Here is why Sabharwal could not head NHRC

In RTI reply, home ministry cites "adverse media and other reports"

PTI | March 17, 2010



Former CJI Y K Sabharwal was not considered for the post of National Human Rights Commission chief because of "adverse media and other reports" about him, the home ministry has said.

Former chief justices R C Lahoti and Y K Sabharwal were both eligible for the post of NHRC chairperson according to provisions of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.

But Justice Lahoti declined the offer citing other engagements whereas Justice Sabharwal was not considered for the "highly sensitive post" because of adverse reports, the ministry said.

In reply to an RTI application by Subhash Chandra Agrawal, the human rights division of the ministry said, "Because of adverse media and other reports with regard to Mr Justice Y K Sabharwal, it was felt that highly sensitive post of chairperson of NHRC may not be offered to him.

"Accordingly, it was recorded on our files that Mr Justice R C Lahoti and and Mr Justice Y K Sabharwal 'are not inclined/not available for different reasons."

The ministry said the offer to Justice Lahoti was made "orally" and there was no correspondence recorded between the union government and Justice Lahoti, adding the conversation had been conveyed to the Home Minister through the Home Secretary.

The post of NHRC chairperson is lying vacant since June 1, 2009 after former Chief Justice S Rajendra Babu retired from the post on May 31.

The government has authorised Justice G P Mathur, a retired Supreme Court judge and a memeber of the commission, to act as its chairperson until a new appointment is made, the ministry had said in a separate reply.

As per the provisions of Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, only a retired CJI till age of 70 years is eligible for the post which makes only Justice R C Lahoti and Y K Sabharwal eligible for the important assignment.

Sabharwal had retired from Supreme Court on January 14, 2007.

The apex court had last month expressed annoyance with the Centre's submission that retired chief justices were not available for appointment as NHRC chairperson.

The government had in a brief affidavit earlier submitted that required incumbents "were not available" to take the post and the government was taking necessary steps to do that.

Comments

 

Other News

What the nine Indian Nobel winners have in common

A Touch Of Genius: The Wisdom of India’s Nobel Laureates Edited by Rudrangshu Mukherjee Aleph Books, Rs 1499, 848 pages  

Income Tax dept holds Ghatkopar Outreach on new IT Act

The Income Tax Department organised an outreach programme in Ghatkopar, Mumbai, to raise awareness about the key features of the Income Tax Act, 2025, effective April 1, 2026. The initiative is part of a nationwide effort to promote taxpayer awareness, simplify compliance, and strengthen a transparent, eff

Making AI work where governance is closest to people

India’s next governance leap may not solely come from digitisation. It will come from making public systems more intelligent, more adaptive, and more responsive to the dynamics at the grassroots. That opportunity is especially significant at the panchayat level, where governance is not an abstract po

Borrowing troubles: How small loans are quietly trapping youth

A silent crisis is playing out in the pocket of young India, not in stock markets or government treasuries, but in smartphones of college students and first-jobbers who clicked on the Apply Now button without reading the small print.  A decade ago, to take a loan, you had to do some paperwor

A 19th-century pilgrim’s progress

The Travels of a Sadhu in the Himalayas By Jaladhar Sen (Translated by Somdatta Mandal) Speaking Tiger Books, 259 pages, ₹499.00  

India faces critical shortage of skin donors amid rising burn cases

India reports nearly 70 lakh burn injury cases every year, resulting in approximately 1.4 lakh deaths annually. Experts estimate that up to 50% of these lives could be saved with adequate access to skin donations.   A significant concern is that around 70% of burn victims fall wi


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter