• About Us
  • Feedback
  • Events Calendar
  • Archives
  • Newsletter
Advanced Search
  • Home
  • News
  • Views
  • GovNow
  • GovNext
  • Login
  • Register
News
  • Top Stories
  • Public Reporter
  • Photo Story
  • Protests & Petitions
  • GNtv
Views
  • Day's Debate
  • Columns
  • Think Tank
  • Interview
  • GNtalk
  • Backstory
GovNow
  • Parliament
  • Your MP
  • Bureaucracy
  • Judiciary
  • Policy
GovNext
  • RTI
  • eGov
  • GreenGov
  • GovPitch
Follow Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
Home › Views › Day's Debate › Is SpiceJet's apology to a differently-abled passenger enough?

Is SpiceJet's apology to a differently-abled passenger enough?

GN Bureau | February 20 2012

Share

SpiceJet pilot Utprabh Tiwari deplaned a woman with cerebral palsy from a Goa-bound flight deciding all by himself that the woman couldn't fly alone. Ironically, Jeeja Ghosh, a 42-year-old teacher at the Indian Institute of Cerebral Palsy, was on her way to a conference on mainstreaming the differently-abled.

The airline personnel, who refused to give Ghosh a written explanation for deboarding her, said that they had failed to convince Tiwari to let her fly. Spicejet issued an apology later and said it was conducting an internal investigation.

However, the question to ask is why hasn't the airline suspended the prejudiced pilot pending inquiry?  The civil aviation authority rules state that medical clearance must not be sought from a passenger unless he or she is known to be suffering from a contagious disease or is in no condition to fly unattended. Tiwari's insistence on deboarding Ghosh smacks of poor understanding of disabilities and normative prejudices. The struggle of the differently-abled citizens to be treated on a par with the general population is undermined by such incidences. So, SpiceJet has not only wronged Ghosh, it has set the cause of the mainstreaming the differently-abled back by leaps. A mere apology does not suffice. SpiceJet and other airlines should consider sensitising their staff to the differently-abled.

Considering this broad argument and any that you may have, do you think that more than an apology, a visible action against the pilot and maybe against the airline would set the right precedent? Is there a need to go beyond words in this case? Post your thoughts.

Related stories

Stories you might like

More stories in this section

Is bad governance, and not market forces, behind the petrol hike?
Should MPs get red beacons?
Will amnesty help recover black money?

Poll

Is SpiceJet's apology to a differently-abled passenger enough?
Yes
0% (0 votes)
No
94.1% (16 votes)
Can't Say
5.9% (1 votes)
Comments posted as an unregistered user will need to be approved by an editor. If you would like to post comments without delay, please register / login.
Comments : 4
View:
Somasundaram's picture
Somasundaram

Cant blame the pilot also. This may be the first instance for the pilot. He might have got frightened and felt she couldnt manage to travel alone. Pilots are not doctors. Feel the lady could have carried a Doctor Certificate to the effect that she can travel alone whether by flights, rails, ships, etc. It is a lesson now. All the staff should be educated and trained as to how to treat special such passengers. What else the Airlines could do? They have promptly apologized. It is not thatI donthave any sympathy or simply supporting the Airlines for obvious reasons. On seeing the lady being flashed every now and then on each and every media channel, I felt the pain immensely and came to the conclusion that the media should have given the news alone instead flashing her which is deterimental to her dignity. I dont know how to blow out my feelings. If I am wrong in expressing my feelings, I may please be excused by one and all. Thanks.

2 months 3 weeks ago
  • reply
Mark's picture
Mark (not verified)

Once he is deplaned he has no choice but to clean the toilet! To ensure that he is recovered from his illness, this pilot should be made to clean public toilets...

3 months 4 hours ago
  • reply
Suman Ghosh's picture
Suman Ghosh (not verified)

Let the idiot pilot clean toilets of the person he deplaned...

3 months 18 hours ago
  • reply
Mark's picture
Mark (not verified)

In a way the pilot is also suffering sort of cerebral palsy to take such decision. He too should be stopped from flying!

3 months 2 days ago
  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Input format
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters (without spaces) shown in the image.

In This Section

  • Most Emailed
  • Most Popular
  • Most Commented
  • I just want to be a change agent - Nilekani...
  • e-Gov lessons from Estonia!...
  • Gandhi in Egypt...
  • Shouldn't the PM come within the ambit of Lok...
2G anna hazare Bihar BJP CBI china congress corruption Delhi DoT e-governance facebook Gujarat High Court India jairam ramesh Kapil Sibal Karnataka Maharashtra Manmohan Singh Mumbai parliament P Chidambaram Pranab Mukherjee prime minister rajya sabha RTI supreme court US Uttar Pradesh
more tags
News
  • Top Stories
  • Public Reporter
  • Photo Story
  • Protests & Petitions
  • GNtv
Views
  • Day's Debate
  • Columns
  • Think Tank
  • Interview
  • GNtalk
  • Backstory
GovNow
  • Parliament
  • Your MP
  • Bureaucracy
  • Judiciary
  • Policy
GovNext
  • RTI
  • eGov
  • GreenGov
  • GovPitch
Follow Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
Copyright ©2010 Governance Now
  • Copyright Info
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Help
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
Developed by LDI