• About Us
  • Feedback
  • Events Calendar
  • Archives
  • Newsletter
Advanced Search
  • Home
  • News
  • Views
  • GovNow
  • GovNext
  • Login
  • Register
News
  • Top Stories
  • Public Reporter
  • Photo Story
  • Protests & Petitions
  • GNtv
Views
  • Day's Debate
  • Columns
  • Think Tank
  • Interview
  • GNtalk
  • Backstory
GovNow
  • Parliament
  • Your MP
  • Bureaucracy
  • Judiciary
  • Policy
GovNext
  • RTI
  • eGov
  • GreenGov
  • GovPitch
Follow Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
Home › GovNow › Parliament › Govt trains gun on media over CWG uproar

Govt trains gun on media over CWG uproar

Censures CAG for "selective representation" of facts
GN Bureau | August 08 2011

Share

The government and ruling Congress on Monday trained guns on the media and the comptroller and auditor general (CAG) even as the Bharatiya Janata Party-led opposition battered them and forced the shut-down of parliament on Monday demanding Delhi chief minister Sheila Dikshit's ouster.

The government was on the backfoot after the CWG scams came to haunt it again after the CAG submitted its report. The opposition moved privileges against the sports minister Ajay Maken for trying to feed "half truths" to parliament after the leaked CAG findings cast a shadow on prime minister Manmohan Singh.

The opposition crowded the well in both the houses and did not allow them to function as it insisted on removal of Dikshit after the CAG indictment of her government for irregularities in creation of facilities for the Commonwealth Games (CWG) while the government insisted that adverse references to her role in certain contracts is "no indictment" warranting her resignation.

The BJP also moved privilege motions in both the houses against Maken for his statement last Tuesday claiming jailed Congress MP Suresh Kalmadi was made the CWG organising committee chairman by the machinations of the BJP-led NDA government and the appointment was a fait accompli for the UPA government.

Former finance minister Yashwant Sinha, who tendered the privilege notice in the lok sabha, quoted extensively from the CAG report tabled on Friday to nail Maken for revealing some facts and suppressing others. His other motion was to suspend question hour and immediately discuss the CAG findings.

Congress spokesman Manish Tewari, however, chose to question the CAG itself for overstepping its role as the financial watchdog under Article 149 and the 1971 CAG Act in commenting upon the process of appointment and trying to implicate the prime minister's office (PMO) under Manmohan Singh over Kalmadi's appointment.

He wondered whether it is "intentional omission or oversight" or choosing to overlook two events on the part of the CAG in selectively referring to documents to fault the PMO on Kalmadi's appointment. The events he referred to had taken place in September and December 2003 during the NDA regime with the cabinet approving the host city contract and the Delhi government, the centre and Kalmadi signing the contract.

There was pandemonium in both the houses right from the start, with the opposition members crowding in the well demanding Sheila Dikshit's head. The members in the well even before the Deputy Speaker took the chair at noon after one adjournment and he was forced to adjourn for the day after letting papers laid amid pandemonium. The same scenario was witnessed in the rajya sabha that gave a miss to the question hour and then adjourned for the day.

Even while confrontation between the government and the BJP escalated, an exercise was on between them to save the truce they entered only last week to allow parliament to function and clear the financial business like insurance and banking bills as also laws on new direct and indirect taxes that are hanging fire. Sinha said an offer has come from the government but refused to share it with the media until the NDA takes a view on it. "We are interested in debates and functioning of parliament and not deadlock," he said.

Soni, Sibal and Salman: The government later chose to go into a media bashing drive at a press conference addressed jointly by information and broadcasting minister Ambika Soni, HRD minister Kapil Sibal and law minister Salman Khurshid, particularly hitting at the electronic media going overboard and pleading to stop flaring up issues with false claims and without proofs. The TV media is concocting facts for the sake of their TRP to attract more advertisements, Soni alleged.

Sibal said one-sided reporting of events is dangerous for democracy and wanted the media to look for a self-regulatory mechanism and to stop sensationalising sensitive legislative and executive processes. Salman said the government was not shying away from discussing the CAG report, but there is a procedure that first the PAC examines it and then parliament discusses it.

All three insisted that nobody in "high office", be it the PM or Sheila Dikshit, have been indicted in the CAG report to justify the way the BJP is demanding action. The government will take a stand only after the PAC has examined the report and it cannot be made to jump the gun, they insisted. "There is no indictment of anyone in the high office, leave aside that of Sheila Dikshit," Soni and Sibal affirmed, pointing out that adverse references in the report do not constitute any indictment.

Congress spokesman Tewari at a separate press conference chided the BJP that after shedding blood in Karnataka, it is trying to draw blood in Delhi and not understanding that the lokayukta report against its then chief minister B S Yeddyurappa and the CAG's CWG report are altogether different.

"It is the function of the PAC to examine the CAG reports and if the CAG reports are to be taken on their face value for the government to take action, the BJP will have to answer why it did not act against its chief ministers in Uttarakhand and Gujarat despite the CAG censures," Tewari affirmed.

The CAG had unearthed misappropriation of funds to the tune of Rs 44 crores in the Maha Kumbh by the "Hindutva" party in power in Uttarakhand while Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi blocked the legislative process of submission of the PAC report for the past many years after it found weight in the CAG establishing corruption to the tune of Rs 500 crores in the state government's Sujlam, Suflam programme. The CAG also indicted his government for huge losses causes to the Gujarat electricity corporation, the Congress spokesman pointed out.

Related stories

Stories you might like

Kill Bill: Discretion in R&R will undo land acquisition law
Parliament adjourned until noon over CAG report
Par nod to Copyright Act amendments
JPC probe sought into alleged scam in coal block allocation
NREGS not reaching the needy: panel

More stories in this section

BJP, govt clash in LS over Karnataka drought
'India becomes largest importer of arms'
BJP slams govt on unilateral cotton export ban
Comments posted as an unregistered user will need to be approved by an editor. If you would like to post comments without delay, please register / login.
Comments : 1
View:
Dinesh58's picture
Dinesh58 (not verified)

Why only Maken and Sheila Dikshit? But every Congress spokesperson like Abhishek Manu Sanghvi, Manish Tiwari, Jayanthi Natarajan including Manmohan, PC, Sibal etc who uses their knowledge of the law to Cheat the Country must resign for cover up of the loot. Seems every ministry has become the private looting business of tax-payers money. UP CM Mayawati emulates her neighbour very well when it comes to scams and receiving cuts. They need to be arrested and send to TIHAR.

9 months 1 week ago
  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Input format
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters (without spaces) shown in the image.

In This Section

  • Most Emailed
  • Most Popular
  • Most Commented
  • Cong MPs from Telangana step up pressure on C...
  • Central staff will have only 14 holidays in 2...
  • 43 top bureaucrats retire this year...
  • Lalu no financial wizard: White Paper...
2G anna hazare Bihar BJP CBI china congress corruption Delhi DoT e-governance facebook Gujarat High Court India jairam ramesh Kapil Sibal Karnataka Maharashtra Manmohan Singh Mumbai parliament P Chidambaram Pranab Mukherjee prime minister rajya sabha RTI supreme court US Uttar Pradesh
more tags
News
  • Top Stories
  • Public Reporter
  • Photo Story
  • Protests & Petitions
  • GNtv
Views
  • Day's Debate
  • Columns
  • Think Tank
  • Interview
  • GNtalk
  • Backstory
GovNow
  • Parliament
  • Your MP
  • Bureaucracy
  • Judiciary
  • Policy
GovNext
  • RTI
  • eGov
  • GreenGov
  • GovPitch
Follow Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
Copyright ©2010 Governance Now
  • Copyright Info
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Help
  • Advertise with us
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
Developed by LDI