Why treat Asaram different from other sex crime accused?

Kid-gloved treatment offered to self-styled spiritual guru raises many questions – and more stink

jasleen

Jasleen Kaur | August 29, 2013



The way the political administrations in multiple states are treating Asaram ‘Bapu’, the self-claimed godman/spiritual guru who is alleged to have sexually assaulted a teenager, has given rise to several questions. About not only law enforcement but also law implementation.

We live in a democracy that believes in the rule of law. So why is Asaram being treated above law?

How is Asaram’s case different from other rape or sexual assault cases in our country? Political parties, especially the BJP, are trying to evade the issue by contending that nothing has been proved yet; that Asaram is innocent until proven guilty. Why do they recall such dictums only when it is convenient for them? Nothing has been proved against either Robert Vadra (in Haryana land deal allegations), Manmohan Singh (coal blocks allocation scam, among many others) or Narendra Modi (inciting 2002 Gujarat riots). So do BJP and Congress leaders not remember the innocent-until-proven-otherwise maxim when calling for their resignation/arrest?

Would political leaders arguing for Asaram on these lines give the same long rope to the five men accused of raping a journalist in a Mumbai mill? Similarly, though the trial is on for nearly seven months now, none of the accused has yet been proven guilty in the December 16 Delhi gangrape case either. So will the politicians say those men (and the juvenile) are as yet innocent?

If not, why is Asaram being given a benefit of doubt? Why can the authorities not treat this case like others?

Rajasthan chief minister Ashok Gehlot has said that no one is above the law, but then why is he refusing to give a clear reply on when will Asaram be arrested?

Jodhpur police, who are investigating the charges of sexual assault, after dropping the teenager’s allegation that the ‘guru’ raped her in his ashram in Jodhpur, had on August 26 issued summons to Asaram, asking him to appear before them by August 30 to record his statement. That’s a four-day leeway anyway. Why? Do Jodhpur police reserve the same treatment for all men accused of sexual harassment?

The police say there are some loopholes and contradictions in the girl's statement, and which need to be investigated further. But shouldn’t the onus also be on Asaram to prove that her charges are wrong?

Having denied the charges, and also mocking the victim by calling her a “smart girl”, Asaram, on the run since the case was filed, had sought time till September 16 to appear before the police. But why does he need time to record a statement if he is innocent?

Why is he running away from Jodhpur police and not assisting the probe?

And why are the government and the police ready to give him that time?

Asaram has been booked under IPC sections 376 (rape; though charge dropped subsequently), 342 (wrongful confinement), 506 (criminal intimidation) and 509 (words, gesture or act intended to insult modesty of a woman); section 8 of Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) and sections 23 and 26 of Juvenile Justice Act in connection with the alleged assault. An FIR has already been lodged against him but he is still to be arrested. So does that mean Asaram, who had earlier said the Delhi gangrape victim was equally responsible for the fatal attack, is above law?

Is he being given time – and I stress the word ‘given’, for no other man accused of such a crime would get even a day to be free and bargain with the cops – because he has a certain 'image' or enjoys political patronage?

In a scathing observation, the supreme court this week said a rapist's offer to marry the rape survivor could never be a ground for letting off the guilty lightly. No compromise between rapists and rape survivors could reduce the gravity of the offence, the apex court said.

Does Asaram believe he can get past even the supreme court’s observation by calling the teenaged victim his "daughter"?

Comments

 

Other News

New Delhi’s Indo-Pacific strategy enters a new phase

India appears to be investing fresh dynamism in its Indo-Pacific strategy. At the time when the US, under president Donald Trump, has adopted a conciliatory approach towards China and has changed the name of America’s Indo-Pacific Command to just Pacific Command, India has quietly moved towards con

CAG flags major fiscal lapses in Maharashtra

Maharashtra`s fiscal management has come under sharp scrutiny after the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India, in its State Finances Audit Report for 2024-25, flagged significant budgetary inefficiencies, accounting irregularities, understatement of key fiscal indicators and widespread governanc

The health sector research we are not doing

Some neglect is loud. This kind is quiet. It sits in research never commissioned, data never collected, questions never asked. In South Asia, that quiet has let the region’s worst health problems stay understudied, underfunded, and out of sight of those who could act.  

Study flags accessibility and last-mile challenges on Mumbai Metro Aqua Line

Mumbai Metro Line 3 (Aqua Line), the city`s first fully underground metro corridor and one of its largest public transport investments, represents a major engineering achievement and has been widely welcomed by commuters. However, the overall commuter experience continues to be constrained by accessibili

Centre intensifies preparedness as El Niño threat looms

Amid uncertainty in the southwest monsoon due to the potential impact of El Niño, the government is addressing the situation with comprehensive preparedness, a clear strategy, and strong ground-level action. While challenges remain, the entire system has been activated in advance and is working proa

India is crossing a climate threshold

On June 28, Delhi recorded a maximum temperature of 41.3°C, four degrees above the seasonal normal. But the “feels like” temperature, which factors in humidity, showed more than 51°C. What the body experienced was very different from what the thermometer recorded.  India`





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter