Why a hero gets a zero

Dismal appraisal of Magsaysay winner raises questions

pankaj

Pankaj Kumar | April 17, 2017 | New Delhi


#AIIMS   #Ashok Khemka   #JP Nadda   #whistle blower   #Sanjiv Chaturvedi   #corruption   #Ramon Magsaysay award winners   #Durga Shakti Nagpal  



Remember Sanjiv Chaturvedi? The one who won the 2015 Ramon Magsaysay for his crusade against corruption. The whistle-blower officer has been facing difficulties from various regimes, and the latest is the BJP. 

The 2002-batch IFS officer received his appraisal for 2015-16 in January. And the health ministry gave him a zero grading. 
 
Ironically, as per an affidavit filed before the Delhi high court on March 6, the Intelligence Bureau (IB) in its confidential report for annual evaluation had found him to be a “diligent officer”.

Justifying his dismal evaluation, the union health minister JP Nadda added insult to injury with these words: “I have gone through the reports of the reporting and reviewing authorities. However, since I have never directly monitored the performance of the officer reported upon and am not in position to form an independent opinion on it, as such, I cannot but agree with the assessment of his immediate superiors.”

Moreover, he was given zero in his performance report for the same year in which he was conferred with the Magsaysay award. 

At present, Chaturvedi is posted as conservator of forest (research) at Haldwani in Uttarakhand. 
 
What happened at AIIMS

Chaturvedi made a name when he unearthed a series of scams in Haryana and earned the wrath of the Congress government of Bhupinder Singh Hooda. He shifted to the centre, and was appointed as deputy director of AIIMS, New Delhi, in 2012, and was given an additional charge of chief vigilance officer (CVO) at the institute, but he has no relief from the new regime either. As the CVO, he initiated action in over 200 corruption cases between 2012 and 2014, leading to his removal from the post of CVO (though he retained the post of deputy director).  

Dr MC Mishra, the AIIMS director who had consistently awarded him a grade of 9.5 (out of 10) in 2013-14 and 2014-15, gave him only 1 in 2015-16.
As per the instructions issued by the department of personnel and training, any grade between 0-4 is considered ‘zero’ for the purpose of promotion and other service matters.  
 
And in Haryana

Low rating are not new for Chaturvedi. During his stint as a forest officer in Haryana from 2005 to 2012, he exposed many corruption cases for which he was always at confrontation with the Hooda government. He was graded 3.5 out of 10 for two consecutive years (2010-11 and 2011-12). But these gradings were restored as outstanding through a presidential order in January 2014. 
 
He was allegedly harassed by the Hooda government throughout his stint in the state. The state government refused to relieve him for central deputation; constituted an inquiry committee against him, accusing him of inefficiency; and tried to downgrade his appraisal. Between 2008 and 2014, the president passed four orders in his support, quashing Hooda’s  orders. 
 
Chaturvedi is not the only one

Ashok Khemka, an IAS officer, has been transferred over 40 times in 23 years of his service after he exposed corruption in departments in which he was posted. He shot to fame in 2012 when he cancelled Congress chief Sonia Gandhi’s son-in-law Robert Vadra’s illegal land deal in Gurgaon. 

Durga Shakti Nagpal, another IAS officer, launched a large-scale operation to stop illegal sand mining in Gautambudh Nagar in 2013. The illegal sand mining was flourishing due to an alleged nexus between politicians and miners. She was suspended for allegedly demolishing an illegal mosque wall in a village in Greater Noida.  
 
Targeting officials like Chaturvedi, Khemka and Nagpal is a major reason why the bureaucracy, supposedly comprising of the most learned officials who run the day-to-day administration of the country, suffers from major corruption and incompetency. 
 

(The article appears in the April 16-30, 2017 issue of Governance Now)
 
 

Comments

 

Other News

Maharashtra Aggregator Cabs Policy flawed: IFAT

On May 21, 2025, Maharashtra issued a government resolution (GR) on its Aggregator Cabs Policy 2025 to formalize the largely unregulated sector. The guidelines outline the framework on ride cancellations, surge pricing, driver earnings, among others for app based services like Ola, Uber. Now, the Indian Fe

The Northeast the most diverse region of our diverse nation: PM

Prime minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the Rising North East Investors Summit 2025 at Bharat Mandapam, New Delhi on Friday. Welcoming the dignitaries to the event, the PM expressed pride, warmth, and immense confidence in the future of the North East region. He recalled the recent Ashtalakshmi Mahot

MMRDA proposes formation of Fare Fixation Committee for Metro Lines 2A & 7

Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) has proposed the constitution of a Fare Fixation Committee (FFC) for Mumbai Metro Lines 2A and 7, currently operated by Maha Mumbai Metro Operation Corporation Limited (MMMOCL). ‘Fare Fixation’ is mandated under Section 33

‘Op Sindoor not an act of revenge, but a new form of justice’

Emphasizing that Operation Sindoor was not an act of revenge, but a new form of justice, prime minister Narendra Modi on Thursday remarked that it was not just an expression of outrage but a display of India`s unwavering strength and determination. He asserted that the nation has adopted a bold approach, s

An ode to the enduring legacy of India’s temple culture

Dynasties of Devotion: The Secrets of 7 Iconic Hindu Temples By Deepa Mandlik (Translated from the Marathi by Aboli Mandlik) HarperCollins, 232 pages, Rs 399

How to improve India’s crèche system

India stands at a pivotal moment, caught between the promise of a demographic dividend and the crisis of gender inequality. While falling fertility rates, rising female education, and increasing labour force participation signal progress, policymakers continue to neglect one of the most invisible yet vital

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now



Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter