Abhadrolok: An open letter to Mamata Banerjee

Your reign as chief minister of West Bengal did bring peace in Jangalmahal and North Bengal. You are trying, I agree. But it isn’t good enough

pujab

Puja Bhattacharjee | December 4, 2014



Dear Mamata didi,

I have been your diehard fan since childhood. But now you are misguiding me. Jokes apart, I hardly had any feelings about you till you drove the Tata nano factory out of Singur. I do not know what people were thinking when they voted for you. I know, I know. They wanted an alternative to the corrupt and politicised CPI (M) government and you, sadly, were the only alternative they had. How could they be so blind so as not to see that you were further destroying the prospects of Bengal?

Your administration is no less corrupt or politicised. But you cannot be a totally bad person right? I agree. Your reign as chief minister of West Bengal did bring peace in Jangalmahal and North Bengal. I was also very impressed by the new and developed James Prinsep ghat on the banks of the Ganges. You are trying, I agree. But it isn’t good enough.

Like a friend says, “In the corridors of college hostel, whenever, your friends unnecessarily hassle you often the reply is ‘Danda mat kar’. Use of a metaphor is never bad in political discourse, only if it isn't as crass as this one”.

But Didi, for want of a contemporary example let us consider 'Bapu'. Even Mahatma Gandhi was a leader of the masses. Why can’t you emulate him? Do you need to get all impulsive and use such crass language? I had to hear quite a few jeers for your ‘bamboo on the backside’ remark. Don’t you have the slightest consideration for our reputation? Have some sympathy for us hapless 'Bangali' men and women who are working everywhere but in West Bengal (no industry, no jobs).

Please have some restraint for our sake. You are very passionate in your action and speech. I respect that. Be passionate but sober. You not only represent a state but also its people. I am sure that the bhadralok intelligentsia who rooted for you once are now banging their heads against the wall in a dark corner of some room. For them, it is a lesson learnt.

For us, it is misfortune after misfortune.

Yours faithfully,
A Bangali woman trying to hide her face
 

Comments

 

Other News

Ram Nath Kovind to be India’s next president

 India’s 14th president is going to be former Bihar governor Ram Nath Kovind, a dalit. He triumphed over former Lok Sabha speaker Meira Kumar in the vote count that took place on Thursday.   Kovind succeeds Pranab Mukherjee, who demits office on July 25. He becomes the

At JNU, all that is beautiful and “solid has melted into the air”…

Dear “Professor” Vice Chancellor,    When the clamour is made all around us, and rightly so, about the condition of growing degeneration of quality education in the higher institutions of learning in our country, you have justly – for which you must be

Making words count

In 2016, 38 bills were enacted in parliament. During that year, on average, the time spent on legislative debate (without interruptions) was 23 percent in the Lok Sabha and 16 percent in the Rajya Sabha (calculated from the PRS Legislative Research data).  Time is, however, just one measure

Business goes north

Tyre manufacturer MRF (originally Madras Rubber Factory), which enjoys instant brand recall thanks to the presence of its logo on cricket superstar Virat Kohli’s bat, figures among the most prominent industries in Tamil Nadu. But the state does not figure in its future plans. Like another TN industry

Do you think the Central Water Commission needs to take on the responsibility of irrigation governance?

Do you think the Central Water Commission needs to take on the responsibility of irrigation governance?

Debating the idea of privacy

Is right to privacy a fundamental right? The Supreme Court on Wednesday heard arguments on the contentious issue linked to the Aadhaar debate. Here`s how the issue has been addressed by different countries, with the first reference dating to 1890.   The Supreme Court on Tuesday s





Video

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter