A lot left unsaid in Sonia’s chintan shivir address

The Telengana issue, the Naxalite problem, the ideological challenge posed by Narendra Modi and his ilk and the faltering economy found no mention in her address.

bhavdeepkang

Bhavdeep Kang | January 18, 2013


Sonia Gandhi: Elected representatives must display greater accountability and demonstrable integrity.
Sonia Gandhi: Elected representatives must display greater accountability and demonstrable integrity.

Congress president Sonia Gandhi responded to civil society rage against black money, corruption and gender violence but failed to tackle contentious political issues in her inaugural address at the party's chintan shivir in Jaipur. A lot was left unsaid: the Telengana issue, the Naxalite problem, the ideological challenge posed by Narendra Modi and his ilk and the faltering economy found no mention in her address.

It was a transparent attempt at controlling the negative fallout of the coalgate and telecom scams, the Anna Hazare agitation for a Lokpal Bill and the brutal bus rape in Delhi. While appearing to share the concerns of civil society, the Congress is clearly worried that prime minister Manmohan Singh's middle class votaries – who celebrated his “clean” image in UPA I – have abandoned him in UPA II.

In a reference to black money, she said, “Lavish and ostentatious displays of wealth (by party leaders)...begs the question...of where this wealth is coming from.” Driving home the point, she said elected representatives must display “greater accountability and demonstrable integrity”. The educated middle class' protest against corruption had led to a churning to which the party must respond, she added.

She was equally emphatic in condemning the continuing atrocities and discrimination against women. In doing so, she was reaching out to a demographic that has so far eluded the Congress: the educated upper class woman. Studies have shown that while women as a whole prefer the Congress, the urban educated rich segment leans towards the BJP.

The other significant aspect of the Congress president's speech was a subtle warning both to Congress party veterans on the one hand and to UPA constituents on the other. At a time when the diesel price hike has agitated the UPA's allies, Sonia Gandhi said that in seeking alliances and dealing with partners, the party could not compromise its position, even while treating their viewpoints with respect. It was a clear signal to the allies that they should not cross their limits.

She expressed deep concern over the eroding vote base of the party in several states, indicating to the Congress old guard that a business-as-usual attitude would no longer be acceptable. The party would have to take note of the changing social and technological scenario and accommodate the aspirations of youth. But she also sent a signal to the youngsters by saying that performance would be the only ladder for advancement in the party.

The tone of the address was different from that of Pachmarhi and Shimla, when the party was on the offensive and more concerned about political issues – whether to go it alone or be open to a coalition. Today, the tone was defensive. It was an oblique acknowledgement of the government's failings (in containing corruption and ensuring gender justice) even while praising it for taking “revolutionary” steps and blaming the party for not being able to encash them.

Once again, she raised the issue of party discipline and called for honest introspection of its strengths and weaknesses – an old raga heard at Pachmarhi and again at Shimla. A passing reference to the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Bill was made and the usual concern for the agricultural sector and need for employment for youth expressed.

By the much awaited stance on smaller states was not spelled out. Nor was their any affirmation of a strong secular coalition against the resurgent right. There was no indication of what direction the economy would take in coming months and how the UPA proposes to come to grips with the Naxalite problem.
 

Comments

 

Other News

`India’s media & entertainment sector poised for historic leap`

The global Media & Entertainment (M&E) industry is on the brink of a major transformation as it marches toward 2030. International revenues are projected to reach $3.5 trillion by 2029, driven by a 3.7% CAGR between 2024 and 2029. This growth will be powered by the dominance of digital advertising,

The India we live in, the India it is

We proudly describe our nation as a land of Unity in Diversity. We have long celebrated our civilization based on plurality, where differences have been seen, not as threats but as expressions of a greater unity. From Kashmir to Kanyakumari, we rejoice our innumerable languages, castes, creeds, an

Intellectual toolkit to make sense of the world

Steven Pinker’s latest major work, ‘When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life’, is an intellectually thrilling expedition into the heart of human society. Its core argument is that the secret to understanding why mark

Study uncovers genetic susceptibility behind high oral cancer burden in India

A Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS) conducted by the Centre for Cancer Epidemiology (CCE) of the Advanced Centre for Treatment, Research and Education in Cancer (ACTREC) at the Tata Memorial Centre here has uncovered critical gen

This standout collection of essays marks 50 years of Emergency

50 Years of the Indian Emergency: Lessons for Democracy Edited by Peter Ronald deSouza and Harsh Sethi Orient BlackSwan, 338 pages, Rs 1025

Checkmate on carbon: Chess strategies for India’s climate economy

The climate crisis is no longer a peripheral debate but a central determinant of economic resilience, particularly for emerging economies like India. Much like a grandmaster sitting before a 64-square battlefield, policymakers and market actors are compelled to strategize in advance, balancing short-term s

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter