Collegium not in sync with democracy: Shah

"Exemplifies misalignment between core values of judicial independence and accountability"

PTI | September 14, 2010



A P Shah, former Delhi High Court chief justice who gave a landmark judgement bringing the office of Chief Justice of India under the ambit of RTI Act, today attacked the present collegium system of judicial appointments to higher judiciary.

"The present system of judicial appointments in the constitutional courts exemplifies the misalignment between the core values of judicial independence and accountability," he said during the fifth annual convention of the Central Information Commission.

Justice Shah, who gave a number of significant judgements including on the disclosure of assets by Supreme Court judges, and decriminalisation of homosexuality, said the process of judicial appointment provides for no oversight.

"Our current appointments system is out of step with democratic culture primarily because it lacks transparency, and provides for no oversight.

"The way in which judges are appointed embody a set of values about democracy. Choosing judge based on undisclosed criterion in largely unknown circumstances reflects and increasing democratic deficit," Shah said.

Speaking on efforts to bring more diversity among the benches he said the other interesting development was around growing consensus to promote conscious efforts and bring more diversity on the bench.

"Judges are not representatives of any group or constituency. Their duty is to do justice to all according to law without any fear or favour, affection or ill-will.

"Equally, the judiciary as a whole does not need to be representative of any group or constituency. However, a judiciary -- indeed any institution -- that fails to reflect the make-up of society from which it is drawn will sooner or later lose confidence of that society," he said.

Justice Shah said an "appropriate balance" between competing principles must be found in something that is best suited to our constitutional set-up and is "uniquely Indian" in that sense.

He was critical of the Judges (Enquiry) Bill, 2006 which allows people to file complaints against sitting judges which can then be examined by proposed National Judicial Council. The council can make reference to Parliament for removal or impose punishment on judges.

"This presents an example of the cure being worse than the disease. This is clearly impermissible for it is unconstitutional and also severely undermines the status and functioning of judiciary. What cannot be done by not less than 100 members of Parliament can now be initiated by only one person," he said.

Justice Shah said until an alternative constitutional procedure is devised for removal of "errant judges without compromising independence, the procedure for complaints must, at the first instance, be an in-house exercise and cannot be given to a small and select number of persons".

Comments

 

Other News

Maharashtra FDA cracks down on `health supplements`; seizes stock worth Rs 1.39 cr

The Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a comprehensive state wide compliance order tightening regulations governing health supplements, nutraceuticals, sports nutrition products and foods for special dietary and medical purposes. The order, issued by Commissioner of Food Safety, Tu

States face rising fiscal pressure as spending outpaces revenue

States across India are facing increasing fiscal pressures, with revenue expenditure growing faster than revenue receipts since 2022-23, largely driven by rising subsidies and transfers, according to the annual ‘State of State Finances 2026-27’ report released by PRS Legislative Research.

Global value chains and sustainability

When a country’s factories become part of global supply chains, making parts or products that feed into goods sold around the world, the economy usually looks stronger. Output rises, exports grow, and technology improves. But the research behind this article [Bhayana and Nag, 2026] asks a harder qu

Narrative sovereignty in the digital age

In today’s world, competition between countries is not limited to military strength or economic power. It also takes place through the stories countries tell about themselves and the way others describe them. Social media and digital platforms have made this competition faster and more visible. Whe

The hidden cost of voter-ID link with welfare

On October 30, panchayati raj minister Rajiv Ranjan Singh, better known as Lalan Singh, told a national workshop in Delhi that Aadhaar would no longer be the basis for government schemes. His argument seemed simple enough. Aadhaar centres are now in every locality, and anyone can get a card made for anyb

The silent epidemic in the Northeast

In Mizoram, more than nine in ten people can read. Anyone there can find out how HIV spreads and how to protect themselves. Yet Mizoram has the highest rates of HIV patients in the country. If education were enough, this would’ve been solved long ago, but it was not. The answer tells us something a

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter