Windfall Formula: when Kalmadi, Mayawati joined hands

The inside story of how rules were bent to favour JP Group for F1 race event

yash

Yash Vardhan Shukla | February 13, 2012


A view of the Buddha circuit
A view of the Buddha circuit

After his release from incarceration on corruption charges, Suresh Kalmadi rushed to his hometown Pune where his loyalists greeted him at the airport. The brazen and repulsive show of solidarity with someone accused of defalcation of huge public money was not that curious as one slogan: “Sabse bada khiladi Suresh Kalmadi”. If the slogan is to be translated into English, it says, “All time big player is Suresh Kalmadi”.

Of course Kalmadi could not be faulted for the ingenuity of his loyalists. But the manner in which he collaborated with moneybags, top bureaucracy and politicians to manipulate the system for his Formula One car race in Greater Noida last year justifies the slogan every bit. Indeed he appears to be an all-time big player. But this slogan is incomplete in the sense that when it comes to shady land deals and dubious methods of making money, Kalmadi could be seen cosying up to UP chief minister Mayawati as well. And Mayawati finds no hesitation in dealing with Kalmadi acolytes either.

A PIL filed in the supreme court, admitted on February 13 for hearing, reveals an intriguing and subversive collaboration of the system to favour those who have money and clout without bothering about sense of justice, propriety and even established principles of law.

The sequence of events that culminated in the hosting of formula one race to the delight of elites reads like unravelling of a plot hatched carefully by powerful people to promote cronyism of the worst order. The story begins on June 2007 when Kalmadi claimed to have received a letter of intent from Formula One chief Brenie Eccelestone to host the car race event in India. The letter started a search for the right venue when FI track designer Hermann Tilke visited Sohna in Haryana and Greater Noida.

With Haryana not showing any interest in the project, Kalmadi and F1 team approached a powerful corporate house JP Associates Limited to build the track in Greater Noida. Sunder Mulchandani, a Kalmadi-acolyte, introduced F1 chief Bernie Ecclestone to Manoj Gaur, executive chairman of the Jaypee group. That the choice fell on Jaypee group is not without reason. This corporate house is known for wielding considerable influence in the Mayawati regime and had bagged the contract for the prestigious Taj Expressway.

This paved the way for signing of a shareholder agreement by JP associates Ltd with Sulbha Realty of Kalmadi’s son, Sumeer Kalmadi, and Trackwork International Private Ltd of Sunder Mulchandani. Thus came into existence JPSK (Jay Prakash Sumeer Kalmadi) Sports Private Limited with Kalmadi’s daughter Payal Aditya Bhartia and son-in-law Aditya Bhartia as independent directors. Ultimately JPSK entered into an agreement with the Federation Internationale De L’automobile (FIA) for holding the Formula One event in India. However, the Kalmadi family withdrew from the JPSK subsequently due to clamour in the media. The JPSK was later converted to the JPSIL which is the subsidiary of the JP group.

Interestingly all this coincided with the UP government framing a policy to create a special development zone (SDZ) which stipulated that around 1,000 hectare area on the Taj Expressway would be created with sports as the core activity. The terms and conditions for those willing to take up the project were tailored to suit the Jaypee group. In fact the conditions for the eligibility were drawn in such a manner as to foreclose all options for possible competition to the Jaypee group during bidding.

Ultimately the JPSIL signed 24 lease deeds with the Yamuna Expressway Industrial Development Authority (YEIDA) for land measuring over 918.13 hectares which is below the mandatory stipulation of 1,000 hectares to qualify as the SDZ. The policy was surreptitiously changed through an order by VN Garg, principal secretary, industrial development, through an order on May 22, 2009 to include projects of 500 hectares and above to qualify for SDZ.

Having cleared all the hurdles for the smooth acquisition, the Jaypee group signed 24-odd leases between September 24, 2009 and May 5, 2010. The key architect of the SDZ policy in 2007, industrial commissioner Atul Kumar Gupta, was rewarded with the post of chief secretary. Even post retirement, he has been suitably looked after with a post in the UP Public Service Commission.

Once the land was allotted to JPSIL, the state bureaucracy moved at breakneck speed to clear all hurdles for JPSIL. On May 5, 2011, JPSIL sought relief in various taxes which were granted by violating all principles of propriety and established rules. For instance, the DM was directed by a secretary of the government to exempt the F1 car race from the entertainment tax. Similarly, stamp duty running into hundreds of crores of rupees was exempted  through a notification within a month. And if you want to know why these exemptions were granted to the Jaypee Associates, hold your breath! These exemptions were given to meet exigencies arising out of the global economic downturn.

The manner in which the SDZ policy was drafted to favour the Jaypee group appears beyond doubt a colourable exercise of power by the political executive and bureaucracy to favour the Jaypee group. The SDZ policy is neither approved by the state legislature nor by the state cabinet. The SDZ is created by an executive order which overlaps the provision of the special economic zone (SEZ)—a policy approved by the state and the union government as well. Yet the SDZ is given all those exemptions which are granted to the SEZ.

What is absurd is the pretext of the global economic slowdown taken by the Mayawati government to curry favours on the Jaypee group. No doubt the building of the F1 track was a highly skilled project which did not create jobs for local people. Similarly the land acquired for this project is purchased at a pittance and  being sold at exorbitant premium for residential and commercial purposes. While the Jaypee group is the obvious beneficiary of this munificence ,  Suresh Kalmadi does pair with Mayawati as the biggest ever-player by hosting the event.

Comments

 

Other News

General Elections: Phase 3 voter turnout 64.4%

Polling in third phase of General Elections recorded an approximate voter turnout of 64.4%, as of 11:40 pm Tuesday, as per the data released by the Election Commission of India close to the midnight. The trend of lower turnout witnessed in the first two phases has thus continued in this round too.

How infra development is shaping India story

India is the world’s fifth largest economy with a GDP of USD 3.7 trillion today, and it is expected to become the third largest economy with a GDP of USD 5 trillion in five years. The Narendra Modi-led government aims to make India a developed country by 2047. A key driver of this economic growth and

75 visitors from abroad watch world’s largest elections unfold

As a beacon of electoral integrity and transparency, the Election Commission of India (ECI) exemplifies its commitment to conduct general elections of the highest standards, offering a golden bridge for global Election Management Bodies (EMBs) to witness democratic excellence first-hand. It continues foste

‘Oral cancer deaths in India cause productivity loss of 0.18% GDP’

A first-of-its-kind study on the economic loss due to premature death from oral cancer in India by the Tata Memorial Centre has found that this form of cancer has a premature mortality rate of 75.6% (34 premature events / 45 total events) resulting in productivity loss of approximately $5.6 billion in 2022

Days of Reading: Upendra Baxi recalls works that shaped his youth

Of Law and Life Upendra Baxi in Conversation with Arvind Narrain, Lawrence Liang, Sitharamam Kakarala, and Sruti Chaganti Orient BlackSwan, Rs 2,310

Voting by tribal communities blossoms as ECI’s efforts bear fruit

The efforts made by the Election Commission of India (ECI), over last two years, for inclusion of Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTG) communities and other tribal groups in the electoral process have borne fruit with scenes of tribal groups in various states/UTs participating enthusiastically in t

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter