Ubershame is more complicated than I thought

Mulling over the details had left me in absolute shock

pujab

Puja Bhattacharjee | December 8, 2014



I had been racking my brain all day today trying to pinpoint what exactly led to the tragic Uber cab incident in which a professional was raped by the driver of the cab she had hired through the aggregator. I made hectic calls to Meru, Mega and Easy cabs trying to find out, both as a concerned woman passenger and a curious journalist, what their safety policies are. In between I indulged in cursing Uber cabs for being so lackadaisical. But soon my anger and frustration turned towards the Delhi police when news started flashing that in spite of the past criminal record of the accused, they had issued a clean character certificate. A ‘ban the police’ cry ensued. Like so many other men and women, I got carried away by emotion.

As I was discussing the details of the case with friends, it suddenly struck me - the accused had spent seven months in jail for allegedly raping a woman but was later acquitted. In anger I had completely overlooked the fact that Shiv Kumar Yadav was acquitted, not convicted. So I started thinking, can we really blame either Uber or Delhi police for what happened. Uber followed the procedure for police verification and Delhi police issued him a clean character certificate based on record. So apparently nobody was at fault.

All this time I had been trying to find out what loopholes of the law led to this unfortunate incident. In fact Uber CEO Travis Kalanick in his statement has said, “We will work with the government to establish clear background checks currently absent in their commercial transportation licensing programs.” In light of the above, this is a very significant remark. The Ambedkar Nagar police station certificate mentions that Shiv Kumar Yadav is not involved in any criminal offence as on the date of the verification. Technically Yadav is an innocent man. My realisation leads me to believe that the entire system has collapsed. The system is very casual and superficial. There ought to have a column to mention whether Yadav was in any way involved in a case earlier along with the outcome. Given the nature of his previous accusation I am sure Uber would have rethought hiring him. Moreover, we do not have any centralised legal database of the convicted to crosscheck information from all over the country.

But this also opens the debate - what about men who had been framed and later acquitted? Why should they be discriminated against? The situation just went from sticky to stickier. Now I am speechless with shock. This is not an average ‘who is to blame’ or ‘what needs to change’ debate. It is a very complicated and complex matter to which I cannot see any immediate solution.

Comments

 

Other News

If art or culture disappears, it wipes out an entire generation with it: Pankaj Tripathi

Known for his indelible roles in Gangs of Wasseypur and Nil Battey Sannata, Pankaj Tripathi  hails from a village in Bihar where many people still don’t have TV sets at home. His parents are farmers in Gopalganj district and the down-to-earth actor likes working in his farm whenever he visit

The unbearable weight of scorched earth

The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), in independent analyses, have declared 2016 the hottest year since 1880. Scientists have said that the planet witnessed three consecutive years of record heat.  The

Does India need IPS and IAS officers?

Does India need IPS and IAS officers?

PSUs under steel ministry must share resources: Minister

Steel minister Chaudhary Birender Singh has directed a high-level coordination committee comprising CMDs and top ministry officials to be constituted for pooling and sharing of resources among PSUs.   He said, “This will lead to aggregation of demand and economies of sc

India seeks dispute panel against US at WTO

India has submitted its first request for establishment of a dispute panel against the US at the World Trade Organisation (WTO)—a request that was blocked by Washington on February 20 stating that this dispute was launched for purely political reasons. According to India, eleven measures ad

So what Pahlaj Nihalani, if there`s lipstick under the burkha

The Central Board of Film Certification seems to be fast turning into 16th century Italian theatre Commedia dell`arte, whose special characteristic is the lazzo - a joke. And Pahlaj Nihalani is the prima donna of all that is not right with the censor board. Nihalani, who is frequently quite

Video

अखिलेश डूबते जहाज में जा बैठे - मोदी
Digital Transformation Summit

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter