“There is a need for rationalisation of passenger trains”
GN Bureau | March 24, 2017
Before privatisation and corporatisation, the Indian Railways need to undertake major reforms including commercial accounting, decentralisation and human resource among others, said Bibek Debroy, economist and member, NITI Aayog at Railways Reforms and Governance Conclave organised by Governance Now on Friday.
Stressing the importance of introducing commercial accounting, he said, “I need commercial accounting not only to attract private sector investment but also because I need to know the kind of return public investment will have.”
In the present system – because of the complicated system of accounting – it’s difficult to ascertain the average rate of return on a typical railways project, he said. In some cases it might be even negative, he added.
“Whether I get access to funds using the World Bank window or some other, those are loans. They have to be repaid, perhaps at an average rate of seven percent. So if I don’t know the rate of return, I will not be in the position to pay back the loan,” he said. The commercial accounting is already being done on a pilot basis in Ajmer and northern zone.
“There is no particular reason why the transition to commercial accounting will not be possible by 2019. It is only a tool, after that one will require MIS which will take few more years,” he said.
Cautioning about the greater demand for public private participation (PPP), Debroy said, “Most services are already privatised. If we are not talking about services and moving away to something else, or are we talking about management which is also PPP or public assets or are we talking building of assets using the private sector?”
“Remember, the cost of capital obtained by the private sector tends to be higher than that obtained by the public sector. Remember that most of our infrastructure is funded by the debt route; that business cycles have their ups and downs and that banks are incapable of lending money for 20-25 years projects. In that scenario, all private sector calculation goes haywire", he said.
On redevelopment of 400 stations, he said, “I don’t think more than 20 stations have the potential land to be exploited by real estate redevelopment. We may see six to seven stations by 2019 including Surat, Chandigarh, Shivajinagar and Brijwasan.”
He said that there is also a need for rationalisation of passenger trains. “Why should we run slow passenger trains between Delhi and Tundla. It is well connected already.”
Further, Debroy said that railways is going to set up a regulator.
The decentralisation of decision making is another major exercise underway in the railways. Historically the zones have been functioning in a decentralised manner. Over a period of time, however, Rail Bhawan has become extremely centralised in its decision making, he said.
Even as railways has 1.3 million employees, it has shortage in the core business of running trains, he said.
After a day-long debate which often turned acrimonious, the Lok Sabha has passed the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2019, seeking to provide citizenship to non-Muslims from three neighbouring countries who have migrated to India. Prime minister Narendra Modi said he was “delighted&
Home minister Amit Shah on Monday introduced in the Lok Sabha the Citizenship Amendment Bill, triggering a long-ranging debate on the ideas of India, with the opposition parties claiming it was regressive. The bill seeks to grant citizenship to non-Muslim citizens of the neighbouring Pakista
The chawl in Mumbai where Dr BR Ambedkar, the father of the Constitution, lived between 1912 and 1934 will be converted into a national monument. Maharashtra chief minister Uddhav Thackeray made the announcement on Friday, On the occasion of 63rd death anniversary of the visionary leader, af
Amid shock and outrage across the country over the rape and murder of a young woman in Hyderabad, the police on early Friday morning killed all the four accused in the case in Hyderabad. Police had taken the four to Chattapally, where they had allegedly burnt the woman’s body after rap
India has been among the countries most affected by climate change, and ranks high on the Climate Risk Index prepared by researchers at NGO Germanwatch. The index for 2019, published this week, takes note of the alarming situation around the world and calls for more steps to mitigate the cr