SC rejects PIL claim of Rs 37,000 cr spectrum loss

SC says not inclined to entertain the PIL as no sufficient materials were placed before it

PTI | July 8, 2011



The Supreme Court on Thursday  declined to entertain a PIL that alleged a whopping loss of Rs 37,000 crore to the exchequer on account of private telecom operators inflating their subscribers base to garner the scarce spectrum.

The petition alleged that besides causing the huge loss, the modus operandi adopted by the telecom operators posed serious threat to national security as thousands of SIM cards were distributed free of cost without basic verification.

A bench of justices G S Singhvi and H L Dattu sought to know from counsel Subhash Sharma locus standi of the petitioner "Aam Admi", an NGO, and said it was not inclined to entertain the PIL as no sufficient materials were placed before it.

"We want to know how many PILs you have filed earlier. Your petition is relying only on newspaper clippings. There is no independent material," the bench told the counsel while dismissing the petition.

Founder of the NGO-Avishek Goenka in his petition claimed that the telecom companies provide a deceitful data of the total numbers of subscribers so as to inflate the subscribers base and illegally capture huge spectrum.

"This approach is adopted by the telecom companies with an idea to keep on acquiring extra spectrum, whose monetary value is very high as well as the same is a scarce national resource owing to the fact that it is a vital utility element for defence organisation. "In view of loss of such high magnitude coupled with concern of security of the country, the petitioner is praying for mandamus and other appropriate writ or directions in the nature of of proper audit and foolproof scrutiny in order to ascertain real and factual subscribers' base to curtail the plunder and misuse of spectrum a national wealth," the petition said.

The petitioners cited certain illustrations to allege that free SIM cards with "free talk time" were being allocated to benami subscribers to inflate the base and claim spectrum accordingly.

"The telecom companies lure the customers with various promotional offers/schemes and in order to live up to the competition of the telecoms sector of having the maximum subscriber base the service providers are selling the pre-paid SIM cards without proper verification of the address of the subscriber and in this manner they are rendering the life and property of Indian citizens and national security into peril," the petition alleged.

It urged the court to direct the Centre and the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India to "conduct audit and weed out" the bogus subscribers.

Comments

 

Other News

How Rafi, Raj Kapoor helped pave the way for a great uranium deal

There`s a certain moment in diplomacy that`s too personal to be captured in a communiqué, too small to make the front page, but more revealing than the front page. This week, prime minister Narendra Modi reached Tashkent and, amid the pomp of state visits, managed to evoke the old Bollywood tunes

Distinguishing Fish 1 and Fish 2: The pragmatism behind India’s WTO ratification

 India became the 123rd WTO member to ratify the multilateral Agreement on Fisheries subsidies (AoFS) when it deposited the Instrument of Acceptance for Phase 1 on July 20, 2026. The ratification is restricted to disciplining Illegal, Unreported and Unregulated fishing (IUU), protection for overfished

The 7% growth problem: Why the next 7% will be harder

India has become accustomed to hearing the 7% growth number. It is now less a milestone than an expectation. Yet the paradox is becoming clearer: maintaining 7% growth may be considerably harder than achieving it once. India’s real GDP grew 7.7% in FY2025–26, following growth of 6.5% in FY202

The Constitution cannot be altered: Justice Abhay Oka

Justice Abhay Oka, who retired from the Supreme Court in May 2025, has said that the Constitution of India cannot be altered. Explaining the landmark Kesavananda Bharati judgment (1973) on the basic structure of the Constitution, he said, “This is one judgment that has saved democracy in India.&rdq

How the flora and fauna evolved in the Indian subcontinent

Mammals of India  By A.J.T. Johnsingh and P.O. Nameer HarperCollins India in association with Bombay Natural History Society  

India`s renewable race is moving beyond megawatts

When Shell bought Sprng Energy in 2022, India`s renewable energy market appeared to offer precisely what global energy majors were seeking: scale, growth and a place in one of the world`s largest energy transitions. Four years later, Shell is selling the same business to Aditya Birla Group for an enterpris

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter