SC asks Tiwari to undergo DNA test

Direction given on paternity suit filed by Rohit Shekhar claiming to be Tiwari's son

PTI | May 1, 2012



Refusing to give any relief to Congress leader N D Tiwari, the Supreme Court on Tuesday directed him to give his blood sample for DNA test on a paternity suit against him, saying "enough is enough".

"Enough is enough, you were not present on earlier occasions. Having regard to your age, we told you to give sample in a sealed cover. We gave you protection under Article 21, but enough is enough," said a bench of justices Aftab Alam and C K Prasad.

The direction was given on a paternity suit filed by Rohit Shekhar, who claims himself to be the biological son of 86-year-old Tiwari.

"Give the blood sample, what is the problem with that?" the bench told Tiwari's counsel Sushil Jain during the hearing of Tiwari's last year's plea, still pending with the apex court.

Tiwari had challenged the high court's December 23, 2010 order, asking him to undergo the DNA test.

On the last hearings of his plea in March 2011, the Supreme Court had given Tiwari the option to convey to the high court his preferred mode of undergoing DNA test - either through examination of the blood sample or his saliva or hair strand.

The apex court had earlier also assured Tiwari that his DNA test result would not be made public unless it would be unavoidable in the interest of justice.

But with Tiwari not agreeing to undergo a DNA test, the apex court had asked him to go back to the high court with his plea.

In the high court, Tiwari contended that he cannot be physically compelled to give his blood sample for his DNA test.

He even won on this count with a single-judge bench of the high court ruling that he cannot be physically challenged to give his blood sample.

The high court, however, last week, on a plea by Shekhar, ordered that Tiwari will have to give his blood sample for his DNA test, for which the police assistance can also be taken in case he refuses to do so.

Tiwari's counsel submitted that if Shekhar's plea was allowed, it would lead to a number of such litigations by people who will seek DNA tests in all paternity suits, thus affecting the reputation of an individual, who is entitled to protection under Article 21 (right to liberty).

The bench, however, was not impressed with the argument and reiterated that Tiwari must give the sample.

The bench also suggested that Tiwari can file a suit against Shekhar on charges of maligning his reputation.

In his plea to the apex court, which came up for hearing today, Tiwari had argued that it would be a violation of his right to privacy and would cause him public humiliation if he is directed to undergo the DNA test.

Tiwari, who had held the post of chief minister of undivided Uttar Pradesh and later of Uttarakhand, had contended that the high court had committed an error in passing the order and it should look at other evidence too to decide the paternity suit rather than focusing on the DNA test which is not a conclusive evidence.

Comments

 

Other News

India`s renewable race is moving beyond megawatts

When Shell bought Sprng Energy in 2022, India`s renewable energy market appeared to offer precisely what global energy majors were seeking: scale, growth and a place in one of the world`s largest energy transitions. Four years later, Shell is selling the same business to Aditya Birla Group for an enterpris

Nepal Floods: India keeps close watch on the situation

India`s central government has been keeping a close watch on the situation arising out of the flash flood in Nepal on Wednesday. Union home minister Amit Shah spoke with the chief ministers of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, the two states that share the border with Nepal, regarding the disaster

UPI completes 10 years of digital payments revolution

The Unified Payments Interface (UPI), launched on August 25, 2016 by the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) under the regulatory oversight of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), has completed 10 years of transforming digital payments in India. UPI has emerged as the backbone of India’s digi

Here’s an I.D.E.A. for career growth and success

Success in today’s professional organisation is no longer solely determined by academic qualifications, technical expertise or years of experience. While these attributes do matter, organisations increasingly value individuals who demonstrate the right mindset and behavioural qualities. The ability

PM interacts with CEOs, founders of space startups

Prime minister Narendra Modi interacted with CEOs and Founders of 20 Space Startups at Seva Teerth on Friday.   CEOs of leading companies in the space sector working in diverse fields ranging from building rockets and reusable semi-cryogenic launch vehicles, avionics, satelli

From one cow to a dairy business

In 2012, Anita Dash wasn`t dreaming of building a dairy brand. She wasn`t studying business models or planning market expansion. Like countless mothers across India, her focus was on something much simpler: giving her children a better future.   At the time, her most valuable

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter