Probe this act of omission

Why is CBI out of RTI Act?

danish

Danish Raza | June 28, 2011



Just when the attention of newsmen across the nation was fixed on the Lokpal issue, the government excluded the central bureau of investigation (CBI) from the purview of the right to information (RTI) act.

And how did you and I come to know about it? The agency, responding to the RTI query filed by Subhash Chandra Agrawal told him that as per a June 9 notification, it had been included in the list of agencies exempted from the purview of the transparency act.

The CBI’s argument is that since it probes sensitive cases, sharing information with public can have crucial ramifications.

CBI had sent its request for exemption from the RTI act to the Department of personnel and training (DoPT) which forwarded it to the law ministry for its opinion.

Interestingly both the Department of personnel and training (DoPT) and the law ministry did not buy the CBI’s argument.

But it appears that the government found sense in the opinion of attorney general G Vahanvati who said that the CBI was involved in safeguarding the country’s economic security and intelligence
gathering.

There are many reasons why the exemption of CBI from the RTI act needs rethinking.

Section 24 of the RTI act puts intelligence and security agencies outside the purview of the act. CBI is purely an investigating agency just like police. The law makers must have given some thought while preparing the list of original 22 agencies exempted from the act and they knew that CBI did not meet the criteria to make it to that list.

Second, section 8 (1) (h) of the RTI act says that the public authority can withhold information which can affect the process of investigation or prosecution or apprehension or prosecution of offenders. But this does not translate into a blanket denial of information. A landmark judgment given in 2007 by justice S Ravindar Bhat in ‘Bhagat Singh Vs chief information commissioners and others’ put things in perspective. “The mere existence of an investigation process cannot be a ground for refusal of the information; the authority withholding information must show satisfactory reasons as to why the release of such information would hamper the investigation process. Such reasons should be germane, and the opinion of the process being hampered should be reasonable and based on some material. Sans this consideration, Section 8(1) (h) and other such provisions would become the haven for dodging demands for information,” the court ruled.
In a similar judgment, the Central Information Commission (CIC) ruled on June 24 that the public authority cannot deny information on the premise of an ongoing probe.

Third, the RTI act has provision whereby any public authority can deny information if it can endanger the life of the citizens or can affect the country relations with another nation. Also, there is a provision where the public authority is allowed to take the permission of an individual before disclosing certain information/ letter/ document pertaining him or her. This is called ‘third party’ information.

Fourth, since the enactment of the act in 2005, there has been not a single case to prove that transparency has in any manner hampered the functioning of the CBI.

Therefore, both the decision to keep CBI out of the RTI act and the way it has been done, have serious flaws.

The only factor which justifies the government’s decision is that fact that the agency is probing some of the biggest corruption cases including the 2G spectrum and CWG which involve the high and mighty. With already so much information in public domain, the government cannot afford letting us know more about the A Rajas, the Kalmadis, the Marans and their bosses.

 

Comments

 

Other News

Maharashtra FDA cracks down on `health supplements`; seizes stock worth Rs 1.39 cr

The Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a comprehensive state wide compliance order tightening regulations governing health supplements, nutraceuticals, sports nutrition products and foods for special dietary and medical purposes. The order, issued by Commissioner of Food Safety, Tu

States face rising fiscal pressure as spending outpaces revenue

States across India are facing increasing fiscal pressures, with revenue expenditure growing faster than revenue receipts since 2022-23, largely driven by rising subsidies and transfers, according to the annual ‘State of State Finances 2026-27’ report released by PRS Legislative Research.

Global value chains and sustainability

When a country’s factories become part of global supply chains, making parts or products that feed into goods sold around the world, the economy usually looks stronger. Output rises, exports grow, and technology improves. But the research behind this article [Bhayana and Nag, 2026] asks a harder qu

Narrative sovereignty in the digital age

In today’s world, competition between countries is not limited to military strength or economic power. It also takes place through the stories countries tell about themselves and the way others describe them. Social media and digital platforms have made this competition faster and more visible. Whe

The hidden cost of voter-ID link with welfare

On October 30, panchayati raj minister Rajiv Ranjan Singh, better known as Lalan Singh, told a national workshop in Delhi that Aadhaar would no longer be the basis for government schemes. His argument seemed simple enough. Aadhaar centres are now in every locality, and anyone can get a card made for anyb

The silent epidemic in the Northeast

In Mizoram, more than nine in ten people can read. Anyone there can find out how HIV spreads and how to protect themselves. Yet Mizoram has the highest rates of HIV patients in the country. If education were enough, this would’ve been solved long ago, but it was not. The answer tells us something a

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter