Cabinet nod for amendment to Juvenile justice Act

Cabinet clears proposal to try minors above 16 years of age under IPC, discretion to lie with juvenile board in heinous crime cases

GN Bureau | August 7, 2014


Protests after Delhi gang rape in December 2012
Protests after Delhi gang rape in December 2012

Notwithstanding opposition from child rights activists, the union cabinet on Wednesday approved an amendment bill that proposes Juvenile Justice Board can decide if a minor above 16 years of age should be tried in a regular court or sent to correction homes.

Such discretion, the proposal states, is allowed to the board in cases involving heinous crimes such as rape and murder. (Also read: Juvenile laws in India: need for uniformity)

Changes in the juvenile justice (care and protection of children) Act, 2000, were discussed by the cabinet after all the central ministries gave their nod for the amendment, media reports suggest.

The amendments, however, do not allow life imprisonment or capital punishment for the minor accused, irrespective of his trial under the juvenile Act or under the Indian penal code (IPC).

So far, irrespective of the gravity of the crime, accused up to the age of 18 are sent to correction homes and the maximum punishment provided for in the Act is three years confinement.

Proposals to bring changes in the Act comes in the wake of the unprecedented public outrage arising out of the conviction of one of the accused in the December, 2012 gang-rape of a young physiotherapist in a moving bus in Delhi.

Women and child development minister Maneka Gandhi herself had been advocating the move lately suggesting it would act as a deterrent for child offenders.

Child rights activists on the other hand have been pointing that such changes would prove counter-productive instead of acting as deterrents.

In a statement to Governance Now, a spokesperson of ‘Save the Children’ that works for child protection and child education in India said, “Let us all focus on operationalizing juvenile systems, in accordance with the spirit of rehabilitating child offenders. We have to work with children to ensure that they become more responsible instead of only punishing them.

Nishit Kumar, head, communication and strategic initiatives, Childline India Foundation, Mumbai, said: “The decision of the exact term for such reformation process must be left to the JJB and should be based on detailed psychological examination and observation of the Juvenile.”

In a representation to late supreme court justice (retired) J S Verma who was heading a panel to amend anti-rape laws in the wake of the December, 2012 Delhi incident, a group of activists had highlighted that the minor accused in the case had a troubled childhood himself, after being separated from his family at the age of five. Instead, they pointed that the state should lay emphasis on protecting the childhood of such juveniles who end up being offenders.

Meanwhile, the amendment approved by the cabinet also has provisions for faster child adoption procedures and setting up foster care homes.

The government plans to introduce the bill in the current session of the parliament.

Comments

 

Other News

NHRC notice to UP govt and BHU VC over police action

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has taken suo motu cognizance of media reports about the alleged inaction by the authorities of the Banaras Hindu University (BHU) into a complaint of eve-teasing and subsequent use of unwarranted manhandling and thrashing of agitating students, mostly women, by

Shipping corporation gets gas carrier vessel

 Shipping Corporation of India Ltd (SCI) has taken delivery of a 2001 Japanese built second hand Very Large Gas Carrier (VLGC) on September 14 at Khor Fakkan in UAE. It has been renamed as Nanda Devi.  The corporation’s total fleet strength stands at 70 vessels, aggregating to dea

When rival telecom honchos will share the stage

 When was the last time you saw all rival telecom corporate leaders come together. May be at time of the formal launch of prime minister Narendra Modi’s Digital India programme in July 2015. Telecom’s top brass will again share the stage at the inauguration of the three-day India Mobile Co

RailTel clocks highest turnover of Rs 903 crore

 RailTel has achieved highest ever turnover of Rs 903 crore and clocked a profit before tax (PAT) of Rs 194 crore and net profit of Rs 130 crore in financial year 2016-2017.  RailTel has said that the past year has been remarkable for it as the railway PSU has proved itself to be a key

What ails Banaras Hindu University

From 1969, following an amendment in the Banaras Hindu University (BHU) Act, the university’s executive council is entirely nominated by the president of India on the recommendations of the HRD ministry. None of the executive council members are elected, which dilutes the democratic structure of the

Indian policymakers don’t have much knowledge of SDGs: Report

The highest proportion of policymakers with not much or no knowledge of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) was found in India (38%), said a report by an international advocacy group. Equal Measures 2030, an advocacy group, which spoke to policymakers in India, Colombia, Indonesia, Keny



Video

Rahul targets Modi in Gujrat

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter