Parl's right to amend laws supreme: FM on Vodafone case

Justifies decision to amend the Income Tax Act

PTI | May 17, 2012



Government on Wednesday justified its decision to neutralise the impact of supreme court decision in the Vodafone case by amending the Income Tax Act with retrospective effect suggesting it was to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

Winding up a debate on Finance Bill in the rajya sabha, finance minister Pranab Mukherjee said parliament is omnipotent and has right to change any provision of the Constitution.

He said the government had to amend the Income Tax Act following the supreme court judgement to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

With the passage of the Finance Bill, 2012 by parliament, the British telecom giant Vodafone might have to pay Rs 20,300 crore as tax, interest and penalty on its acquisition of Hutchison stake in Hutchison Essar in 2007. The deal was signed in Cayman Islands.

"Indian parliament is omnipotent...It has the power to amend any Article of the Constitution," Mukherjee said, adding the government's decision should not be seen as disrespect to supreme court.

"It is not to ignore the constitutionally assigned responsibility of the supreme court...As judiciary has the right to interpret law, legislature has the right to enact law. In the process, if there are divergences of opinion it should be treated as confrontation, it is the honest difference of opinion. If we make an attempt of reconciling that honest difference of opinion, it is not wrong," he said.

Mukherjee said he had told UK Chancellor of Exchequer George Osborne "(what) you have done in your country and I have exactly done it". Government today justified its decision to neutralise the impact of supreme court decision in the Vodafone case by amending the Income Tax Act with retrospective effect suggesting it was to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

Winding up a debate on Finance Bill in the rajya sabha, finance minister Pranab Mukherjee said parliament is omnipotent and has right to change any provision of the Constitution.

He said the government had to amend the Income Tax Act following the supreme court judgement to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

With the passage of the Finance Bill, 2012 by parliament, the British telecom giant Vodafone might have to pay Rs 20,300 crore as tax, interest and penalty on its acquisition of Hutchison stake in Hutchison Essar in 2007. The deal was signed in Cayman Islands.

"Indian parliament is omnipotent...It has the power to amend any Article of the Constitution," Mukherjee said, adding the government's decision should not be seen as disrespect to supreme court.

"It is not to ignore the constitutionally assigned responsibility of the supreme court...As judiciary has the right to interpret law, legislature has the right to enact law. In the process, if there are divergences of opinion it should be treated as confrontation, it is the honest difference of opinion. If we make an attempt of reconciling that honest difference of opinion, it is not wrong," he said.

Mukherjee said he had told UK Chancellor of Exchequer George Osborne "(what) you have done in your country and I have exactly done it".

Comments

 

Other News

A 19th-century pilgrim’s progress

The Travels of a Sadhu in the Himalayas By Jaladhar Sen (Translated by Somdatta Mandal) Speaking Tiger Books, 259 pages, ₹499.00  

India faces critical shortage of skin donors amid rising burn cases

India reports nearly 70 lakh burn injury cases every year, resulting in approximately 1.4 lakh deaths annually. Experts estimate that up to 50% of these lives could be saved with adequate access to skin donations.   A significant concern is that around 70% of burn victims fall wi

Not just politics, let`s discuss policies too

Why public policy matters Most days, India`s loudest debates stop at the ballot box. We can name every major leader and recall every campaign slogan. Still, far fewer of us can explain why a widow`s pension is delayed or how a government school`s budget is actually approved. That

When algorithms decide and children die

The images have not left me, of dead and wounded children being carried in the arms of the medics and relatives to the ambulances and hospitals. On February 28, at the start of Operation Epic Fury, cruise missiles struck the Shajareh Tayyebeh school – officially named a girls’ school, in Minab,

The economics of representation: Why women in power matter

India’s democracy has grown in scale, but not quite in balance. Women today are active participants in elections, influencing outcomes in ways that were not as visible earlier. Yet their presence in legislative institutions continues to lag behind. The Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam was meant to addres

India will be powerful, not aggressive: Bhaiyyaji

India is poised to emerge as a global power but will remain rooted in its civilisational ethos of non-aggression and harmony, former RSS General Secretary Suresh `Bhaiyyaji` Joshi has said.   He was speaking at the launch of “Rashtrabhav,” a book by Ravindra Sathe


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter