Judges medical expenses cannot be made public under RTI, rules SC

There should be some respect for privacy, says supreme court bench headed by the CJI

GN Bureau | July 2, 2015


#supreme court   #medical records   #judges   #rti   #right to information   #privacy  

The supreme court on Thursday said that privacy should be respected and declined to provide information about judges medical expenses.

The court held that the medical expenses incurred on judges and their family members cannot be disclosed or made public under the Right to Information Act.

A bench headed by Chief Justice H L Dattu said, "there should be some respect for privacy and if such information are being disclosed, there will be no stopping."

The bench refused to interfere with the Delhi high court verdict which had dismissed a plea seeking details of medical reimbursements of supreme court judges, saying it had personal information and providing it would amount to invasion of their privacy.

"We understand that we are getting the reimbursement from public money for our treatment and we are entitled for it as per the service conditions of judges," the bench, which comprised justices Arun Mishra and Amitava Roy, observed.

"Today he is asking information for medical expenses. Tomorrow he will ask what are the medicines purchased by the judges. When there will be a list of medicines he can make out what type of ailment the judge is suffering from. It starts like this. Where does this stop," the bench observed.

The apex court was hearing an appeal filed by RTI activist Subhash Chandra Agarwal against the April 17 judgement of a division bench of the High Court which had upheld decision of its single judge that the information about reimbursement of medical bills of judges and their families cannot be disclosed under RTI law.

The Delhi HC’s single judge had set aside the Central Information Commission's (CIC) direction holding that judges have to disclose such information. The supreme court disagreed with the contention of advocate Prashant Bhushan that as the citizens are entitled to know how public money is spent by public servants, they also have a right to know how these funds were being utilised for medical treatment of judges.

Comments

 

Other News

Stories of the Sun, the source of knowledge and life

The Eternal Sun: The Legacy of Surya Deva  By Shalini Modi Rupa Publications, 192 pages, Rs 295 ‘The Et

Rethinking disaster management in Tripura

In 2024, heavy floods submerged large parts of Tripura, disrupting lives and livelihoods, affecting critical infrastructure, and bringing life to a standstill in several parts of the state. Media reports suggested that the flood claimed 32 lives and displaced close to 1.5 lakh people. Barely had floodwater

MMRDA signs $26 bn MoUs in AI and sustainable industry at WEF

On day three of the World Economic Forum (WEF) Annual Meeting 2026, the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) formalised two landmark investment Memoranda of Understanding (MoUs) valued at USD 26 billion, signalling a strategic shift towards future-ready, integrated economic ecosystems.

Confused about the complex realities of modern work life? Help is here

Corporate Hostages: Roads to Captivity, Paths to Liberation By Dr. N. Raj Mohan Rupa Publications, 200 pages, Rs 295

Cabinet approves equity support to SIDBI

The union cabinet, chaired by PM Narendra Modi, has approved an equity support of Rs.5,000 crore to Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI). The equity capital of Rs. 5,000 crore will be infused into SIDBI by the Department of Financial Services (DFS) in three tranches of Rs.

233-year-old Ramayana manuscript gifted to Ram Katha Museum

In a significant cultural handover, Prof. Shrinivasa Varakhedi, Vice Chancellor of the Central Sanskrit University, presented a rare 233-year-old Sanskrit manuscript of the Vālmīkirāmāyaṇam (with the Tattvadīpikāṭīkā) to Nripendra Misra, chairman of the Executive Council of Prime Ministers` Mus


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter