Back to ‘lamppost politics’

Chouhan faced fatigue factor, relied too much on party machinery

ajay

Ajay Singh | December 12, 2018


#Vasundhara Raje   #Madhya Pradesh   #assembly elections   #Shivraj Chouhan   #BJP   #Congress  
Celebration at AICC office in New Delhi (Photo: Arun Kumar)
Celebration at AICC office in New Delhi (Photo: Arun Kumar)

The Indian electorate’s tryst with cyclical elections invented a phenomenon called ‘lamppost elections’. Implicit in this formulation was the notion that the people would elect a minion against a titan if they decide to do so. Irrespective of the stature of a leader in front, even a lamppost can be a victor.

 
Of late this lamppost syndrome is forgotten in the Indian elections. With caste and communal prejudices playing a dominant role in determining the contours of politics, India’s political map developed fault-lines at many levels. Till the emergence of Narendra Modi as the most prominent national leader after Rajiv Gandhi in the late 1980s, each election seemed to be a turf battle on local issues with a party’s organisational structure playing a subsidiary role.
 
However, the lamppost syndrome seemed to be revived a bit in these state assembly elections in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh. More particularly, in Madhya Pradesh, where the BJP and the Sangh Parivar boast of running the most formidable organisational machinery which is perfectly aligned with their political goal, the BJP’s loss is an instructive lesson in political history.
 
In Rajasthan, much of the blame is placed on the shoulders of the outgoing chief minister, Vasundhara Raje – and the rest on the state’s tendency of 25 years to keep alternating between the two parties. Vasundhara Raje attempted to introduce innovations in governance, but her haughty and aloof ways meant she had little connect with the masses. 
 
Unlike Chhattisgarh’s outgoing chief minister Raman Singh who appeared quite complacently ensconced in his cocoon and believing in his own infallibility, Shivraj Singh Chouhan in Madhya Pradesh was a restless soul, running all around to protect his political turf. He was ably assisted by all constituents of the Sangh Parivar whose deep penetration in the state for decades on end is quite evident. Yet Chouhan lost ground to a less organised and untested leadership of the Congress. In a state where the BJP ruled for 15 years, how this situation has come about?
 
One obvious answer to this query is the hubris engendered by longevity in public offices. Chouhan’s long innings as the chief minister seemed to have developed an aura of invincibility around himself. Oblivious to the ground slipping away beneath his feet in rural areas on account of economic distress and mafia activity, Chouhan seemed to have believed that his old tricks of social-welfare spending and winning over certain caste groups would sail him through. Unlike the past when his government’s social spending ameliorated the lot of the poor, his welfare schemes triggered more scandals than uplift the poor.
 
That Chouhan started believing in his own invincibility was evident all across the state where he, accompanied by his wife Sadhna Singh, featured prominently in campaign posters. For the first time, the election campaign posters were seen carrying pictures of the wife of the sitting chief minister. The incongruity of such campaign is not ethical but political. In the Indian context where the family is kept away from public life, Chouhan’s indiscretion was glaring. More so in light of the fact that there were murmurs in power corridors of Bhopal that the Chouhan household wielded undue influence in running the state administration.
 
It is nobody’s case that Chouhan ran an inefficient administration. Far from it; Chouhan could justifiably be credited with running an efficient government that substantially improved the quality of life of people. For instance, the state had very poor connectivity when it came to roads and electricity only 15 years back. The rural infrastructure was abysmally poor and urban growth was haphazard. No doubt, Madhya Pradesh has now taken a giant leap forward and enhanced its capacity in urban growth and rural infrastructure. It came out of the tag of ‘BIMARU’ states on account of surplus agriculture production.
 
But all that proved to be of no avail as there was substantial erosion in the credibility quotient of the chief minister that ultimately triggered a fatigue factor. Chouhan’s propensity to stick to time-tested formulae of social spending and mouthing bravados like “Mai ke lal” in support of scheduled castes entailed the law of diminishing political returns. People seemed to become weary of platitudes and took all development works initiated by the BJP government as their entitlements. Apparently Chouhan had lost novelty value while seeking his re-election for the fourth time.
 
The fact that the BJP still retained support in electoral terms which is bigger than the Congress can justifiably credited to the formidable organisational machinery which remains not only intact but fighting fit. But this election has also blown the myth of the party’s overreliance on the organization at the time of elections. The biggest takeaway of this election is:  irrespective of existence of robust organisational machinery, people would choose a lamppost against a ruling titan if they decide to.
 
[This analysis has appeared on FirstPost.com]
 
 
 

Comments

 

Other News

Maharashtra NCC Directorate bags PM Banner at R-Day celebrations

For NCC, the Republic Day Celebrations (‘RDC’) this year – in the year of ‘Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav’ and ‘Swarnim Vijay Varsh culminated’ –with the PM’s rally at Carriappa Parade Ground at Delhi Cantt on Friday. Cadets from 17 NCC director

Covid conundrum: Where exactly does all the government money go?

COUNTDOWN Can India Rebound from the Meltdown of the Century? By Anshuman Tiwari and Anindya Sengupta Bloomsbury, 268 pages, Rs. 799

Governance Now to honour achievers with Visionary Awards 2021

On January 29, the Governance Now a platform for analysis of public policy and governance from the house of Sri Adhikari Brothers will honour achievers with the Visionary Awards of 2021 in a virtual webinar attended by thousands of followers. Hon’ble Union Minister, Law and Justice, S

How should budget 2022 handle the water and sanitation sector?

Why sanitation in budget 2022-23 is important? The upcoming budget 2022-23 will be of significant value as India is in the middle of the third wave of the pandemic. The budget presents an opportunity to aid the specific sectors of the economy to recover as well as combat the severi

Imperative omissions in the Constitution

The making of the Indian Constitution and its subsequent adoption on January 26, 1950 required the founding members to go through several pieces of the legal document that the country already had during the British rule, let alone the Constitution of other countries. Until 1857, these laws, although applie

R-Day parade showcases India’s military might, cultural diversity

President Ram Nath Kovind led the Nation in celebrating the 73rd Republic Day today as part of ‘Azadi ka Amrit Mahotsav’ across the country. The celebration saw a series of new events conceptualised by the defence ministry during the main parade on Rajpath along with ‘Beat

Visionary Talk: Ram Pratap Singh with Kailashnath Adhikari on UP Elections


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter