SC puts telecom policy from 2001 to 2008 under scanner

Apex court will monitor CBI probe into the 2G scam

PTI | December 16, 2010




Set to monitor the 2G spectrum scam probe, the supreme court on Thursday widened the investigation in the case by bringing in its ambit the telecom policy from 2001 to 2008 covering both the NDA and the UPA regimes.

A bench comprising justices G S Singhvi and A K Ganguly made it clear that the emphasis of the investigation would be to determine the loss of money to the public exchequer and said a progress report on the probe has to be filed by the CBI and enforcement directorate in a sealed cover on the next date of hearing on February 10, 2011.

However, the bench said there was no need for a special team to investigate the scam as the government has agreed for court-monitored investigation which is moving in the right direction and solicitor general Gopal Subramanium and senior advocate K K Venugopal, appearing for CBI, have assured that there will be comprehensive investigation by the two agencies (CBI and ED).

"We are giving directions that the CBI shall carry investigation based on the CVC report and consider the findings of CAG which has prima facie found that ineligible entities were granted licences," it said.

The bench allowed the appeal filed by NGO, Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL), against the Delhi high court which had rejected the plea for CBI investigation into the irregularities in the grant of licence for 2G spectrum.

"The high court has committed serious error in dismissing the writ petition. Prima facie, there was sufficient material supported by documents to proceed on the allegation," the bench observed.

The bench said that the report of the central vigilance commission and the findings of the CAG needed impartial investigation.

It said that how licences were granted to the ineligible operators has to be investigated and as to why TRAI did not take action has to be looked into.

The bench said that the CBI should consider the investigations done by the CVC and the findings of the CAG on the irregularities, which according to it, were blatant violation of norms.

The bench further said that the investigation will also cover why roll out obligations were not fulfilled.

The bench asked the investigating agencies to probe the transfer of dual technology -- CDMA and GSM, saying while the notification for the dual technology was issued on October 19, 2007, one of the service provider was given the permission a day earlier.

The investigation shall also cover huge loans by public sector banks and if DoT officials were signatory to the licence agreements, the bench said.

The bench directed the CBI and ED to carry out investigations without being influenced by any individual, their ranks, functionaries and agencies.

The bench asked the directorate of income tax to hand over the transcripts of the tapped conversations carried out under the order of the home secretary to the CBI.

The court had reserved its judgement on December 8 after hearing arguments forwarded by CPIL, CBI, enforcement directorate, department of telecommunication and former telecom minister A Raja who resigned from the cabinet in the wake of the scam.

In earlier hearings in the apex court, CVC P J Thomas, whose appointment had come under a cloud, had offered to recuse himself from overseeing the CBI probe into 2G spectrum scam.

The recusal was prompted by SC's posers about his ability to oversee the CBI probe into the 2G scam as he happened to be telecom secretary under A Raja, as well as in view of a pending chargesheet against him in Kerala's palmolein import scam.

The apex court, while hearing arguments earlier, had favoured widening the ambit of the probe to include spectrum allocation since 2001 under the NDA regime.

"The issue raised in the case is not limited to only Rs 1.76 lakh crore but has a much wider compass. We would not like to prejudice the probe. But what happened in 2001 needs to be looked into. It is for the CBI to investigate and find out," the bench had observed.

Raja's counsel T R Andhyarujina, in his arguments, had maintained that his client had only been following up the 2001 policy initiated by his predecessors.

The court had also expressed surprise over public sector banks providing loans to the tune of Rs 10,000 crores to the 2G spectrum licensees on the basis of hypothecation of their respective licenses.

"If it is true it is astonishing. It goes much far beyond what you are advancing," the bench had quipped as Prashant Bhushan, appearing for CPIL and quoting various reports, told it about the disbursement of huge loans by various banks, including the State Bank of India to licensees.

Bhushan had told the bench that the SBI granted Rs 2,500 crore loan to Uninor, which is a joint venture between real estate major Unitech Ltd and Norway's telecom giant Telenor.

"A bank, which is the most premier bank of the country, the State Bank of India, functioning under the Act of Parliament, is lending Rs 10,000 crore. It is a matter of such great public importance. It needs to be covered under the CBI investigation," the bench had observed while favouring "holistic investigation."

Senior counsel K K Venugopal, who appeared for the CBI, had supported the bench's view saying that the CBI will register a separate case to probe the bank's role in the fraud.

"The investigation on this issue cannot be carried out in the pending case and a fresh FIR has to be registered," he had submitted.

The FIR in the telecom scam was registered by the CBI on October 21, 2009, against unnamed persons under various provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

The ED had also lodged the complaint under the Prevention of the Money Laundering Act and Foreign Exchange Management Act.

Comments

 

Other News

Cabinet approves Dearness Allowance, Dearness Relief

The union cabinet chaired by prime minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday approved the release of an additional instalment of Dearness Allowance (DA) to central government employees and Dearness Relief (DR) to pensioners with effect from 01.07.2026 representing an increase of 3% over the existing rates of 6

Cyclone Arnab strikes Andhra as warming oceans amplify storm risks

Cyclone Arnab made landfall along the Andhra Pradesh and Yanam coasts in the early hours of Wednesday as a very severe cyclonic storm, with maximum sustained wind speeds of 125–135 kmph and gusts reaching 150 kmph. Its rapid intensification has raised concerns about how warmer oceans, global warmin

Counting matters but which ones?

The first instinct of public policy is to count. Its harder task is to count what counts. We have become remarkably good at measuring the reach of the welfare state vis-à-vis beneficiaries covered, rupees transferred, houses built, connections installed and services delivered. But some of the most

Inching closer to a trade deal with America

The cooperation between India and the United States goes back quite a time. We need to relegate that era to the backburner when Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru visited US in the times of president Dwight Eisenhower and called the American let-off of 10 million dollars in defence aid to Pakistan as a “gun w

Manch vs Musk: Forty people and a foreign billionaire

About forty people walked the roundabout on Teen Murti Marg to the gate of Chanakyapuri police station, a distance you could cover in under a minute, on Friday to protest against Elon Musk’s Starlink. The walk was called by the Swadeshi Jagaran Manch. Nobody joined them on the way, and nobody seeme

Master sculptor recalls the making of the Shankaracharya statue

The Golden Chisel: The Story Behind the Making of Ram Lalla  By Seethalakshmi S. and Rahul Nandan Rupa Publications, 168 pages, Rs 395  

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter