Demonetisation costs include a contraction in cash money supply and subsequent, albeit temporary, slowdown in GDP growth; benefits include increased digitalisation
GN Bureau | January 31, 2017
Finance minister Arun Jaitley on Tuesday said that post demonetisation, once the cash supply is replenished, which is likely to be achieved by end March 2017, the economy would revert to the normal. Therefore, the real GDP growth in 2017-18 is projected to be in the range of 6.75-7.5 percent.
The Economic Survey presented in parliament points out that demonetisation will have both short-term costs and long-term benefits. Briefly, the costs include a contraction in cash money supply and subsequent, albeit temporary, slowdown in GDP growth; and benefits include increased digitalisation, greater tax compliance and a reduction in real estate prices, which could increase long-run tax revenue collections and GDP growth.
On the benefits side, early evidence suggests that digitalisation has increased since demonetisation. On the cost side, effective cash in circulation fell sharply although by much less than commonly believed – a peak of 35 percent in December, rather than 62 percent in November since many of the old high denomination notes continued to be used for transactions in the weeks after November 8.
Additionally, remonetisation will ensure that the cash squeeze is eliminated by April 2017. The cash squeeze in the meantime will have significant implications for GDP, reducing 2016-17 growth by 0.25 to 0.5 percentage points compared to the baseline of 7 percent. Recorded GDP will understate impact on informal sector because, for example, informal manufacturing is estimated using formal sector indicators (index of industrial production). These contractionary effects will dissipate by year-end when currency in circulation should once again be in line with estimated demand, which would also allow growth to converge to a trend by FY 2017-18.
Effect through end-December
Likely longer-term effect
|Money/interest rates||Cash declined sharply||Cash will recover but settle at a lower level|
|Bank deposits increased sharply||Deposits will decline, but probably settle at a slightly higher level|
|RBI's balance sheet largely unchanged: return of currency reduced the central bank’s cash liabilities but increased its deposit liabilities to commercial banks||RBI's balance sheet will shrink, after the deadline for redeeming outstanding notes|
|Interest rates on deposits, loans, and government securities declined; implicit rate on cash increased||Loan rates could fall further, if much of the deposit increase proves durable|
|Financial System Savings||Increased||Increase, to the extent that the cash-deposit ratio falls permanently|
|Corruption (underlying illicit activities)||Could decline, if incentives for compliance improve|
|Unaccounted income/black money (underlying activity may or may not be illicit)||Stock of black money fell, as some holders came into the tax net||Formalization should reduce the flow of unaccounted income|
|Private Wealth||Private sector wealth declined, since some high denomination notes were not returned and real estate prices fell||Wealth could fall further, if real estate prices continue to decline|
|Public Sector Wealth||No effect.||Government/RBI's wealth will increase when unreturned cash is extinguished, reducing liabilities|
|Formalization/ digitilisation||Digital transactions amongst new users (RuPay/ AEPS) increased sharply; existing users’ transactions increased in line with historical trend||Some return to cash as supply normalises, but the now-launched digital revolution will continue|
|Real estate||Prices declined, as wealth fell while cash shortages impeded transactions||Prices could fall further as investing undeclared income in real estate becomes more difficult; but tax component could rise, especially if GST imposed on real estate|
|Broader economy||Job losses, decline in farm incomes, social disruption, especially in cash-intensive sectors||Should gradually stabilize as the economy is remonetized|
|GDP||Growth slowed, as demonetisation reduced demand (cash, private wealth), supply (reduced liquidity and working capital, and disrupted supply chains), and increased uncertainty||Could be beneficial in the long run if formalization increases and corruption falls|
|Cash-intensive sectors (agriculture, real estate, jewellery) were affected more. Recorded GDP will understate impact on informal sector because informal manufacturing is estimated using formal sector indicators (Index of Industrial Production). But over time as the economy becomes more formalized the underestimation will decline. Recorded GDP will also be overstated because banking sector value added is based (inter alia) on deposits which have surged temporarily||Informal output could decline but recorded GDP would increase as the economy becomes more formalized|
|Tax collection||Income taxes rose because of increased disclosure Payments to local bodies and discoms increased because demonetised notes remained legal tender for tax payments/clearances of arrears||Indirect and corporate taxes could decline, to the extent growth slows Over long run, taxes should increase as formalization expands and compliance improves|
|Uncertainty/ Credibility||Uncertainty increased, as firms and households were unsure of the economic impact and implications for future policy Investment decisions and durable goods purchases postponed||Credibility will be strengthened if demonetisation is accompanied by complementary measures. Early and full remonetisation essential. Tax arbitrariness and harassment could attenuate credibility|
The arrest of Palaniappan Chidambaram, former union minister of home & finance, by the CBI, albeit after his much dramatic disappearance and reappearance, has brought an end to his long run from the arms of law. As a finance minister, being at the other end of the law, the former ministe
An unintended consequence of the inversion of Article 370 and the division of the state of Jammu and Kashmir into two union territories is the curious revival of Pakistan’s interest in Indian history and sociology. For the first time in decades, a Pakistan prime minister made the Rasht
Neeraj Kabi, a critically acclaimed self-taught actor, theatre director, and acting teacher, has worked in Odiya, Hindi and international cinema, theatre, television and web series. In 2014 he was honoured with the best actor award at the 4th Sakhalin International Film Festival for his role in the fil
Prime minister Narendra Modi has told US president Donald Trump that Pakistan prime minister Imran Khan’s “incitement to anti-India violence” was not good for peace in south Asia. Modi and Trump had a telephonic conversation – their first since the Aug 5 move to chang
As children are consuming more and more fast foods and sweetened beverages are becoming, leading to obesity and related non-communicable diseases (NCDs), the Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) has come out with guidelines on such substances. The dietary guidelines under its nutrition chapter
Contrast prime minister Narendra Modi’s first Independence Day speech in 2014 with his latest, the first in the second term, and you know the difference. His first speech was less about future and much about the basic needs like Swachch Bharat (clean India). His speech on Thursday, on the other hand,