MNREGS vs graft, not centre vs state

Corruption in rural jobs guarantee scheme was exposed by Governance Now

trithesh

Trithesh Nandan | October 28, 2011



The slugfest between the centre and the Uttar Pradesh government continues on Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee (MNREG) scheme in the state. After Jairam Ramesh’s letter to the UP government last week, Mayawati has accused the rural development minister of playing politics. With the state elections around the corner, Mayawati has rubbished Ramesh's allegations by attributing “political motives” to his letter.

In the present context more significant than usual politics is the huge corruption in the MNREGS implementation. Governance Now was the first to expose the whole issue threadbare in the October 16-31 issue. As part of a Governance Now team, I went to two districts of UP – Kanpur Dehat and Unnao. My colleagues went to Varanasi, Sonbhadra, Kushinagar and Siddharth Nagar. All we found was that there was blatant misuse of the scheme funds, which were meant to provide employment to rural household.

We were amazed at the ingenuity of UP bureaucracy in innovating new ways of making money. Their imaginative skills were at display when we learnt that a 400-metre road cost Rs 7.83 crore in a village, Rs 10 lakh were spent on a 175 metre long, two and half feet wide track, mitti bharai and construction of a boundary wall at government nursery cost Rs 22.33 lakh, a pond cost Rs 2 crore, check dams of Rs 40 lakh, brick guard to protect sapling cost of Rs 6.6 crore ... the list can go on.

We also found out the most expensive hole in the ground, where a soak pit of barely one cubic metre was dug up for a whooping Rs. 1.66 crore. There were glaring gaps between “estimated cost” and “actual expenditure”. Also, the mistakes in feeding data into the management information system (MIS) were evident.

However, all these were lesser crimes compared to the mother of all embezzlement my colleague found – a mythical Taj Mahal to Red Fort road in Sevapuri in Varanasi district – a non-existent road worth Rs 1 crore!

The questions which emerged from our ground visit was: is there any monitor mechanism to investigate all the projects in villages? Who are the people pulling strings behinds the scenes?

As we searched for answers, all we got in reply from lower-rung officials was that all these scams might be computer mistakes. Then, why did not the state government check the data before it showed up on the rural development ministry website?

Some of these questions left us puzzled, more so because last year the Obama administration heaped praises on the innovative social scheme. A briefing of the MNREGS was arranged at the G-20 in Washington in 2010. But nobody knew that in our own backyard, our own officials were letting the scheme down by writing inflated bills, filing wrong MIS entries, diverting funds and embezzling crores straight into pockets.

Unfortunately Mayawati refuses to see it beyond politics. She seems quite oblivious to the fact that growing corruption would end up marginalising only those who are socially and economically depressed. Ironically this social section always looked towards her as saviour. Given the fact that Mayawati has stubbornly looked the other way, there is a strong possibility of this serious issue getting derailed in the centre-versus-state political tussle. Those involved in siphoning off people's money would ultimately have the last laugh.
 

Comments

 

Other News

CAG flags major fiscal lapses in Maharashtra

Maharashtra`s fiscal management has come under sharp scrutiny after the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India, in its State Finances Audit Report for 2024-25, flagged significant budgetary inefficiencies, accounting irregularities, understatement of key fiscal indicators and widespread governanc

The health sector research we are not doing

Some neglect is loud. This kind is quiet. It sits in research never commissioned, data never collected, questions never asked. In South Asia, that quiet has let the region’s worst health problems stay understudied, underfunded, and out of sight of those who could act.  

Study flags accessibility and last-mile challenges on Mumbai Metro Aqua Line

Mumbai Metro Line 3 (Aqua Line), the city`s first fully underground metro corridor and one of its largest public transport investments, represents a major engineering achievement and has been widely welcomed by commuters. However, the overall commuter experience continues to be constrained by accessibili

Centre intensifies preparedness as El Niño threat looms

Amid uncertainty in the southwest monsoon due to the potential impact of El Niño, the government is addressing the situation with comprehensive preparedness, a clear strategy, and strong ground-level action. While challenges remain, the entire system has been activated in advance and is working proa

India is crossing a climate threshold

On June 28, Delhi recorded a maximum temperature of 41.3°C, four degrees above the seasonal normal. But the “feels like” temperature, which factors in humidity, showed more than 51°C. What the body experienced was very different from what the thermometer recorded.  India`

The Geography of India’s inflation

India today finds itself in an unusual position. At a time when geopolitical conflicts, trade fragmentation, and supply-chain disruptions are reshaping the global economy, the country`s macroeconomic fundamentals remain relatively upwards. Growth remains among the highest in the world, inflation has larg





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter