Income tax department irregularly allowed deductions: CAG -Governance Now

Income tax department irregularly allowed deductions: CAG

The income tax department irregularly allowed deduction to assessees in 19 cases in eight states in respect of income earned through sale of carbon credit

GN Bureau | November 23, 2016

#carbon credit #Income Tax department #CAG #infrastructure

The income tax department irregularly allowed deduction to assessees in 33 cases across 13 states in respect of infrastructure developed by joint venture formed by collaboration with foreign companies, undertakings owned by association of persons (AOPs), assessees who did not enter into agreement with the government, non-compliant industrial park and excluded works contractors. This resulted in underassessment of income involving tax effect of Rs 205.84 crore, observed the CAG.

The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report on allowance of deduction to the assessees engaged in infrastructure development said that the ITD irregularly allowed deduction to assesses in 16 cases in eight states where the business of the assessees such as sale of plots, projects not covered under infrastructural facilities, conversion charges, development/maintenance of park etc, were not eligible for the deduction. This resulted in underassessment of income involving tax effect of Rs 174.35 crore.

The report also noted that the income tax department irregularly allowed deduction to assessees in 19 cases in eight states in respect of income earned through sale of carbon credit which involved tax effect of Rs 34.77 crore.

“The ITD irregularly considered additions made on account of treatment of expenditure as revenue, sale of fixed assets, disallowance made u/s 40A(3) 14A, 40(a) etc., for deduction in nine cases in five states. Consequently, the allowances were more than the amount claimed by the assessee involving consequential tax effect of Rs 74.66 crore.

“The ITD irregularly allowed deduction to assessees in eight cases in two states in respect of profits derived from ‘Railway Sidings/Jetties’ constructed and operated by the assessees for their private purposes, which did not qualify to be treated as infrastructure facilities in terms of Explanation to section 80 IA(4). Irregular allowance of deduction attracted tax effect of Rs 2066.70 crore.”

The report went on to say that the ITD irregularly allowed deduction to assessees in six cases in four states for the period beyond the permissible limit of 10 consecutive assessment years, starting from the declared initial assessment year. Incorrect allowance of deductions resulted in underassessment of income involving tax effect of Rs 859.47 crore.

“The ITD irregularly allowed deduction to assessees in 15 cases in eight states where the assessee did not apportion the common expenses between eligible and non eligible units properly which resulted in excess allowance of deduction involving tax effect of Rs 224.47 crore.”

Read the full CAG report here

Comments

Other News

When insurance fails our migrant workers

Two weeks ago, 28 year old Senthil Kumar (name changed) from Tiruppur died of a heart attack in a labour camp near Dammam, Saudi Arabia. His body came home to Chennai because his employer agreed to pay for the airfare. His family received ₹10 lakh under the Pravasi Bharatiya Bima Yojana (PBBY). The distr

Fifty years later, what we need to learn from the Emergency?

50 Years of the Indian Emergency: Lessons for Democracy Edited by Peter Ronald deSouza and Harsh Sethi Orient BlackSwan, 376 pages, Rs 1,025

Diwali now part of UNESCO’s Intangible Cultural Heritage list

Deepavali, the festival of lights, has been inscribed on UNESCO’s List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity. This was announced at the 20th UNESCO Intergovernmental Committee session at Red Fort, New Delhi, held from December 8-13, 2025. It is the 16th Indian element on thi

IIT Bombay launches Rs 250 crore deep-tech VC fund

The Society for Innovation and Entrepreneurship (SINE) at IIT Bombay has launched India’s first deep-tech venture capital fund managed by an academia-linked incubator -- the Y-Point Venture Capital Fund. With a total corpus of Rs 250 crore, the fund aims to accelerate early-stage deep-tech startups b

Revisiting anti-Sikh violence of 1984

Remembering the Past: Critical Perspectives on the Anti-Sikh Violence of 1984 Edited by Ishmeet Kaur Chaudhry, with a Foreword by Amritjit Singh Orient BlackSwan, pages, Rs 1,285

`Vande Mataram showed India the way to self-reliance`

`Vande Mataram` showed India the way to self-reliance. "It became a mantra to challenge external companies, which also expanded the mantra of independence towards the mantra of Swadeshi,” prime minister Narendra Modi said in the Lok Sabha on Monday, as he initiated a debate on the occasion of th