Why Sathasivam should not have taken up Kerala governor's post

Sathasivam might be extremely well-meaning and the best candidate for the job, but that is not reason enough to jeopardise propriety of his earlier post or risk judicial independence

shantanu

Shantanu Datta | September 4, 2014 | PIB File Photo




In about 19 hours, P Sathasivam, the chief justice of India till April 26 this year, will take oath as the next governor of Kerala. The swearing-in ceremony is scheduled for 10 am tomorrow (September 5) but the 65-year-old has set off a debate bigger than the one spawned by the, first, appointment, and, subsequently, resignation of his predecessor Sheila Dikshit, who reportedly checks out of Raj Bhavan in Thiruvananthapuram today.

Predictably, it has become a BJP versus Congress, and slowly everyone else as well, slugfest. Like all decisions, appointments, resignations or removals in the 10-year UPA administration became a Congress vs BJP and everyone else tussle.

So, what’s the problem if, as the BJP says, there’s nothing in the constitution that “technically” can bar Sathasivam’s appointment? A lot. Ethical, for one. Juridical, for another.

Here are three reasons why Sathasivam should have said “well, thank you but no, thank you” to the NDA government’s offer to put him up at Thiruvananthapuram Raj Bhavan:

1. While the post of a governor is largely, well, insignificant, Sathasivam’s last post was anything but that. As many, including lawyers in Kerala and the all-India bar association, have pointed out, it’s beneath the dignity of a former chief justice of India (CJI) to hold a governor’s post, which comes much lower in the constitutional hierarchy. For the record, the CJI is the fourth highest position in the country, preceded only by the president, the vice-president and the prime minister.

So, Sathasivam might be extremely well-meaning – and there’s no reason to disbelieve that – and he could be the best candidate for the job, but it’s not his personal characteristics and hallmark that is important here. It is the dignity and propriety of the position he held earlier that should be the consideration.

2. There’s a good reason why the election commission wants a “cooling-off” period for even government servants before they can join electoral politics. There are even advocates for extending a similar one-year cooling-off period (as laid down in the all-India service rules) before retired bureaucrats can take up a job in the private sector (read an earlier story on that here). The word is conflict of interest.

Governors are nothing if not political pawns, and the CJI’s is way, way more important a position than a bureaucrat’s. So there’s little reason to believe conflict of interest is an impossibility from this precedent – Sathasivam is the first former CJI to be appointed a governor; chief justices to high courts have earlier been appointed in such positions, while the Congress had made another former CJI, Ranganath Mishra, a Rajya Sabha MP from Odisha between 1998 and 2004.

As Arun Jaitley, then the leader of opposition in Rajya Sabha wrote early last year after retired SC judge Markandey Katju’s appointment as the Press Council of India chairperson: “I have held a strong view that Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts must not be eligible for jobs in the Government after retirement.  In some cases  the pre-retirement judicial conduct of a judge is influenced by the desire to get a post retirement assignment.”

Jaitley’s party might now argue that was his personal opinion ‘then’ but what cannot be denied is the wisdom in the eminent lawyer’s contention.

This is in no way peddling the Congress’s allegation that Sathasivam’s gubernatorial appointment was a ‘gift’ from a “pleased” Modi administration for scrapping an FIR against Amit Shah, Modi’s Man Friday and now the BJP president, in a fake encounter case. But what would, for instance, stop the rising eyebrows when an SC bench next gives a verdict in any case involving any political leader or party, which would obviously be seen as ‘favourable’ by some others? That, in effect, is the main worry against handing out such positions to ex-judges, let alone a former CJI.

As senior SC lawyer and Aam Aadmi Party leader Prashant Bhushan has said, “Offering such posts to retired judges compromises the independence of the judiciary.”

3. Explaining that there has been “no controversy” over his appointment, Sathasivam had earlier said, “If I say no to this job, I have to do farming in my village. As a former CJI I can have good relations with the state and the Centre and it will benefit the people of Kerala [when he becomes the governor].” While there is little logic in the first part of his contention – well, if he has to do farming, so be it; one cannot make an exception or put propriety of a key position in jeopardy to employ someone who doesn’t want to take up a family work or has not saved up judiciously for a post-retirement future could be a crude counter – it throws up an interesting point.

The government, for one, could think of better post-retirement benefits for CJIs and others who have held such key positions. If thousands of crores can be 'wasted' on the upkeep of former legislators – and much of it illegally – there sure is merit in spending more on such key figures to ensure there is zero controversy or conflict in the way they carry out their duties, at work or post-retirement.

An independent judiciary is one of the biggest assets that we enjoy in our robust democracy. There’s little point in jeopardising it, or even making it come close to the point where even an iota of suspicion is set off.

Comments

 

Other News

Maharashtra FDA cracks down on `health supplements`; seizes stock worth Rs 1.39 cr

The Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a comprehensive state wide compliance order tightening regulations governing health supplements, nutraceuticals, sports nutrition products and foods for special dietary and medical purposes. The order, issued by Commissioner of Food Safety, Tu

States face rising fiscal pressure as spending outpaces revenue

States across India are facing increasing fiscal pressures, with revenue expenditure growing faster than revenue receipts since 2022-23, largely driven by rising subsidies and transfers, according to the annual ‘State of State Finances 2026-27’ report released by PRS Legislative Research.

Global value chains and sustainability

When a country’s factories become part of global supply chains, making parts or products that feed into goods sold around the world, the economy usually looks stronger. Output rises, exports grow, and technology improves. But the research behind this article [Bhayana and Nag, 2026] asks a harder qu

Narrative sovereignty in the digital age

In today’s world, competition between countries is not limited to military strength or economic power. It also takes place through the stories countries tell about themselves and the way others describe them. Social media and digital platforms have made this competition faster and more visible. Whe

The hidden cost of voter-ID link with welfare

On October 30, panchayati raj minister Rajiv Ranjan Singh, better known as Lalan Singh, told a national workshop in Delhi that Aadhaar would no longer be the basis for government schemes. His argument seemed simple enough. Aadhaar centres are now in every locality, and anyone can get a card made for anyb

The silent epidemic in the Northeast

In Mizoram, more than nine in ten people can read. Anyone there can find out how HIV spreads and how to protect themselves. Yet Mizoram has the highest rates of HIV patients in the country. If education were enough, this would’ve been solved long ago, but it was not. The answer tells us something a

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter