Modi govt goes to SC against HC order

Gujarat HC upheld appointment of Lokayukta by governor

PTI | January 19, 2012



The Gujarat government on Thursday approached the supreme court challenging the state high court order upholding the appointment of justice R A Mehta as the Lokayukta by the governor.

The Gujarat high court had on Wednesday upheld the appointment of justice (Retd) Mehta as the Lokayukta while sharply criticising chief minister Narendra Modi for his "pranks" that had sparked a "constitutional mini crisis".

Rejecting the state government's plea, three months after the high court gave a split verdict, justice V M Sahai said the "pranks" played by the chief minister on the Lokayukta issue "demonstrates destruction of our democracy".

Justice Sahai, who was given the task of hearing the challenge against the appointment of Lokayukta following the conflicting verdict of the two-member bench, said Modi's "questionable" conduct of "stonewalling" the appointment of justice Mehta threatened the rule of law.

He said the chief minister's effort to metastasise the procedure for appointment of Lokayukta by issuing the Gujarat Lokayukta (Amendment) Ordinance, 2011, were "deprave and truculent" actions.

Holding that "extraordinary situations demand extraordinary remedies", he said, "Open resistance of the Council of Ministers headed by the chief minister in not accepting the primacy of the opinion of the chief justice of the Gujarat high court in the matter of appointment of Lokayukta has created a crisis situation."

There was no good reason to reject the name of justice Mehta once the objections of the chief minister had been overruled by the Chief Jusitce, he noted.

Modi had insisted on justice J R Vora to be appointed as Lokayukta but this was not accepted by the chief justice on the ground that the judge had been appointed as the Director of the Gujarat State Judicial Academy.

If the chief minister's choice had been accepted, it would have set a "pernicious trend" and would have propitiated the public functionaries who were likely to fall within the scanner of Lokayukta and destroyed the integrity of the instituion as envisaged, justice Sahai said.

Gujarat Governor Kamla Beniwal had on August 25 last appointed justice Mehta to the post of Lokayukta, which had been lying vacant for the last eight years.

The state government had challenged the appointment in the high court the very next day, saying the governor had "bypassed" the state government.

Modi had maintained that the governor had acted unconstitutionally in selecting the ombudsman as the state government had not been consulted.

On October 11, a division bench of the high court had given a split verdict on the appointment issue.

While one of the judges had upheld the decision of the Governor, another judge had quashed the warrant of appointment issued by him, terming it unconstitutional.

The matter was then referred to justice Sahai.

Comments

 

Other News

El Niño threatens India’s Rabi crops

India’s southwest monsoon ended with a 13% rainfall deficit in 2026, its weakest performance in a decade, raising concerns over agricultural production, water security and the upcoming rabi season. With El Niño expected to persist into early 2027, experts warn that declining soil moisture, dep

Regulating the data advantage: India’s new e-Commerce framework

For over a decade, India’s e-commerce story has rested on a simple premise: platforms connect buyers and sellers, while data fuels efficiency, personalisation, and scale. However, as the market matured, its structure has revealed a growing imbalance. E-commerce platforms, especially marketplace ent

Changing weather patterns, climate change responsible for Nepal floods

The interaction between active Western Disturbances, increased atmospheric moisture and the region’s complex topography aswell as global warming are important factors behind intense rainfall in the Himalayas, leading to flash floods in Nepal, according to meteorologists. Nepal

A right she cannot reach

Last summer, the two of us spent several weeks in rural Madhya Pradesh with a non-profit that works on gender justice through women’s self-help groups. We went in with a notebook full of laws. The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act. The Dowry Prohibition Act. Free legal aid for every wo

Tier-2 cities lead India’s digital credit push

Digital payments have become a reflex for urban India, but the confidence earned in paying has not yet carried over to borrowing. That is the central finding of `How Urban India Pays Report 2026`, released by Pahlé India Foundation in collaboration with Amazon Pay. Based on a survey of 5,149 consu

India calls for doubling bilateral trade with UK by 2030

Commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal has called upon businesses in India and the United Kingdom to translate the opportunities created by the India-UK Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) into expanded trade, investment, partnerships and job creation. Addressing the Bu

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter