All benches should appreciate SC ruling on Singur: Medha Patkar

Medha Patkar, social activist and leader of National Alliance of People’s Movements talks about SC ruling on Singur

sreelatha

Sreelatha Menon | September 16, 2016


#NANO   #Ratan Tata   #Land grap   #SC   #West Bengal   #Farmers   #Singur   #Medha Patkar   #National Alliance of Peoples Movements  
Medha Patkar, social activist and leader of National Alliance of People’s Movements
Medha Patkar, social activist and leader of National Alliance of People’s Movements

Now that the SC has given the judgment for returning the land of the farmers in Singur, does this guarantee similar rulings for farmers protesting against acquisition of land in other parts of the country?
There are no such guarantees. Different benches are giving different judgments. In fact, since the Land Acquisition Act, 2013 came into being, 25 judgments have come on ‘public purpose’ and all are different. Everything has to be fought and fought and fought. Look at the Sardar Sarovar Project. It is the 31st year of our fight and we are still fighting. As for this judgment, it is by one bench. All benches should appreciate it. All benches of the apex court and other courts should speak in one voice on land acquisition.
 
So what is the significance of the judgment?
It is as historic as the Singur farmers’ movement was. It is significant for mainly two reasons: First, it takes a stand on protecting fertile agricultural land, and does not discriminate between those farmers who received compensation and those who refused to take it. When we went to Singur in the beginning of the protests, we were arguing that the land being taken from farmers was not barren but fertile. I, Mahasweta Devi and all activists of the Singur movement were present. We took pictures in the fields to prove that fertile land was being taken when barren land was available.
 
Secondly, the movement succeeded as most farmers remained firm on their stand. While nearly 1,000 acres of land was taken, owners of about 400 acres refused to accept compensation. The others were under pressure to take it. The judgment will now help all the owners get back their land.
What was the role of the West Bengal government?
One should first salute the farmers who bravely fought, even without taking compensation. But this ruling would not have been possible if the Mamata Banerjee government had not supported the petition in court. The best part is that the Left parties are also now on our side.
But wasn’t the Singur situation created by the Left?
The Left has however been part of the fight against the retrograde land ordinance of the Modi government and it opposed all the three ordinances along with movements and other parties.
 
So what should we expect now?
What we must have now is political unity, at least in Bengal, on land issues. The reason is that in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and other BJP-ruled states, land legislations have been made which are exact replicas of the anti-farmer Modi ordinance. Hence, political unity is very essential. 
The judgment is being seen as anti-industry and anti-industrialisation. Is that true?
It won’t come in the way of industry. Industry and agriculture should complement each other. Aren’t they both meant for the good of society?
 
Can’t Tata Motors appeal against the judgment?
I feel that the Tatas should also welcome the judgment. They should show that they are different from the stereotypes that we see in the industrial sector
 
Even according to the 2013 Act, land not used should be returned to the original owners. Is that helping anyone?
About 40,000 hectares were acquired from various people for the Sardar Sarovar Project. According to the 2013 Act, they are all owners again as the government never took possession of the acquired land. The Indore high court has even stayed the acquisition. Now if the government of Madhya Pradesh wishes to get that land, it has to acquire it again, take consent, and so on.
 
(The interview appears in September 16-30, 2016 edition of Governance Now )
 

Comments

 

Other News

The three Es to end open defecation

Open defecation is an issue that plagues our country every morning between 2 am and 6 am! To get rid of this practise from Indian society, prime minister Narendra Modi on October 2, 2014 announced the Swachh Bharat Mission (SBM). The Swachh Bharat Mission is a spin-off from the Nirmal Bharat Abhi

Aadhaar data not leaked: UIDAI

 The Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) on Monday said here that the Aadhaar data is fully safe and secure and there has been no data leak or breach. UIDAI said in a statement that data on government websites was placed in public domain as a measure of proactive disclosure unde

Aadhaar data not leaked: UIDAI

 The Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) on Monday said here that the Aadhaar data is fully safe and secure and there has been no data leak or breach. UIDAI said in a statement that data on government websites was placed in public domain as a measure of proactive disclosure unde

Right of mother, child to good health, well-being non-negotiable

 The United Nations General Assembly recognized November 20, 1954 as Universal Children’s Day to promote and celebrate the rights of children. On this day in 1959, the UN adopted the Declaration of the Rights of the Child and in 1989, the Convention on the Rights of the Child. While the day is c

Private sector hiring may look up in next fiscal: ASSOCHAM

The hiring outlook in the private sector is expected to stay muted till beginning of fiscal 2018-19, an ASSOCHAM assessment based on its feedback from members has indicated. "The focus, right now is how to deleverage, consolidate, exit from non-core businesses and achieve a lean and me

Gujarat in the times of another Vikas

In October, during yet another of his visits to Gujarat, prime minister Narendra Modi inaugurated a curious range of projects in Vadodara: a transport hub and multi-level parking facility as well as a waste-to-energy plant of the municipal corporation. If there were no elections coming closer, it would hav



Video

Former cabinet minister priyarajan dasmunshi passes away after prolonged illness

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter