HC flays Idea for suppressing information in Spice merger case

Court expressed displeasure with Idea for failing to place some relevant communication relating to the merger before the court

PTI | May 20, 2011



Aditya Birla Group firm Idea Cellular on Thursday faced the ire of the Delhi High Court for suppressing certain documents while getting its approval for merger with Spice Communications.

Idea, meanwhile, cried foul against the Department of Telecom (DoT) for furnishing to the court only parts of its correspondence with the company and getting a stay on the merger "behind its back", without getting any notice.

However, Justice Manmohan expressed displeasure with Idea for not being fair to the court and failing to place some relevant communication relating to their merger.

"You don't even produce basic documents, licence agreements and correspondence. Then you are rely on some judgements. Your clients (Idea and Spice) are not being fair to the court. How could the court make a informed decision?" Manmohan told the counsel for the telecom companies.

"Do you think this correspondence is useless? Your scheme of merger says about transfer of licence. This document is not disclosed to court. Real grab of the matter is not disclosed?" he added.

DoT has alleged that the two companies had suppressed information while securing the court approval for the merger. Later, the court stayed the merger on DoT's plea.

Meanwhile, Idea and Spice refuted DoT allegations, blaming the department for not furnishing all correspondence between them before securing the stay order.

"It is unfair that they (DoT) do not give complete correspondence. DoT approached the Delhi High Court on March 30, three years after the merger, and they do not serve me the application and get stay behind my back. It is against natural justice," said Senior advocate Abhishek M Singhvi, appearing for the telcos.

The company maintained that it was its "Bonafide belief" that for the merger of companies it had to seek the court's approval, and for merger of licences DoT's nod was required.

DoT has also issued a cancellation order to Idea for the overlapping of licences in the same circle in view of the merger announced in 2008.

The companies alleged high handedness on part of DoT for selectively withholding their 3G spectrum, issuing show cause and demand notices, and then obtaining an ex-parte order on the three year old merger.

Idea is facing charges of violation of terms and conditions and has claimed that it never wanted to retain the unused spectrum and had offered to surrender the overlapping licence.
 

Comments

 

Other News

Beyond LPG: Is PNG ready for India’s next cooking fuel transition?

India, the second-largest importer and consumer of LPG after China, faces growing pressure due to supply constraints. Most of India`s LPG imports transit through the Strait of Hormuz, a focal point of global turmoil. Given that LPG forms the backbone of household kitchens and the restaurant industry, any s

Maharashtra adopts hybrid model for Census 2026 data collection

The government has initiated preparations for Census 2026 in Maharashtra, introducing a hybrid approach that combines optional self-enumeration with comprehensive door-to-door data collection to ensure complete coverage across the state.   According to senior officials, the Self-

What the nine Indian Nobel winners have in common

A Touch Of Genius: The Wisdom of India’s Nobel Laureates Edited by Rudrangshu Mukherjee Aleph Books, Rs 1499, 848 pages  

Income Tax dept holds Ghatkopar Outreach on new IT Act

The Income Tax Department organised an outreach programme in Ghatkopar, Mumbai, to raise awareness about the key features of the Income Tax Act, 2025, effective April 1, 2026. The initiative is part of a nationwide effort to promote taxpayer awareness, simplify compliance, and strengthen a transparent, eff

Making AI work where governance is closest to people

India’s next governance leap may not solely come from digitisation. It will come from making public systems more intelligent, more adaptive, and more responsive to the dynamics at the grassroots. That opportunity is especially significant at the panchayat level, where governance is not an abstract po

Borrowing troubles: How small loans are quietly trapping youth

A silent crisis is playing out in the pocket of young India, not in stock markets or government treasuries, but in smartphones of college students and first-jobbers who clicked on the Apply Now button without reading the small print.  A decade ago, to take a loan, you had to do some paperwor


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter