Mr Tharoor, Sreesanth not guilty but not 'not guilty' either

... Unless proven otherwise, that is. While Delhi Police claims to have circumstantial evidence against the cricketer, CBI has more than that against Ashwani Kumar, and a case can be made out against Bansal, too. None of them are above suspicion, as is being bandied out by Congress in open season of irregularities.

shantanu

Shantanu Datta | May 16, 2013



More than murky, the arrest of S Sreesanth and two other cricketers from Rajasthan Royals team is getting to be more thrilling than most IPL matches this season.

While union minister of state for HRD Shashi Tharoor is reportedly batting for the Kerala cricketer, at least as of now, his family is smelling deep conspiracy, alleging that Indian cricket team captain MS Dhoni and off-spinner Harbhajan Singh are framing him.

“Sreesanth is a good player and Keralites are proud of him,” Tharoor said on Thursday, according to a report on the Malayala Manorama website.

That’s all right, but Tharoor's "Keralite" pride does not prove Sreesanth's innocence.

So the junior minister explains in more detail. “You know there is a maxim that one is innocent until proven guilty. So let us not judge his guilt until the proof has been provided, the courts have gone through the process, his defence is heard. I’m not prepared to condemn him until there is a conclusive determination of guilt. All I can say (is) that it is a very sad day for those of us who like Sreesanth and his contribution to cricket,” the minister, forced to quit from the union cabinet three years ago after his name was dragged in the IPL mess involving the Kochi team where Sreesanth was a star player, was quoted as saying.

That is the new defence for the Congress: with so many proverbial skeletons tumbling out the closet, if the party had a jail to house all the accused, it would be full house by now. So, the next best argument is: innocent until proven guilty — be it Pawan Kumar Bansal or Ashwani Kumar over the last few days, or Sreesanth now.

What Tharoor, and the other Congress leaders defending their tainted leaders, forget is that innocent does not mean a not guilty verdict. It does not mean they are above suspicion, for the accused still remains an accused; just as a suspect remains a suspect — till proven otherwise.

So if the “maxim that one is innocent until proven guilty” holds true, as Tharoor reminded the country this morning, it should also hold good that the same person is not blameless — or “not guilty” — unless proven innocent. In Sreesanth’s case, the Delhi Police special cell claims to have zeroed in on Sreesanth, along with Rajasthan Royal teammates Ankit Chavan and Ajit Chandilia, in Mumbai soon after their match with Mumbai Indians at Wankhede Stadium after keeping the players’ phone on surveillance.

According to reports by PTI and television channels, the special cell had been tracking — or tapping — phones of several cricketers for a while now, and found evidence of match fixing — be it fixing the whole game or bits and pieces of it, or what is dubbed spot fixing.

That, Tharoor is certainly aware, is circumstantial evidence, which automatically makes him a suspect, if not guilty, and thus certainly not above board. And that is precisely why BCCI has suspended the three cricketers pending inquiry.

In Ashwani Kumar’s case, the law enforcement agencies have more than just circumstantial evidence, while a case could be made out against Bansal, too. Either way, none of the three are above suspicion. They may not be guilty unless proven, but they definitely are not innocent until proven so.

Comments

 

Other News

How infra development is shaping India story

India is the world’s fifth largest economy with a GDP of USD 3.7 trillion today, and it is expected to become the third largest economy with a GDP of USD 5 trillion in five years. The Narendra Modi-led government aims to make India a developed country by 2047. A key driver of this economic growth and

75 visitors from abroad watch world’s largest elections unfold

As a beacon of electoral integrity and transparency, the Election Commission of India (ECI) exemplifies its commitment to conduct general elections of the highest standards, offering a golden bridge for global Election Management Bodies (EMBs) to witness democratic excellence first-hand. It continues foste

‘Oral cancer deaths in India cause productivity loss of 0.18% GDP’

A first-of-its-kind study on the economic loss due to premature death from oral cancer in India by the Tata Memorial Centre has found that this form of cancer has a premature mortality rate of 75.6% (34 premature events / 45 total events) resulting in productivity loss of approximately $5.6 billion in 2022

Days of Reading: Upendra Baxi recalls works that shaped his youth

Of Law and Life Upendra Baxi in Conversation with Arvind Narrain, Lawrence Liang, Sitharamam Kakarala, and Sruti Chaganti Orient BlackSwan, Rs 2,310

Voting by tribal communities blossoms as ECI’s efforts bear fruit

The efforts made by the Election Commission of India (ECI), over last two years, for inclusion of Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTG) communities and other tribal groups in the electoral process have borne fruit with scenes of tribal groups in various states/UTs participating enthusiastically in t

GST revenue for April 2024 at a new high

The gross Goods and Services Tax (GST) collections hit a record high in April 2024 at ₹2.10 lakh crore. This represents a significant 12.4% year-on-year growth, driven by a strong increase in domestic transactions (up 13.4%) and imports (up 8.3%). After accounting for refunds, the net GST

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter