The Rs 10 tool every journalist must use

A seasoned practitioner tells us how he has used RTI to great effect

swati

Swati Chandra | August 29, 2017 | NEW DELHI


#Shyamlal Yadav   #right to information   #RTI   #book review   #Journalism Through RTI  


In 2007, Shyamlal Yadav, then a senior journalist with India Today magazine, decided to use the RTI law, enacted only two years ago, to find out the details of foreign trips made by union ministers. Foreign travel is expensive, time consuming and, more often than not, does not serve any real purpose. Yadav wanted to know which minister travelled how much. It took him 59 applications and appeals (excluding the ones filed for the follow-up) – and four months – to find out. At least three ministries did not respond. In the end, with the replies he received from the PMO, the cabinet secretariat and various ministries, it was revealed that 71 union ministers had totted up airmiles equalling 256 circumambulations of the globe. All in three and a half years. 

The story appeared in the magazine in February 2008 with the headline ‘Frequent Fliers’. It was widely followed by other newspapers and TV channels. Then prime minister Manmohan Singh was constrained to ask his ministers to curtail foreign travel. This was the first story that Yadav broke using RTI. Since then, he has kept up his relentless quest to find out answers to niggling questions that governments may not want to answer. 
 
In 2016, Yadav, now with The Indian Express, was tipped off that bank managers or staffers were being made to deposit a rupee in some accounts opened under the prime minister’s flagship Jan-Dhan scheme. The idea was to bring down the number of accounts with zero balance. Again, he filed a series of RTI applications with a number of banks to find out the number of accounts with balance ranging from zero to less than Rs 1 to less than Rs 10 and so on. Some of the answers came in, and he followed it up with visits to villages where Jan-Dhan account holders told him they hadn’t deposited anything but their accounts came to hold Rs 1 each mysteriously. In September 2016, his newspaper ran the story of how bank staffers were being told to window-dress statistics by making small deposits into Jan-Dhan accounts.
 
Curiosity, that quintessential journalistic spur, followed by patient RTI work and painstaking perseverence that took him to villages in UP to find out what really was happening made the story eminently readable. “RTI has taken me through a protracted, time-consuming and often frustrating journey, which after all makes for interesting reading,” he writes in his first book, ‘Journalism through RTI’, a hands-on manual on how to go about using RTI.
 
Yadav continues to use (and refine the use of) RTI for journalism. In his advance praise for the book, Satyananda Mishra, former chief information commisioner, says, “Yadav has married information to its rightful bride, the newspaper, and transformed it into an instrument of social change.” Such words, coming as they do from a former chief information commissioner, ornament and highlight the worth of what is essentially a no-frills book that sets out how one man extracted information in the public interest from the coils of red tape – and how you could do it too, with some persistence.
 
The book is divided into 11 chapters. In the initial pages, Yadav traces RTI to the concept of freedom of information and provides a comprehensive history of the idea. We learn that Sweden implemented it as early as 1766, during the rule of Adolph Frederick. Later, in the 20th century, the United Nations recognised the idea of freedom of information after World War II. The US implemented it 200 years after Sweden, in 1966. Pakistan was ahead of India: it got a freedom of information law in 2002. In India, the UPA-1 government had it enacted in 2005. Neighbours Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, the Maldives and Sri Lanka have RTI laws similar to ours. The first chapter also discusses at length the role of the media in bringing out information. It speaks highly of the efforts of activists like Subhash Agrawal, an advocate who like Yadav himself is a champion at using RTI to extract information that citizens ought to know.
 
The book is a veritable library of case studies: of interesting and apparently not so interesting (but relevant) questions Yadav has found answers to. He recalls trying to get an idea of how clean India’s major rivers were: he filed 39 applications and appeals for over a year with the ministry of environment, forest and climate change, the central pollution control board, the central water commission and various state pollution control boards. The resulting story traced the journey of the Ganga Action Plan of 1986 as well as every river covered under the National River Conservation Plan (NRCP) since 1995. Some of his other journalistic stories, narrated in this book, include those on a secret list of empowered group of ministers, iftaar parties at public expense, and corruption cases against bureaucrats.
 
His huge successes notwithstanding, Yadav writes: “Despite the RTI Act, getting crucial information from the government is a tough, tedious and often frustrating engagement where, it would appear, anti-transparency is a statement of belief and hiding the information and passing the buck, the favourite diversionary activity.”
 
 


The chief public information officer of IIT Kharagpur once wrote to him that the RTI Act “...confers right to information on all ‘citizens’ and not all ‘persons’. The citizenship can only be a natural born person and it does not even by implication include a legal or juristic person. Hence you being a person of The Indian Express, New Delhi, are not entitled to seek any information under the RTI Act.” Such is the reluctance to part with information, and such are the excuses on offer.
 
On the other side, like habitual non-serious litigants and election contesters, there has emerged a new brand of busybodies – the sort who want to know, say, how many bricks went into the building of a new government structure. On one occasion, as Yadav writes, an applicant asked about the number statues of Gandhi, Nehru and 60 other personalities installed in the country. He even asked whether his own statue could be installed somewhere. “Public authorities find it difficult to provide information to such queries and their concerns may be genuine, because many such applications can be quite disconcerting and wastage of time,” he writes.
 
As for politicians, he says “... no senior political leaders have been known to express the fear of the use of RTI by media. There are, of course, complaints and criticism of excessive use by people who misuse the law as well.” And as for the Narendra Modi government, he says it shows “no sign that [it] wants to weaken the RTI Act”. However, he cautions that “there are several officials who have started taking RTI provisions casually after the change in regime”. 
 

(The review appears in the August 16-31, 2017 issue of Governance Now)
 
 
 

Comments

 

Other News

Evaluating public-private partnership, the right way

Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) projects are always under scrutiny, given the options of alternative of traditional procurement for the government. The value-for-money debate is one of the essential parameters to judge any PPP. In the absence of any credible data on this regard, it is very difficult to e

Electoral bonds emerge as preferred mode of political donation

Electoral bonds, introduced in January 2018 to bring in transparency in political funding, has emerged as the preferred route for making donations to parties, according to an analysis of the parties’ audit reports by the Association of Democratic Reforms (ADR). “Given the anonymi

On Met Dept’s foundation day: let’s talk weather

With a humble beginning in 1875, the India Meteorological Department (IMD) – which is celebrating its 145thFoundation Day on January 15 – has marched forward with various milestones and paradigms to serve the society. When weather and climate are playing more and more role in our daily lives, h

You have to sometimes find your adversary No. 1: Prithviraj Chavan

Prithviraj Chavan, a senior Congress leader and former Maharashtra chief minister, is the key architect of the ruling Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) alliance that came to power after the three-day government of the BJP, supported by Ajit Pawar of NCP, fell apart just before the supreme court ordered an open b

Connecting the dots: Environmentalism, development and health

Every winter Delhi experiences some of the worst air pollution levels in the world. Concentrations of particulate matter – PM10 and PM2.5 – regularly hover around values of 400 to 500, levels that are considered extremely hazardous by both Indian and international air quality standards. Doctors

Stimulate demand to revive economy: Abhijit Banerjee

Nobel laureate economist Abhijit Banerjee has sounded an alarm on the economic crisis and compared the present situation to the 1991 economic crisis, stressing that to revive the economy it is important to stimulate demand. Like elsewhere in the world, the level of trust in experts and the e



Archives

Current Issue

Video

CM Nitish’s convoy attacked in Buxar

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter