Roy rejoinder: No gun intended

Arundhati's delayed “what-I-meant-was” leaves much to be clarified

ashishm

Ashish Mehta | June 4, 2010



Arundhati Roy, our leading public intellectual, has made a rare clarification. She says she never wrote the phrase “Gandhians with a gun”, used to describe Maoists in an essay she wrote for the Outlook in March. The phrase appeared in the sub-headline and Roy says it was written by the magazine. The British newspaper Guardian also carried the  same article, under the headline “Gandhi, But With Gun.” Roy could be issuing a similar clarification for the Guardian too.

Addressing a public meeting in Mumbai on Wednesday, Roy reiterated: "I never called them Gandhians with guns. It was a blurb carried by a magazine. What I meant was that they (Naxals) are more Gandhian than any other Gandhian in their consumption pattern...their lifestyle, which is in stark contrast to their violent means of resistance."

We need to react to the clarification since we too had joined the debate (“Arundhati, propagandist with a fat dictionary”). In short:

(1) The Outlook article was published in the March 29 edition, on stands March 22. Roy's clarification, disowning the phrase, comes more than two months later. If she disagreed with the three words, she could have pointed it out much earlier.

(2) It is not exactly clear why she is on the defensive. She has, after all, not disowned that she has termed “the superiority of ‘the non-violent way’” as “ Gandhi’s pious humbug”. Or, making fun of the nonviolent means of resistance like hunger strikes which she had supported and advocated in the past.

(3) Roy is yet to explain what made her change her mind on non-violence. In her several essays (particularly on the Narmada Bachao Andolan), she was all for non-violence, all for Gandhian ways. Once can certainly evolve one's ideology, support Gandhi one day and (say) Narendra Modi the next day, but as a public intellectual, you are expected to explain. You can't be preaching non-violence one day and exhorting them to take up arms the next – without an explanation. That's the one explanation she should have given, instead of blaming her ideological confusion on the Outlook.

In her Mumbai lecture, she explained this much: “Gandhian way of opposition needs an audience, which is absent here.” Violence, on the other hand, has a ready audience, which according to Roy is the sole decider in things like this. Sad.

Comments

 

Other News

HPCL, Tata Steel among National CSR Award 2020 winners

Hindustan Petroleum Corporation, HDFC, Tata Steel and Tech Mahindra are among the winners and the recipients of honourable mentions in the National CSR Awards 2020 announced by the ministry of corporate affairs (MCA) on Thursday. The MCA instituted the annual National Corporate Social Respon

India’s tree lovers get together for a nation-wide tree festival

A good monsoon has left the trees all washed and spruced up. It’s right time to take a good look at them, and also to tell the young generation about their diversity. So, tree lovers across the country have joined hands to celebrate a festival of trees this month. The August Tree Fest

How did a policeman move unarmed and fearlessly for 37 long years in Bihar?

Unbounded: My Experiments with Law, Physics, Policing and Super 30 By Abhayanand Rupa Publications, 344 pages, Rs 595   Abhayanand has

India@75: A timely study of the state of the nation

India after 1947: Reflections & Recollections By Rajmohan Gandhi Aleph, 118 pages, Rs 399 Rajmohan Gandhi was about 11 when India won independence. As the nation celebrates 75 years of freedom, how would he – and others like him – feel?

BMC denies protocol breach in ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’

The BrihanMumbai municipal corporation (BMC) has rebutted a Shiv Sena leader’s allegation of breach of protocol in the implementation of the ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’ campaign. On Friday Rahul Shewale, group leader of Shiv Sena in Lok Sabha, had accused BMC commissioner IS Chahal

Mumbai`s stalled building projects: Is self-redevelopment the real solution?

Land in Mumbai city, which is surrounded by water on three sides, is scarce and has a premium. Property prices in certain areas of financial capital of the country are as much as Rs 1 lakh per sq ft. Yet, 5,800 buildings have been lying in a stalled condition for the last 18 years. Meanwhile

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter