Indian Politicians’ Servants?

That’s what IPS has been reduced to, says one who opted out. 1/3rd civil servants think like him

sanjpandey

Sanjay Pandey | August 4, 2010



I grew up in a middle-class family in Uttar Pradesh. During those days, students all around me had just one aspiration: to make it to the civil services. This burning ambition cut across students pursuing all sorts of courses. I remember even some of the brighter minds at the  Indian Institute of Technology competing for civil services. Despite being a student of computer science, I too opted for a combination of physics and sociology to make it to the Indian Police Service. I was overjoyed at achieving my goal and so was my entire family. Never could I imagine that one day I would actually end up quitting the same force.

Nothing had prepared me for the disillusionment that began as early as during the training right at my induction. For me, the dinner table had always been a casual affair. But it was not so in the police. One had to dress properly to eat in the mess. I found it terribly difficult to come to terms with this regimentation.

The mandatory unquestioning and undue submission to seniors came as a blow to my upbringing as a freethinking individual straight out of the intellectual atmosphere prevalent at the IIT Kanpur. While training in the northern part of Maharashtra, I found the absolute dictatorial regime of some of my seniors unpalatable and unwarranted. Thinking that it was too early for me to take any drastic decision, I suffered several years of absolute dictatorial rule of my seniors.

While I suffered the harrassment of seniors during my early years in the service, later, during my stint with the economic offences cell, I came face to face with the reality of absolute subservience of the service to political masters and the powers usurped by the political powers running the government.

Just when I thought I was doing a great service to the nation, investigating a huge fraud of embezzlement of soft loans meant for cobblers by big businessmen close to our political rulers in Mumbai, I was moved out of my post.  I was shocked that my work was nowhere near completion and yet I was shunted out, in the guise of routine administrative transfers. I was relieved of my responsibilities even before I could brief my successor on the details of the eight months of investigations that I had done. Though a few well-wishers in the ranks offered me some moral support, they were helpless as they themselves were at the mercy of these powerful political masters.

A few years later, on the advice of some well-meaning seniors in the service, I joined the elite group which looks after the security of the prime minister. I believed that in this assignment there would be no conflict with the political powers, since there was no executive role to play.

However, within a few months I realised that this job more than anything else made me a personal effect of political masters. In the name of providing security to the prime minister, I was primarily managing the tour programmes of the prime minster and ex-prime ministers. If I was not travelling with the prime minister and his predecessors, I was guarding their houses, maintaining the daily lists of guests and servants who visited his house. I was playing the role of a well-paid personal servant. This humiliated me as an IPS officer. It was this job along with my experiences with senior servants and political masters that made me decide that it was time to move on.
No one wants to be a servant. Most colleagues in service never even talk of themselves as being one. They refer to themselves as government officers. My 14 years in service made me realise that while the outside world referred to us as officers, in the system we were just glorified servants to the political masters. If any of us did not behave as a servant, punishments came swift and drastic.
Political masters call the shots and keep to themselves the magnanimity of granting mercy petitions. Once you get entangled, there is no way to get out I was lucky to have made a decision early on and built my career as an individual and not as a personal effect of either a senior servant or a politician.

This first appeared in the June 16-30 issue of the Governance Now magazine (Vol. 01, Issue 10)

Working with tied hands?

Findings of a recent survey:

  • 34 percent civil servants have thought of quitting the job, mainly due to political interference, mediocrity, corruption, better pay in the private sector and conformity.
  • 81 percent officers across services believe political corruption takes place because there are some civil servants willing to collaborate in it.
  • 52 percent respondents believe that postings and transfers are not based on merit.
  • One-fourth civil servants believe very few officers have integrity.
  • 36 percent of the respondents reported that they had been a victim of harassment in their service.


The Centre for Good Governance, Hyderabad, along with AC NielsenORG-MARG carried out the survey, which included responses from 4,808
officers of various services.

Comments

 

Other News

Understanding Bharat’s history from its own perspective

Eminent Distorians: Twists and Truths in Bharat`s History By Utpal Kumar BluOne Ink, 334 pages

‘MAGA’ + ‘MIGA’ = ‘MEGA’ partnership for prosperity: Modi

Prime minister Narendra Modi has linked the dream of a Viksit Bharat with US president Donald Trump’s slogan, ‘Make America Great Again’, or ‘MAGA’, saying that when these two democracies work together, i.e. ‘MAGA’ plus ‘Make India Great Again’ (‘

ONOE: Anti-federalism or pro-reform?

The government`s move to implement ‘One Nation, One Election’ (ONOE) has ignited widespread debate. On one hand, it offers tangible benefits, such as removing the possibility of a governance paralysis and reducing election costs. On the other hand, the opposition and sections of civil society s

PM Surya Ghar: Muft Bijli Yojana completes first year

On February 13, 2025, the PM Surya Ghar: Muft Bijli Yojana (PMSGMBY) will mark its first anniversary, celebrating a year of empowering households with affordable solar energy and accelerating India’s transition to a sustainable future. Launched by prime minister Narendra Modi on Febru

How to leverage AI to solve urgent global issues

The world seems to be hurling towards World War III in all the possible scenarios: hot war, cold war, and proxy war. The battleground seems to have expanded beyond physical to digital or virtual/mixed reality with technology like drones. Moreover, the line between civilian and military targets seems to hav

Budget: Progress towards SDGs and areas for improvement

The Union Budget 2025-26 outlines India`s vision for economic and social growth while also reflecting the country`s commitment to sustainable development. As India moves closer to the 2030 deadline for the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), this budget presents a balanced approach

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now



Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter