Kathua horror: Can we deliver justice to Kathua girl?

No lessons learned after the barbaric crime on Nirbhaya in 2012

GN Bureau | April 13, 2018


#women   #rape   #Kuldeep Singh Sengar   #Nirbhaya   #Aasifa   #Unnao rape   #Kathua rape  
Candlelight vigil at India Gate over Kathua, Unnao rape cases (Photo: Twitter/Congress)
Candlelight vigil at India Gate over Kathua, Unnao rape cases (Photo: Twitter/Congress)

The 15-page chargesheet by J&K Police’s crime branch is a chilling revelation of what all is wrong in our society. The eight-year-old girl who was kidnapped, drugged, brutally gang-raped and strangled to death is now being labelled as “the new Nirbhaya”. Instead of categorising her, a question which needs to be asked loudly is, ‘Why do we have another Nirbhaya?’ Was the atrocity and barbarity done to one daughter not enough to shake our conscience? Have we not learned any lessons?

 
The child, yes a little child, was punished for belonging to the nomad Muslim community of Bakarwals in Jammu’s Kathua district. A little far from Kathua, in Unnao in Uttar Pradesh another girl waits for justice after her father died in judicial custody for complaining against a BJP MLA for allegedly raping his daughter. Both the states instead of supporting the victims are shielding the perpetrators of crime.
 
Prime minister Narendra Modi is yet to break his silence and condemn both the incidents in strongest words. It was VK Singh, MoS, external affairs, from the ruling party who first said that "we have failed Asifa as humans" and assured "...she will not be denied justice."
 
But can justice be delivered to the Kathua girl? Here are some reasons which make justice a long, tiring, and elusive:
 
  • Just like in 2012, after the Nirbahaya shame, some arrests will be made in both the cases, and some heads will also roll, but the lengthy and frustrating procedure of delivering justice will again test our patience. The four convicts were sentenced to death on September 13, 2013, by the Delhi high court for Nirbhaya’s rape. Their sentence was upheld by the supreme court in May 2017, yet the culprits are still not hanged. The accused will soon file a review petition in the SC and further delay the justice. 
  • A minor is accused of raping and murdering the Kathua girl. A minor also brutally raped Nirbhaya in 2012. The identity of the minor who raped the Kathua girl will be kept top secret just like the one who raped Nirbhaya. His fate would be exactly the same and would be tried under the Juvenile Justice Act and sent to remand home for some years and then later can move on in his life, like nothing happened. After spending three years in a remand home for raping Nirbhaya, the juvenile was released in December 2015. 
  • A few days after the rage and anger boils down over the Kathua incident, debates will be conducted on life imprisonment vs death penalty. Instead of making the laws more stringent to make our daughters feel safe, there will be numerous debates whether the barbaric crime falls under the “rarest of rare” category and will death penalty be enough a punishment.
  • Just like the Nirbhaya fund, another fund would be set up in the name of Kathua girl. Numerous promises would be made to save the “beti” but nothing will be done on the ground. According to Dr Ranjana Kumari, director, Centre for Social Research, and chairperson, Women Power Connect, “Nirbhaya fund can be called a political casualty. The funds have been utilised without vision. The schemes have been formulated by the ministry of women and child development, the ministry of home affairs and the ministry of railways, with no proper implementation and vision.” A similar fate awaits the Kathua girl and for India’s daughters.
  • Remember Lok Sabha member Kirron Kher’s advice to a rape victim against boarding the auto that had three male passengers in Chandigarh? Let’s wait for some time and there would be comments as to why the child ventured into the forest alone? Victim blaming and shaming is already in full swing in Unnao. 
  • Soon, we may have another documentary depicting the plight of India’s daughters, which would be banned again for projecting the country in a poor light. The honour and pride of the nation will be protected no matter how helpless and unsafe the women feel.

The earlier version of this article named the the girl in Kathua. Now her identity has been witheld to protect her privacy.

Comments

 

Other News

HPCL, Tata Steel among National CSR Award 2020 winners

Hindustan Petroleum Corporation, HDFC, Tata Steel and Tech Mahindra are among the winners and the recipients of honourable mentions in the National CSR Awards 2020 announced by the ministry of corporate affairs (MCA) on Thursday. The MCA instituted the annual National Corporate Social Respon

India’s tree lovers get together for a nation-wide tree festival

A good monsoon has left the trees all washed and spruced up. It’s right time to take a good look at them, and also to tell the young generation about their diversity. So, tree lovers across the country have joined hands to celebrate a festival of trees this month. The August Tree Fest

How did a policeman move unarmed and fearlessly for 37 long years in Bihar?

Unbounded: My Experiments with Law, Physics, Policing and Super 30 By Abhayanand Rupa Publications, 344 pages, Rs 595   Abhayanand has

India@75: A timely study of the state of the nation

India after 1947: Reflections & Recollections By Rajmohan Gandhi Aleph, 118 pages, Rs 399 Rajmohan Gandhi was about 11 when India won independence. As the nation celebrates 75 years of freedom, how would he – and others like him – feel?

BMC denies protocol breach in ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’

The BrihanMumbai municipal corporation (BMC) has rebutted a Shiv Sena leader’s allegation of breach of protocol in the implementation of the ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’ campaign. On Friday Rahul Shewale, group leader of Shiv Sena in Lok Sabha, had accused BMC commissioner IS Chahal

Mumbai`s stalled building projects: Is self-redevelopment the real solution?

Land in Mumbai city, which is surrounded by water on three sides, is scarce and has a premium. Property prices in certain areas of financial capital of the country are as much as Rs 1 lakh per sq ft. Yet, 5,800 buildings have been lying in a stalled condition for the last 18 years. Meanwhile

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter