Mayawati ‘respects’ Ansari: She is right, but was she right?

If you cut out her antics, dramatics and theatrics, Mayawati was only pointing out that the RS chairman doesn’t do his duty properly. Can she be faulted for the purport of her comment per se?

shantanu

Shantanu Datta | December 13, 2012




It’s not a Bollywood film if all does not end well. Such situations are a little more real — a mishmash of them is strung together and given a four-letter tag: life.

But in India, we love Bollywood fare. We know it’s grossly unfair, that fare, but we still love it. We are like that only.

A bit of that was played out in parliament today, as Mayawati, the irrepressible Bahujan Samaj Party chief, took a U-turn a day after her scathing deprecation of Rajya Sabha chairman Hamid Ansari and said she has nothing but respect for the man and the chair he occupies.

"I respect you. I respect the chair...I have full faith in the chair that he will find a way to get the voice of the downtrodden heard," Mayawati said, according to PTI.

And more: "I have full faith in you. I have full confidence that you will be able to find a way out to ensure that the House runs smoothly and the legislation is passed."

As did everyone else — from the prime minister to the leader of opposition to other members of the upper house. They all rose to the occasion and showed their respect for Ansari, the country’s vice-president, and his chair.

"Respect for the chairman of the House is respect for maintenance of the dignity of the House,” Manmohan Singh said. “We will work, from all sections of the House, to ensure that the chair gets all the cooperation, all the respect that is due to you and to this august chair.”

Addressing Ansari, leader of opposition Arun Jaitley said, "This House will speak in one voice in upholding your honour both as an individual and the also the dignity of the chair that you occupy."

It was a typical Bollywood film endgame, as, to quote the PTI report, “An overwhelmed Ansari profusely thanked the Prime Minister, Jaitley, Mayawati and leaders of all other political parties and members of the House for the sentiments expressed.  "The Chair as always seeks the cooperation of the House for running it smoothly," he said, bringing curtains down on the controversy that had raged in Rajya Sabha on Wednesday.”

You could almost visualise the relieved audience using the back of their hands to wipe away tears of joy after the anxiety- and angst-ridden climax, even as the end credits roll down the screen.

All very good, for democracy does not allow us to stand up and start making contemptuous remark against others.

But democracy also advises us to stand up and point out if someone is wrong, without, of course, assaulting the person — either verbally or physically.

So what did Mayawati say on December 12 that got everyone’s goat? She blamed Ansari, as chairman of the Rajya Sabha, in scuttling the passage of her pet bill: one that assures reservation to SC/ST in government job promotion. The BSP supremo rushed to the well of the House after protests from her bête noire, the Samajwadi Party, disrupted proceedings when the issue was to be discussed.

"I am not ready to listen to anything. We have seen in the last few days that every day the House is not allowed to function after 12 pm. It is your responsibility to ensure that it functions. Who will ensure that it functions?" Mayawati asked Ansari (LINK: http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/manmohan-singh-calls-hamid-ansari-after-mayawati-remarks-in-rajya-sabha/1/237457.html)

Shorn of the dramatics, was she way off the mark?

Then she took the attack straight to Ansari: "You are not seen here after 12 pm. What kind of House is this? You have to take a decision on what has to be done for this (ensuring the functioning of the House)."

Shorn of the theatrics, again, was she wrong? If yes, she ought to apologise. And profusely at that.

But if not, she was right, right?

And if you cut out the purportedly insulting language she used, Mayawati was only using her democratic right and duty to speak the truth, and point out what she deems is a malaise in the system. Can she be faulted for the purport of her comment per se?

No one addressed those issues today, for we are not a nation that loves unhappy endings. Long live Bollywood.

Comments

 

Other News

UPI completes 10 years of digital payments revolution

The Unified Payments Interface (UPI), launched on August 25, 2016 by the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) under the regulatory oversight of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), has completed 10 years of transforming digital payments in India. UPI has emerged as the backbone of India’s digi

Here’s an I.D.E.A. for career growth and success

Success in today’s professional organisation is no longer solely determined by academic qualifications, technical expertise or years of experience. While these attributes do matter, organisations increasingly value individuals who demonstrate the right mindset and behavioural qualities. The ability

PM interacts with CEOs, founders of space startups

Prime minister Narendra Modi interacted with CEOs and Founders of 20 Space Startups at Seva Teerth on Friday.   CEOs of leading companies in the space sector working in diverse fields ranging from building rockets and reusable semi-cryogenic launch vehicles, avionics, satelli

From one cow to a dairy business

In 2012, Anita Dash wasn`t dreaming of building a dairy brand. She wasn`t studying business models or planning market expansion. Like countless mothers across India, her focus was on something much simpler: giving her children a better future.   At the time, her most valuable

Ethanol blending: The two sides of a story

India`s crude oil consumption is estimated to be around 88.5% imported from abroad. This one single figure is also responsible for why ethanol has become both an economic strategy and fuel policy at the same time. In an economy like India, which depends so heavily on foreign oil, any increase in internat

Food inflation: Not a macroeconomic statistic but a developmental indicator

India`s retail inflation shows a reassuring picture at first glance. According to the latest data, Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation edged up to 4.38% in June 2026 from 3.93% in May 2026, but continued to remain within the Reserve Bank of India`s (RBI) target band of 4% (+/- 2%). However, beneath this

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter