Rape crime is not negotiable, say lawyers on bail for TN rapist

Madras HC judge’s order of mediation in rape case blasted by activists and lawyers

shivani

Shivani Chaturvedi | June 26, 2015


#madras   #high court   #rape   #rapist   #mediation   #devadass   #women  

Lawyers and women's rights activists have termed the order as unacceptable and shocking. These are public reactions against the controversial order of justice P Devadass of the Madras high court in a rape case. Early this week justice Devadass accepted the bail of a rapist and directed him to mediate with his victim.

Advocate Ajtha of Madras high court says, "It is a complete injustice in the particular case. The case is not in a position to come to table for mediation. This order only shows inefficiency of courts."

"Article 14, which says, equality before law and that all people should be treated equally, is not unknown to this judge. Would this judge given the same statement had the victim been from any rich or influential family?" she asks.

When it comes to poor people, judges' verdicts are different, the advocate said.

"Rape is an inexcusable crime. It is not an offence that can be negotiated away,” said senior advocate and rights activist Sudha Ramalingam.

“Unfortunately, there have been several instances through the years where the courts have tried to mediate and find 'solutions' including marriage of the victim to the rapist, or compensation to the victim, in lieu of imprisonment. Criminal law regards rape as a serious offence and does not allow for compounding, i.e. withdrawal of the case by the victim," Sudha said.

The Madras high court has again recommended alternate dispute resolution (ADR) in a case of rape. The decision of justice Devadoss appears to endorse negotiation, or mediation in case of rape. In his judgment, he states that the true victim of the crime is actually the child that the victim gave birth to. Therefore, the court has suggested that through alternate dispute resolution, the accused and the victim find an amicable solution which would then be used to mitigate the sentence of imprisonment. For this reason, the court had released the accused on bail, she adds.

ADR is only suitable for civil cases where essential rights of individuals are not at stake, Sudha says. Serious offences such as rape are not amenable to plea bargaining, or compounding. Whilst so, referring this case to mediation sets a dangerous and undesirable precedent.

It must be remembered that crimes against women were, until recently, regarded as taboo topics, never to be discussed in public or even dealt with seriously. Looking at them through the lens of shame rather than rights had resulted in serious underreporting and also witnesses (including survivor of crime herself) turning hostile resulting in acquittals. It has been a long uphill battle to raise awareness and sensitise the public as to the seriousness and scale of violence against women. Given this history, it is regressive to endorse ADR in case of rape as it appears to trivialize the underlying offence, she said.

Comments

 

Other News

“Private hospitals functioning in regulatory vacuum”

Patients and health groups came together in Delhi to voice concerns over the unethical practices of private hospitals, which they say are a direct outcome of the regulatory vacuum, allowing them to monetize the vulnerability of patients. The study of the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority (NPPA) tha

UP Investor Summit: Will promise convert into performance?

The UP investors’ summit has received an overwhelming response. On the opening day, Wednesday, 1,045 memorandums of understanding (MoUs) worth Rs 4.28 trillion were signed at the summit – and as it closes today the figure is only going to go up. With big-ticket investments from

Why Virat Kohli, Priyanka Chopra should not quit as brand ambassadors

After becoming the brand ambassador for Punjab National Bank in 2016, cricket star Virat Kohli has appeared in advertisements promoting a variety of loans. Now that PNB is in deep soup over an alleged Rs 11,400 crore scandal, Kohli is expected to end his contract with the bank. That may not be fair.

Kamal Hassan`s political films

Kamal Hassan, who launched his political party Makkal Needhi Maiam on Wednesday, has acted in films with political themes or making a social commentary. Here are four of them:   1) Hey Ram!: He plays the role of a would-be assassin of Mahatma Gandhi who changes his mind and decid

Chief secy controversy yet again exposes AAP’s political immaturity

The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), for all its talk of high ideals, had an image problem right from its inception: that it was a motley crew of politically naïve people. When the going was good, this image came very handy. Arvind Kejriwal and Co. were seen as a fresh new alternative to the usual run-of-the-mi

Tales from the defence world to give heart to Modi & Sitharaman

Prime minister Narendra Modi and defence minister Nirmala Sitharaman are in the midst of one direct attack, one insidious insinuation and a special kind of offensive. These concerted actions have emerged after both firmly showed their hand and spoke their mind on going down the indigenous path for most o

Current Issue

Current Issue

Video

CM Nitish’s convoy attacked in Buxar

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter