Radical change can wait; pragmatism rules for now

Modi promised a clean break from politics-as-usual, but cabinet expansion signals a return to casteism and cronyism

ajay

Ajay Singh | November 10, 2014


President Pranab Mukherjee, vice-president Hamid Ansari and PM Narendra Modi with the newly inducted ministers at Rashtrapati Bhavan in New Delhi
PIB Photo

A day is a long time in politics. November 9, the day when prime minister Narendra Modi expanded his cabinet, was such a day. Every moment of the induction of 21 new members in the council of minister was suffused with a sense of déjà vu. Hence, the event was devoid of novelty. The Shiv Sena’s attempt to introduce an element of suspense was also so predictable that the 40-minute function at the Rashtrapati Bhavan proved to be a drab affair.

Contrast this with the hopes Modi had raised just before he had taken over. He was quite categorical in his insistence that his maxim of “minimum government and maximum governance” would not be a mere slogan but would be turned into reality. This was the precise reason why he asked a team of his officials, including the new principal secretary, to restructure governance. They dutifully worked out verticals through which many ministries were either merged or obliterated to ensure effective governance. There were all indications that the new PM was determined to break the mould and embark on a new style of governance.

November 9 can be counted as a day that belied the great expectations. Here was the prime minister who removed his railway minister after merely five months – and not for trivial reasons. Those aware of the gossip in the Rail Bhavan would know that Sadanand Gowda’s inefficiency and indiscretion were unparalleled in the annals of the railways. No doubt, Suresh Prabhu is an excellent choice, and he is known to be highly efficient. Yet he is bequeathed with a dubious legacy that needs to be sorted out first.

Now look at the caste calculus that determined the contours of the expanded cabinet. In Bihar where the assembly elections are slated in less than a year, Giriraj Singh was chosen in the council ministers ignoring the controversy that surrounds him. The recovery of a huge sum of unaccounted money from his residence after the Lok Sabha elections is still a case in progress. His induction was clearly aimed at winning over Bhumihars while Rajiv Pratap Rudy was brought in to rope in Rajputs. Similarly, Mahesh Sharma from Noida, a doctor by profession and owner of Kailash Hospital, was selected to pacify Brahmins in Uttar Pradesh. Though Sharma claims to be a philanthropist, the phenomenal growth in his business is a testimony to his enormous clout in UP cutting across party lines.

The induction of turncoats like Birender Singh and Ram Kripal Yadav in the council of minister was clearly a reward for opportunism. In both cases, the castes and not credentials determined their political ascendancy. Singh, a jat from Haryana, found favour with the BJP for having delivered Haryana to the party’s kitty. In the same vein, Yadav is expected to wean away yadavs from Lalu Prasad in Bihar to turn the situation around for the BJP. “Principles” become a convenient fig leaf to cover up crass opportunism.

For those who have witnessed the solemn ceremony of swearing-in many a times, it will be difficult to miss the ringing sound of pious pledge, “I will do right to all manner of people in accordance with the constitution and the law without fear or favour, affection or ill-will.” But invariably this pledge has been violated in letter and spirit for years on end. November 9 was hardly an exception. Dr Harsh Vardhan was removed as health minister and replaced by Jay Prakash Nadda, a leader from Himachal Pradesh, who was accused of persecuting Sanjeev Chaturvedi, an IFS officer and whistle-blower posted as central vigilance officer (CVO) in AIIMS. The circumstances in which the change was effected will raise questions about the government’s conduct.

These issues are flagged not out of cynicism. Far from it. What is intended here is highlighting the people’s aspirations for change and expectations from the government. Modi seems to have initially responded to those impulses when he promised to change the culture of governance. His selection of colleagues like Manohar Parrikar is particularly praiseworthy. Similarly he was acutely conscious of choosing men with impeccable records in Haryana and Maharashtra, two crucial states with huge economic significance, as chief ministers. Yet he seemed to be afflicted by the usual bug of casteism and cronyism in the next stage of politics. Perhaps he may be guided by pragmatism that prompts him to stick to stated truism. As the adage goes, the more things change, the more they remain the same.

Comments

 

Other News

Bangladesh to get high-speed diesel from Numaligarh refinery

A sale-purchase agreement was signed between Numaligarh Refinery Limited (NRL) and Bangladesh Petroleum Corporation (BPC) for supply of high speed diesel (HSD) through the proposed 131 km Indo-Bangla friendship pipeline.    The agree

Ajay Maken fails to charm Delhi

The dismal performance of the Congress in the Municipal Corporations of Delhi elections forced party chief Ajay Maken to announce his resignation, ending an energetic effort to revive the party in the national capital.   Ajay Maken, now 53, had taken over as the chief

AAP in hot water following MCD poll debacle

The BJP’s clean sweep is not just a referendum on the Arvind Kejriwal government, but also could mark the beginning of the end of one of India’s youngest political parties, the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP). After the Bharatiya Janata Party’s massive win in the UP assembly elections, th

Will make Delhi corruption free: Manoj Tiwari after BJP win

In an interview with Governance Now after BJP’s victory in all the three municipal corporations of Delhi, Delhi BJP president Manoj Tiwari said that the focus will be on sanitation and effort will be to make Delhi free of corruption. What are BJP`s immediate goals a

NBCC to get technology from Poland for energy efficient buildings

In order to jointly promote, develop and adopt external thermal insulation and composite systems (ETICS) solutions technology in construction of highly energy efficient green buildings, NBCC (India) Limited and Bolix, SA of Poland have inked a memorandum of business exploration (MoBE).  

Shiva Sanjari talks about her documentary on the first woman filmmaker of Iran

Iranian documentary filmmaker Shiva Sanjari is known for her documentary Here the Seats are Vacant, about the first woman filmmaker of Iran. The movie was shown at the 13th International Association of Women in Radio and Television (IAWRT) Asian Women’s Film Festival.



Video

फिर खिला कमल, कांग्रेस-आप का हुआ बुरा हाल

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter