Book review: The memoir of the bureaucrat, written in humorous vein but remains serious in its message
Himanshu Upadhyaya | December 8, 2016
The year 2014 saw the publication of the memoirs of a former CAG of India, Vinod Rai, and this year another former member of this prestigious constitutional body has penned an account of his time as an auditor (and also administrator while on deputation). Parimal Brahma’s book talks about the experiences that honest and upright officers in public administration go through. He recalls the tragic story of his friend, Abhas Chatterjee, a topper in the 1966 civil service exam, who quit services in January 1992, feeling disgusted and disenchanted with the system.
Brahma recollects grave episodes of how the idea of public accountability gets compromised by actions of public administrators. This memoir has very little on the early years of his career as probationary civil services officer and the first posting. Towards the end of the first chapter, he looks at his days of working as deputy accountant general (works) at Bhopal, where he was transferred from Calcutta in 1971.
There is an account here of how he moved from public auditing to the central secretariat. He recounts that initially he was short-listed for the position of under-secretary, department of economic affairs. This shift could not take place since the cadre-controlling authority, the CAG of India, felt that not taking his prior consent was akin to taking him for granted. Many months later there came an order from the CAG office posting him as an under-secretary at the ministry of defence. One can see the aspirations of a bright young Indian audit and accounts service (IAAS) officer and a slight bitterness tinged with a tone of humour.
There are three chapters where he recollects his days in the ministries of defence, civil aviation and tourism, and environment and forests. He recollects personalities of various secretaries and ministers through episodes that are both humorous and deadly serious such as the proceedings of the public account committee (PAC) on audit paragraphs. Several episodes that he narrates give the reader an impression of what systemic deficits are encountered in ensuring public accountability and probity. Occasionally, Brahma would cite correspondence – a letter from an anguished father of a Major voicing the grievances and a letter that he wrote to the PMO pointing out flaws in the system of selecting secretaries. He is unsparing in his criticism of how we continued many years to maintain an overseas tourism promotion office in a country from where only 18 tourists a year on average would come to India. Similarly, he also talks about how he had to disapprove a tourism director general’s Malaysia trip for an event whose agenda was more tilted towards poaching Indian tourists to east Asian countries, rather than attracting tourists to India.
Third chapter has details on how the environment ministry failed to deliver on the idea of environmental protection, be it protection of tigers or conserving our holy rivers against pollution.
The fourth and fifth chapters raise several important issues concerning ethics in governance and the need to preserve the institutions and parliamentary processes that have a promise to ensure public accountability and probity. He talks about the cash-for-question phenomenon that makes elected representatives ask ‘motivated questions’, the loopholes in the premier investigation agency CBI, the promise that the institution of Lokpal (ombudsman) offers and a few episodes of his work in what he calls ‘graveyard postings’.
The fifth chapter starts with his narration of his efforts yet again to break away from a ‘prison’ called the central secretariat and at last finding a reprieve that he got a chance to return to roots – the CAG office. This chapter also raises some pertinent issues about how the top boss as the CAG is appointed and a need to ensure accountability in selection. It is known for quite some years now that this coveted constitutional post has been bagged by persons belonging to IAS cadre and questions have been raised whether there shouldn’t be a rethinking about giving it to IAAS cadre when the next CAG gets appointed.
I had picked up this memoir with a hope that Brahma would tell his readers about the much awaited amendments to the CAG (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Services) Act, 1971. Sadly there is nothing on this and other ongoing debates around the role of CAG in the PPP arrangements.
Upadhyaya is an assistant professor at Azim Premji University, Bengaluru
(The book view appears in the December 1-15, 2016 issue)
BJP is all set to retain Gujarat, indicated one exit poll. Another exit poll, however, showed a tough fight in at least one region. Aaj Tak exit poll showed that BJP will win 99 – 113 seats, getting a majority in the 182 member assembly. The Congress will get 68 – 82 seats, falli
Goa shipyard Limited (GSL) has delivered the second fuel barge to Indian Navy on December 2, 33 days ahead of contractual delivery schedule, and recently got inducted into the Navy. Navy was in the need of self-propelled 1000Ton fuel barges, with a view to fuel big ships like INS Vikramadity
Minister of state for defence Subhash Bhamre has assured Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd (HAL) that work load for its Nashik unit will continue to flow even after Su-MKI manufacturing and production activities conclude in the next few years. “HAL has the world class facilities and giv
Naval submarine INS Kalvari was dedicated to the nation by prime minister Narendra Modi on Thursday in Mumbai. INS Kalvari is a diesel-electric attack submarine built by the Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders Ltd for the Indian Navy. As per the plan, five more such submarines would be inducted into
People queued up since early morning to cast their ballot to decide the political fate of 851 candidates in the second and final phase of the bitterly fought Gujarat assembly elections. The votes in all the 182 seats will be counted on December 18. Over 22 million people are eligible to cast
Had the situation not been so desperate, then the AAP government’s proposal to sprinkle water from helicopters would have been considered hare-brained. But, a more practical solution to tackling air pollution may well be around the corner and it lies in the success of a pilot project in Iceland.