SC upholds "rotten" Allahabad HC remark; takes potshots at judges

Says some judges at the HC suffer from "uncle judge" syndrome

PTI | December 10, 2010






 The Supreme Court today rejected a plea for expunction of its controversial, 'something-rotten-in-Allahabad High Court' remark, saying it stood by its suspicion that some of its judges, not all, are suffering from uncle judge syndrome.

"There are many excellent and upright judges too there, who are keeping the flag of the High Court flying high by their integrity and hard work," a bench of justices Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Mishra said, while disposing of the High court's application.

"It is totally false to say that all judges of the Allahabad High Court are corrupt. It is nowhere mentioned in our November 26 order that all judges are corrupt," the bench said.

"We have not painted everyone with the same brush," it said, adding, "What is mentioned in the order is that there are complaints against certain judges, not all judges."

The bench, however, refused to rule out that the High Court is completely bereft of the 'uncle judge syndrome' which refers to judges passing favourable orders for parties represented by lawyers personally known or related to them (judges) in the High Court.

Referring to its November 26 order, the bench said, "It has been mentioned in the order that many lawyers who are relatives of judges are scrupulously taking care that no one should lift a finger on that account.

"Others, however, are shamelessly taking advantage of this relationship," it said.

Rejecting the arguments of senior counsel P P Rao that even a clarification that some are excellent and good judges would still put their integrity in doubt, the bench remarked, "It is not just time to react but also to introspect.

"We can quite appreciate the anguish of some of the judges of the High Court, but we cannot overlook the fact that there are times when introspection is required and not mere reaction," it said.

"We earnestly request the judges to consider our (November 26) order in that spirit," the bench noted.

Reacting to Rao's persistent plea that the clarification would not be sufficient, Justice Katju angrily retorted during the hearing, "Do not tell all those things. I and my family have more than 100 years of association with the Allahabad High Court.

"People know who is corrupt and who is honest. So do not tell me all this," said Justice Katju, adding, "Tomorrow, if Markandey Katju starts taking bribe, then the entire country will know about it. So do not tell me as to who is honest and who is corrupt."
 

Comments

 

Other News

The Constitution cannot be altered: Justice Abhay Oka

Justice Abhay Oka, who retired from the Supreme Court in May 2025, has said that the Constitution of India cannot be altered. Explaining the landmark Kesavananda Bharati judgment (1973) on the basic structure of the Constitution, he said, “This is one judgment that has saved democracy in India.&rdq

How the flora and fauna evolved in the Indian subcontinent

Mammals of India  By A.J.T. Johnsingh and P.O. Nameer HarperCollins India in association with Bombay Natural History Society  

India`s renewable race is moving beyond megawatts

When Shell bought Sprng Energy in 2022, India`s renewable energy market appeared to offer precisely what global energy majors were seeking: scale, growth and a place in one of the world`s largest energy transitions. Four years later, Shell is selling the same business to Aditya Birla Group for an enterpris

Nepal Floods: India keeps close watch on the situation

India`s central government has been keeping a close watch on the situation arising out of the flash flood in Nepal on Wednesday. Union home minister Amit Shah spoke with the chief ministers of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, the two states that share the border with Nepal, regarding the disaster

UPI completes 10 years of digital payments revolution

The Unified Payments Interface (UPI), launched on August 25, 2016 by the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) under the regulatory oversight of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), has completed 10 years of transforming digital payments in India. UPI has emerged as the backbone of India’s digi

Here’s an I.D.E.A. for career growth and success

Success in today’s professional organisation is no longer solely determined by academic qualifications, technical expertise or years of experience. While these attributes do matter, organisations increasingly value individuals who demonstrate the right mindset and behavioural qualities. The ability

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter