A tale of two verdicts shows Modi is no control freak

Conviction or acquittal, opposition is as usual looking for PM's hand in everything

ajay

Ajay Singh | December 26, 2017 | New Delhi


#UPA   #governance   #Lalu Prasad   #A Raja   #prime minister   #Narendra Modi   #DMK   #2G   #fodder scam   #CBI   #ED  
GN illustration
GN illustration

 It is the story of the exoneration of A Raja and the conviction of a metaphorical raja (Lalu Prasad used to call himself a raja of Bihar) that reveals a complex web of governance in India.

Raja’s exoneration in the 2G scam was quickly followed by Lalu’s conviction in the fodder scam. Of course, in both cases, the respective CBI courts delivered verdicts which are conveniently and liberally interpreted by the accused.
 
But look at the manner in which Raja, Kanimozhi and their colleagues in the DMK are expressing jubilation over the court’s verdict and describing it as “triumph of the truth”. Quoting the verdict, they call the 2G scam nothing but a figment of imagination of some conspirators out to destroy the “impeccable” image of the UPA government. And who else could be the chief conspirator but the country’s prime minister Narendra Modi himself!
 
Now turn the story towards Ranchi where Lalu, after being convicted, discovered that he is in the league of “Nelson Mandela, Martin Luther King and BR Ambedkar”. He claimed himself to be on the side of truth and blamed the BJP and the Prime Minister for purveying falsehoods leading to his conviction. He also hints at a conspiracy of upper castes to corner him. And the lead role in this conspiracy is being played by none other than Modi himself.
 
A careful reading of CBI court additional sessions judge OP Saini’s verdict in the 2G case shows that he clearly blames the CBI and the Enforcement Directorate of carrying out a “shoddy investigations” and their inability to produce a shred of incriminating evidence to prove the existence of a scam. Obviously, the CBI’s investigation and its prosecution annoyed the court to extent that it found no merit in the claims of wrongdoings in 2G spectrum allocations.
 
Contrast this with Lalu’s case and one will find that the CBI has investigated the fodder scam in a meticulous manner and convinced the court to convict the prime accused, Lalu, on the basis of evidence. In both cases, there is one consistency in the arguments that the BJP in general and Modi in particular are out to destroy the reputation of their political adversaries. Along with this runs the theme of the CBI and the ED being used by the government to target the Opposition. If one goes by statements of Lalu, Raja and certain Congress leaders, it would appear that all institutions, including the judiciary, are mere puppets in the government’s hand.
 
Is there any iota of truth in these allegations? Apparently, in both cases facts are stranger than fiction. Right from the word go, both cases were strictly monitored by the Supreme Court. In the 2G case, much before the BJP came to power and could take it up, the Supreme Court clearly indicted the government and found fault with Raja’s indiscretion in tweaking the policies to favour certain individuals. The scam was investigated successively by two CBI chiefs - AP Singh and Ranjit Sinha – both considered very close to the Congress. While AP Singh’s proximity to Ahmed Patel was quite evident in the UPA’s tenure, Sinha was initially too close to the UPA regime but switched sides before 2014 Lok Sabha polls in anticipation of a change.
 
Particularly intriguing was the manner in which the Supreme Court enforced its decision on the CBI and the ED to retain a particular set of investigating officers (some with dubious credentials) and prosecutors to pursue the 2G case. Apparently neither the CBI nor the ED was given any latitude to choose investigators and determine the course of prosecution as everything came under the SC’s mandate which almost crippled the government’s role. The reality is that the government has let the agencies function as per the direction of the SC to proceed with the case. In effect, the CBI court’s judgment reads like an indictment of the SC which assumed for itself a role beyond the constitutional mandate and infringe on the executive’s domain.
 
Similarly in the fodder scam case, the meticulous investigation carried out by the CBI established Lalu’s culpability beyond doubt and led to his conviction. It is no secret that in UPA’s tenure, Lalu desperately tried to get rid of the fodder scam by employing all means, fair and foul. He approached the SC with a request to club together all cases related to the fodder scam in order to manipulate the situation in his favour. However, his adversaries in the court were vigilant enough to foil all his attempts. Given the history of the fodder case, it is quite evident that the investigation and prosecution were hardly ever tinkered with by the Modi government.
 
Then how does one interpret the allegation of over-centralisation of power in PMO or in Modi? Perhaps, the tale of prosecution of Raja and Lalu is quite revealing about Modi’s style of functioning. The manner in which Raja was let off the hook was a reflection of professional incompetence of the ED and the CBI. Similarly, Lalu’s conviction is indicative of professional hard work and competence of another set of officers from the same CBI. The PMO’s influence is completely absent in both the cases. This goes quite contrary to Modi’s image of being control-freak. Far from it, he appears to be guided by motivation far greater than implicating petty political criminals who would, in any case, meet their nemesis sooner than later.
 
(This article first appeared on First Post.)
 

Comments

 

Other News

Harnessing the demographic capital: how effective are skilling programmes?

Probing data concerning increased job creation and the decline in unemployment has been holding the attention of economists and been subject of discussions in several think tanks in the preceding months. The NITI Aayog reports that 3.53 million new jobs were created between September 2017 and February 2018

It`s time to Unlock now, with economic focus

With Lockdown 4 ending Sunday, the home ministry has issued new guidelines to fight COVID-19 and for phased re-opening of areas outside the Containment Zones. The guidelines, issued based on extensive consultations held with states and UTs, will be effective from June 1 till June 30. The first phase of reo

Small kitchen gardens turn saviours for Gujarat tribal families

When the whole world is fighting COVID-19, food and nutrition security has become a major issue. The pandemic has aggravated the existing food crisis in India, especially in rural and tribal regions. There has been less availability of fresh foods in most parts of the country, and the tribal community has

India will set example of post-Covid-19 economic revival: Modi

India is determined to “set an example” for the rest of the word in the post-pandemic economic revival, prime minister Narendra Modi has said, underling the need to become self-reliant. “There is also a widespread debate on how the economies of various countries, including

3,543 ‘Shramik Special’ trains transport 48 lakh people in 26 days

Close to 48 lakh migrant labourers have been able to reach home from the cities they were working in, as the Indian Railways have run a total of 3,543 “Sharmik Special” trains from May 1. Following the home ministry order regarding the movement by special trains of migrant worker

How Jeevan Raths have helped 52,000 migrants in Maharashtra

Before the novel coronavirus hit it, Mumbai about 10-12 lakh labourers from elsewhere had made it their home. The figure for the state of Maharashtra was another 18-20 lakh. As the pandemic spread and the Maximum City emerged as the worst-hit place in India, all economic activities came to an end, and with



Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter