Ward 125 in Ghatkopar east area. It’s about 7:30 pm on a hot April e
Sunil Bhatt, a Gujarat-based professional, has completed what is possibly the first PhD thesis on prime minister Narendra Modi. The thesis, titled ‘Leadership, Governance and Development: A case study of Shri Narendra Modi’, has been accepted at the Veer Narmad South Gujarat Universit