CBI chief’s visitors: Civil society activists want whistle-blower protection

Aruna Roy and others write to CJI: “Is court being misled to focus on the source?”

GN Bureau | September 16, 2014



A group of civil society activists and commentators have written to the chief justice of India (CJI), pointing out that instead of focusing on who gave the alleged log-book of visitors at CBI director Ranjit Sinha’s residence, a special investigation team should be formed to probe the matter. Here is the text of their letter as assessed through an email from Shailesh Gandhi:

16 September 2014

To,

The Chief Justice,

Supreme Court of India


Dear Sir,

Nearly two weeks back a visitor’s diary was shown by Prashant Bhushan to the supreme court, which showed that a number of persons under investigation by CBI had been meeting its director at home quite frequently. If the allegation was true the CBI director should have at the very least been suspended.

Mr Ranjit Sinha at first did not challenge the veracity of the record but asked how it could have come to Prashant Bhushan. He then claimed that it was an intrusion on his privacy. He also stressed that he may have met a few persons who were being investigated and that some were family friends. On 12 September he demanded that Prashant Bhushan reveal the source of the diary.

On 15th, the supreme court has issued the same order. This order appears to go against the spirit of the Whistleblower’s Act passed by Parliament. It is true that the rules for the Act have not been made so far. But the nation and the courts had backed the idea and spirit of the whistleblower’s act. It appears to many citizens that the court is being misled into focusing on whether Mr Bhushan got the record legitimately. If the allegations are true the CBI director is getting enough opportunity to change, destroy or create evidence. People believe that this is a regular practice of those in power. The head of CBI is certainly a person of great power.

We request the court to kindly consider the following options:

1. Get all the supposed visitors who were being investigated or are likely to have been representatives of such persons to state whether they had visited the CBI director’s residence.

2. Get Mr Ranjit Sinha to give a statement as to which persons named in the visitor’s diary never came to his house and whether any of his staff was present at these.

3. Get a Special Investigation team of persons with proven integrity to go through the records of the CBI to see if any link can be established between the supposed visits and the CBI’s investigations subsequently and to talk with some of the supposed visitors.

If this has to be meaningful, the first two should be ordered to be done within a week, and last within four weeks. Justice Verma has demonstrated that a report on a complex matter can be submitted in this time. The credibility of the nation’s institutions is at stake and we request that the supreme court to consider our request. We admit that our plea may be considered irregular, but we believe it is necessary in the interest of the nation.

Yours truly,

Aruna Roy, Ajit Ranade, Jagdeep Chhokar, Nikhil Dey, Rajni Bakshi, Shailesh Gandhi, Trilochan Sastry, and others.

Comments

 

Other News

Hope Adityanath adjusts his public rhetoric to befit his new office: Expert

  Indian parties do not choose their politicians with a view to what the world might conclude, but there is no denying the signal Yogi Adityanath’s pick sends: with a huge mandate, the BJP has decided to lead with the face of religious nationalism—not the forward-looking, twe

The secret of Modi’s success

Here is a proposition: Narendra Modi is the top  thinker, the top intellectual of our times. Is that an exaggerated claim? Not altogether. Here’s why. After Brexit and after Trump, intellectuals, especially in the west, are busy guessing what exactly is going on in the world, what

Do you think campaigning by UP CM Yogi Adityanath in Delhi civic polls will boost BJP`s victory chances?

Do you think campaigning by UP CM Yogi Adityanath in Delhi civic polls will boost BJP`s victory chances?

Allow uninterrupted discussion on Finance Bill: Civil society to Hamid Ansari

Almost a week ago, Finance Bill, 2017, was passed in the Lok Sabha as a money bill in the midst of a walk out by the opposition.  In the 92-page document of the bill, centre has pushed 40 amendments to various acts including the IT Act. Eminent people like Fali Nariman, Girish Karnad, TM Krishna, Arun

BHEL unveils 250 MW eco-friendly lignite power plant in Gujarat

  Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (BHEL), a Maharatna PSU, has successfully commissioned 250 MW unit based on eco-friendly circulating fluidized bed combustion (CFBC) technology, using low grade coal (lignite) as the primary fuel.    The 250 MW lignite

Right to recall not recommended by law panel

  The Law Commission which had examined the issues of right to rejection and the right to recall, has not recommended for the same, the Lok Sabha was informed.   Union minister PP Chaudhary said that the Law Commission of India was requested in January, 2013,

Video

योगी आदित्यनाथ ने किया गृह प्रवेश

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter